-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
InFAMOUS [Mafia] [OT] No Good Karma...
- Thread starter melonrabbit
- Start date
Claiming on D2 has gotta be the most un-cabot thing I've ever seen while playing with cabot.
have you been lurking here waiting for the shitpost
Kyan already has nothing in his favour.cause why not lover. Scum aint gonna hit me, it's town only.
You lynch me you get your flip and know Kyan has nothing in his favour right now and CCS is still alive for you to have a fun time with.
Can I vote again?
Yeah this is completely an attempt to get out ahead of this.Commuter is easy scum claim.
But why claim so early as scum.
Unless he knows we'd think that.
Ugh
cause why not lover. Scum aint gonna hit me, it's town only.
You lynch me you get your flip and know Kyan has nothing in his favour right now and CCS is still alive for you to have a fun time with.
Two kills existing still gives a bit of credence to kyan. He certainty wasn't full on town just from ccs claim already.
Don't think this gave us really any benefit daaaaawg.
Guess it's par for the course for our PRs this game though.
If you are telling the truth.
If town loses it will have to do with the cluster fuck of roles dying day and night one. Not trusting the witch.sure, I think I've given enough material for you to work with, the other KP might take a shot at me, but i doubt scum will.
I really didn't think keeping CCS alive would happen, because gafia has been fucked by neutrals so many times. But oh well.
If town loses it will have to do with the cluster fuck of roles dying day and night one. Not trusting the witch.
seems weird to be making excuses already.
Well when you are throwing a fit about us having the audacity to not immediately lynch ccs, and we are in a fucking sticky wicket already, it's just stating facts. Not excuses.seems weird to be making excuses already.
Ya ninny
Disagree. This doesn't exist in a vacuum. We are in a tough spot already as town.Not voting CCS as town isn't good. Like it's sort of playing against wincon levels of not good. It should be shocking if even 1 person doesn't vote CCS today.
moderately confused
explain to me the point of this claim
The talk of almost no PRs remaining was annoying to me, CCS was being discussed as being kept alive when he can fuck about with PRs as well as scum.
Also dramatic claim, its rare for me. It's usually just drunk claim.
OceanicAir
Member
Not voting CCS as town isn't good. Like it's sort of playing against wincon levels of not good. It should be shocking if even 1 person doesn't vote CCS today.
Well Kawl isn't sooooooooo...
And I'm pretty sure that our wincon involves removing threats to town, which would be actual killing roles which doesn't seem to include CCS as far as I see.
No we're not. There's still like 20 people alive and 1 of them is almost certainly an investigator.Disagree. This doesn't exist in a vacuum. We are in a tough spot already as town.
The talk of almost no PRs remaining was annoying to me, CCS was being discussed as being kept alive when he can fuck about with PRs as well as scum.
Also dramatic claim, its rare for me. It's usually just drunk claim.
that seems like a bad reason to claim
that seems like a bad reason to claim
well nobody's perfect.
well nobody's perfect.
is true, is true.
We already had a day cop and a ic to start. I wouldn't be surprised if that was it for investigative roles and that scum have no god father or anything like that to counteract them.No we're not. There's still like 20 people alive and 1 of them is almost certainly an investigator.
2 kills a night and lacking our doctor and our town vig seems a rough spot to me.
A vanilla 21 person game has 2 copsWe already had a day cop and a ic to start. I wouldn't be surprised if that was it for investigative roles and that scum have no god father or anything like that to counteract them.
2 kills a night and lacking our doctor and our town vig seems a rough spot to me.
A vanilla 21 person game has 2 cops
*BLANKET ASSUMPTION ABOUT GAME ROLE DISTRIBUTION GOES HERE*
today in if i fucking designed this game
Easy. No cops 4 you
?*BLANKET ASSUMPTION ABOUT GAME ROLE DISTRIBUTION GOES HERE*
Easy. No cops 4 you
let me tell you, i have had some ideas
A vanilla 21 person game has 2 cops
[plus the one about Witch winning with scum]A vanilla 21 person game also starts with a n0 peek
Feels like all your game design assumptions are based on a different Mafia site.
Pretty certain. It feels right with how he played.So kawl are you certain CCS is neutral
Pretty certain. It feels right with how he played.
Ironclad stuff.
I'm convinced
Do you think it's more likely that there are no remaining investigators? Because I would be surprised if someone thought this but maybe it's me that's wrong.[plus the one about Witch winning with scum]
Feels like all your game design assumptions are based on a different Mafia site.
We only had a one shot suicide cop so far right? Yeah there is probably at least one more investigative role of some kind.Do you think it's more likely that there are no remaining investigators? Because I would be surprised if someone thought this but maybe it's me that's wrong.
We only had a one shot suicide cop so far right? Yeah there is probably at least one more investigative role of some kind.
Oh so you think there still could be help but you're alright with throwing his results into question all the same.
Yes?Oh so you think there still could be help but you're alright with throwing his results into question all the same.
If CCS targets them then they'll know it, it's not like we could end up running on false info without knowing it.
Far more likely for him to hit scum than 1 town investigator though. And far more potentially damaging for the person targeted.
Or her, my apologies.
Kawl says we're in bad shape but I lean on bats side, we've lost prs but this game isn't made on prs it's made on discussion and investigation. CCS is a wedge in the discussions and investigation, and potentially a wedge for remaining prs.
He probably is neutral but there's still a chance he's scum. He has no reason to be honest at any point. That itself is dangerous to any pr out there.
Is it dangerous to scum? Sure. But majority of the game is town so it's more likely to hurt us than scum.
I don't know what the second killing power is but CCS is still a factor in that I'd he remains alive.
We can't definitively solve things with CCS around
Kawl says we're in bad shape but I lean on bats side, we've lost prs but this game isn't made on prs it's made on discussion and investigation. CCS is a wedge in the discussions and investigation, and potentially a wedge for remaining prs.
He probably is neutral but there's still a chance he's scum. He has no reason to be honest at any point. That itself is dangerous to any pr out there.
Is it dangerous to scum? Sure. But majority of the game is town so it's more likely to hurt us than scum.
I don't know what the second killing power is but CCS is still a factor in that I'd he remains alive.
We can't definitively solve things with CCS around
What is the bolded, lover?Or her, my apologies.
Kawl says we're in bad shape but I lean on bats side, we've lost prs but this game isn't made on prs it's made on discussion and investigation. CCS is a wedge in the discussions and investigation, and potentially a wedge for remaining prs.
He probably is neutral but there's still a chance he's scum. He has no reason to be honest at any point. That itself is dangerous to any pr out there.
Is it dangerous to scum? Sure. But majority of the game is town so it's more likely to hurt us than scum.
I don't know what the second killing power is but CCS is still a factor in that I'd he remains alive.
We can't definitively solve things with CCS around
We can solve things because the possessed get a notification.
What is the bolded, lover?
We can solve things because the possessed get a notification.
Do we know if everyone gets a possessed notification, or is it people with abilities?
We find that out eventually but essentially requires soft claims.
We don't know for sure but it seems weird to assume otherwise.Do we know if everyone gets a possessed notification, or is it people with abilities?
We find that out eventually but essentially requires soft claims.
It will become apparent pretty quickly either way.
Games may not be built completely on roles, but roles are built to be roughly equal to each other in terms of power. We've lost quite a few powers already, meaning scum is running around both unfettered and probably with some shit still in the chamber. So we are down.Or her, my apologies.
Kawl says we're in bad shape but I lean on bats side, we've lost prs but this game isn't made on prs it's made on discussion and investigation. CCS is a wedge in the discussions and investigation, and potentially a wedge for remaining prs.
He probably is neutral but there's still a chance he's scum. He has no reason to be honest at any point. That itself is dangerous to any pr out there.
Is it dangerous to scum? Sure. But majority of the game is town so it's more likely to hurt us than scum.
I don't know what the second killing power is but CCS is still a factor in that I'd he remains alive.
We can't definitively solve things with CCS around
Well Kawl isn't sooooooooo...
And I'm pretty sure that our wincon involves removing threats to town, which would be actual killing roles which doesn't seem to include CCS as far as I see.
Again I'd like to raise I'm uncomfortable with people assuming that CCS is telling the whole truth. We don't know what CCS is apart from claiming neutral. Which may be true, but you won't be claiming scum now will you
Games may not be built completely on roles, but roles are built to be roughly equal to each other in terms of power. We've lost quite a few powers already, meaning scum is running around both unfettered and probably with some shit still in the chamber. So we are down.
We're down but we're in no position to think that rolling the dice as you say is the only desirable option.
Blargonaut
Banned
hey, I think someone's trying to frame me as Timeaisis' killer
good thing you all have terrible memories and/or deductive capabilities
good thing you all have terrible memories and/or deductive capabilities
Blargonaut
Banned
bats what happened to your N0 item
Blargonaut
Banned
I bet Kawl is a Veteran and AbsolutBro died protecting him
Mafia killed Timeaisis because they feared the Doctor. Since bats and Kawl aren't dead, safe to say there aren't any Strong peeps amongst us
Mafia killed Timeaisis because they feared the Doctor. Since bats and Kawl aren't dead, safe to say there aren't any Strong peeps amongst us