-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
InFAMOUS [Mafia] [OT] No Good Karma...
- Thread starter melonrabbit
- Start date
YesNOnoNOYes
Member
DAY 3 CURRENT VOTE TALLY:
cabot (2)
Blargonaut 1733
Kyanrute 1747
Bronx-Man (1)
cabot 1700
Ri'Orius (1)
Kalor 1699
isaacnukem (1)
WaffleTaco 1724
No active vote for Day 3: *Splinter, Bronx-Man, Flame_AC, isaacnukem, Kawl_USC, Lone_Prodigy, OceanicAir, Ri'Orius, SkyOdin, Swamped, Zeusy, Zippedpinhead
Day 3 Postcount: *Splinter 2, Blargonaut 11, Bronx-Man 1, cabot 5, Flame_AC 2, isaacnukem 5, Kalor 4, Kawl_USC 0, Kyanrute 6, Lone_Prodigy 2, OceanicAir 1, Ri'Orius 1, SkyOdin 3, Swamped 1, WaffleTaco 5, Zeusy 1, Zippedpinhead 1
Day 3 ends:
Automated vote tally here
9 votes for majority
cabot (2)
Blargonaut 1733
Kyanrute 1747
Bronx-Man (1)
cabot 1700
Ri'Orius (1)
Kalor 1699
isaacnukem (1)
WaffleTaco 1724
No active vote for Day 3: *Splinter, Bronx-Man, Flame_AC, isaacnukem, Kawl_USC, Lone_Prodigy, OceanicAir, Ri'Orius, SkyOdin, Swamped, Zeusy, Zippedpinhead
Day 3 Postcount: *Splinter 2, Blargonaut 11, Bronx-Man 1, cabot 5, Flame_AC 2, isaacnukem 5, Kalor 4, Kawl_USC 0, Kyanrute 6, Lone_Prodigy 2, OceanicAir 1, Ri'Orius 1, SkyOdin 3, Swamped 1, WaffleTaco 5, Zeusy 1, Zippedpinhead 1
Day 3 ends:
Automated vote tally here
9 votes for majority
I would think ol' Cabbie would have more honor than that
I don't regret the CCS lynch but you can't deny scum benefitted from it. I still thought there was a chance he was scum. But alas not anymore.
Scum knew CCS was likely telling the truth. I strongly believe multiple scum were on that wagon.
It's fairly obvious they are confident of lynching me.
OK anyone saying I'm stepping back from the lynch is pushing a lie.
I said I made my case and I'm not arguing against it, then I said the flip benefitted scum because it was exactly as CCS said.
I also said I would never have trusted CCS and he was very certain to try and kill me last night.
That's not a town move. I know that.
I said I made my case and I'm not arguing against it, then I said the flip benefitted scum because it was exactly as CCS said.
I also said I would never have trusted CCS and he was very certain to try and kill me last night.
That's not a town move. I know that.
Neither of the things you describe is something only a scum does
This is bad.
I was only thinking of the possibility of the second killing party trying to get me.
There's no way scum was killing me after day 2
Un-fucking-believable
Thanks Ri I wasn't done Reacting yet.
The hardest, but why do you think scum would kill him? He's a very likely lynch candidate and (if town) possibly untargetable, he'd by my absolute last choice of NK.
Exactly this. He was essentially ordinary and guaranteed to die sooner or later. Sooner is better than later for giving PR cover.
If you think this changr of heart will get me off your case you have sorely misjudged the situation.
I'm sorry I know this is retreading old ground but I can't read this post and not correct it.
Lover how does that conflict my case yesterday? The post flip revealed yes, scum would've wanted thks role out ASAP.
Nothing of my case to. Kill CCS is affected by this revelation
I'm just being clear that seeing the flip and understanding scums need to rid CCS is not the same as admitting killing CCS was a mistake.
I expect to die today. I'm not as worried about it now since we only had one NK.
Your case yesterday was all about not being able to trust neutrals and neutrals have screwed town over in the past blah blah blah.
"He could also be scum" was an afterthought. A possibility that you never seemed to find particularly likely. I'm pretty sure you only mentioned it after I brought it up as being the only way I'd consider voting for CCS.
Alright.
No one bought that theory. Worst frame job ever
I'd bet there are multiple scum in Zipped, SkyOdin, Flame and Ri'orious.
Sky has a lot of sheeped scumreads on him, which gives me some pause there. Ri'orious can have half a town point if you flip scum, I guess. I can't remember anything that makes me feel good about Zipped or Flame.
LP has made a couple of ok observations but nothing that helps me read him. At this rate he's going to be on my scumlist just by process of elimination. His contempt for the post limit makes me want to lynch him regardless of alignment.
Kyan I trust but don't remember why. Hmm.
I feel like Sky isn't the only one with sheeped scumreads on them. If I had to pick 2 scum out of your list of 4, I'd say Zipped and Ri'orious.
I've been thinking back on Zipped (as I seem to always scumread him) and I can't remember anything. Feels like he's been less of a presence than usual this game. I think he's my first choice of the four.
I'm off to the Edinburgh Fringe today so I will probably be out for the entire day.
In that case, I'd like a quick and dirty reads list out in case I am turbo'd.
Strong scum
09. [m] Bronx-Man EST
03. [m] Ri'Orius PST
Lean scum
06. [m] Kyanrute - GMT+2
19. [m] isaacnukem - UTC+8
21. [m] Flame_AC EST
????
13. [m] Blargonaut GMT
17. [m] *Splinter GMT
20. [m] Zippedpinhead EST
05. [m] TheGoddamn - UTC+8 [f] Swamped
10. [m] SkyOdin PST
Lean Town
02. [m] Zeusy - New PST
16. [m] Lone_Prodigy PST
Strong Town
01. [f] WaffleTaco - New CST
22. [m] Kalor BST
04. [m] OceanicAir CST
In that case, I'd like a quick and dirty reads list out in case I am turbo'd.
Strong scum
09. [m] Bronx-Man EST
03. [m] Ri'Orius PST
Lean scum
06. [m] Kyanrute - GMT+2
19. [m] isaacnukem - UTC+8
21. [m] Flame_AC EST
????
13. [m] Blargonaut GMT
17. [m] *Splinter GMT
20. [m] Zippedpinhead EST
05. [m] TheGoddamn - UTC+8 [f] Swamped
10. [m] SkyOdin PST
Lean Town
02. [m] Zeusy - New PST
16. [m] Lone_Prodigy PST
Strong Town
01. [f] WaffleTaco - New CST
22. [m] Kalor BST
04. [m] OceanicAir CST
isaacnukem
Member
I'd be down for a Zippedpinhead lynch.
Why is SkyOdin null, I thought you were scumreading him? Or am I remembering wrong?
How is Kalor strong town?
isaacnukem
Member
Because I'm leaning scum on him.
isaacnukem
Member
That's one broken radar
Like I said yesterday, I did not get the point of cabot's play. I called the OG claim a joke (to myself) the moment I saw it, but since the point of it was, I thought, to obfuscate whether or not he could commute on n2, I said nothing. Timing of the claim was off and all, but I wanted to see how he'd play the presumed gambit forward.
Then he claims the expected, the odd-night commuter and that kinda screws with my original assumption. Why clarify when you can be killed? Then I changed to the silly idea that he is actually a even-night commuter and is trying to bait a kill so it'd miss. So I tamed my public suspicion towards cabot when commenting on it, to make him look more of a lucrative target.
So that was my line of thought before the kill. cabot, I don't suppose the you have a better explanation for the claim today than yesterday? Cuz right now all I see that you claim a commuter when I was redirected to you. That seems extremely reactionary to me.
Blargonaut
Banned
I believed it because no one I've ever encountered in GAFia has the stones to lie about their Role like I do
Everyone tells the truth here
seriously, go back and check
No liars
Blargonaut
Banned
but you did
Saying that I've consistently avoided making arguments is wrong. I opened the day as the first one to vote with reasoning attached to it. There's been times where I've said something and didn't have examples but some reads are going to be based on gut. Especially in your case where I voted for you on day 2. Also I've mostly been playing on mobile so looking up other people's posts is more of a hassle. I'm not sticking with the vote on you today but that's because I think ri'orius is more likely to be scum.
Cabot is someone I go back and forth on. When they claimed commuter I considered that they were scum but now their posts today have me leaning town. The way that they handled their claim feels like something town would do as well. OA is someone that I need to look at again because I don't remember what I thought about them yesterday.
I only posted that bad spot post because I was bothered by how the day ended. Looking at it now it does seem Ominous.
Blargonaut
Banned
yeah I believe Kalor
UNVOTE: cabot
How about Ri'Orious
UNVOTE: cabot
How about Ri'Orious
Blargonaut
Banned
yes Zeusy, my reputation precedes me and don't you ever forget it
Blargonaut
Banned
This Mafia feels like they've got at least 1 or 2 "ideas" people, going by their target selections so far. But shallow-type, predictable ideas; avoiding bets & Kawl N1 to kill... Timeaisis? Then offing betsnacks?
By-the-book weakling scum. Afraid to gun for the real contributors OR they need that volume to keep their low-activity rank-and-file in play.
We're dealing with a team of casuals here. I'd say 5; 3 quiet ones with 2 more knowledgeable leaders.
Absbro didn't die by scum, he was likely killed by a Town-interest party N1, as he was D1's 2nd-most scum-read. Or else he died protecting Kawl, set off a Kawlveteran trap.
And FWIW, I think that cabot Role-claimed erratically as he did, because he's been leading the scum team by-the-book thus far and this is his wilder way of fun-compensating for his boring scum tactics. "Work hard, play hard" so to speak
By-the-book weakling scum. Afraid to gun for the real contributors OR they need that volume to keep their low-activity rank-and-file in play.
We're dealing with a team of casuals here. I'd say 5; 3 quiet ones with 2 more knowledgeable leaders.
Absbro didn't die by scum, he was likely killed by a Town-interest party N1, as he was D1's 2nd-most scum-read. Or else he died protecting Kawl, set off a Kawlveteran trap.
And FWIW, I think that cabot Role-claimed erratically as he did, because he's been leading the scum team by-the-book thus far and this is his wilder way of fun-compensating for his boring scum tactics. "Work hard, play hard" so to speak
Blargonaut
Banned
w a i t
a
f u c k i n g
m i n u t e
If CCS Possessed Kyanrute N1, and we got 2 dead N1
I think CCS lied about redirecting Kyan to cabot
I think CCS sent Kyan to Absbro N1; CCS thinking he was helping Town by moving against D1's 2nd-most scum-read, Absbro... but when Absbro died and turned out to be our Doctor, Neutral CCS balked and lied that he redirected to cabot, to save face
Kyan must have been scum to have been Possessed to kill Absbro
That's why Kyan wouldn't vote against cabot Yesterday, because they're scum-mates
CCS just happened to lie in a way that pinned 2 scum to the pressure; straight-up revealed Kyan to be scum, and got cabot to Role-claim as (Odd-Night) Commuter defensively!
shit
VOTE: Kyanrute
a
f u c k i n g
m i n u t e
If CCS Possessed Kyanrute N1, and we got 2 dead N1
I think CCS lied about redirecting Kyan to cabot
I think CCS sent Kyan to Absbro N1; CCS thinking he was helping Town by moving against D1's 2nd-most scum-read, Absbro... but when Absbro died and turned out to be our Doctor, Neutral CCS balked and lied that he redirected to cabot, to save face
Kyan must have been scum to have been Possessed to kill Absbro
That's why Kyan wouldn't vote against cabot Yesterday, because they're scum-mates
CCS just happened to lie in a way that pinned 2 scum to the pressure; straight-up revealed Kyan to be scum, and got cabot to Role-claim as (Odd-Night) Commuter defensively!
shit
VOTE: Kyanrute
Blargonaut
Banned
SkyOdin
Ri'Orious
cabot
Kyanrute
Zippedpinhead
That's Mafia
Ri'Orious
cabot
Kyanrute
Zippedpinhead
That's Mafia
Blargonaut
Banned
and CCS had motive to lie to Town and not inform us of his real redirection end-target in Absbro, not cabot; just to spite us, because of the way Town treated him with lack of alternatives
Or else *Splinter is Mafia instead of cabot...
Or else *Splinter is Mafia instead of cabot...
WaffleTaco
Wants to outlaw technological innovation.
Your avatar is petty much how I feel after reading that lol. Like you make this case, and at the last second you mention how Splinter could be scum.
Thoughts on D1
Well, it makes sense that Batsnacks died tonight, he was the innocent child. Maybe scum feared if they targeted him earlier there would be a doctor on him? Maybe they thought the time was ripe given the number of PRs who have died so far, including the doctor.
I've only played one other game with Isaac so it's unfair for me to generalize, but he seems uncharacteristically enthusiastic so far (still reading D1, maybe things have changed now, will get there).
Kawl bringing attention to one of his own scumtells because he is maybe acting actively against it?
Ahhh, I missed Kyan's quality shit posts (is that an oxymoron?)
Cabot's first point is really stretching it. Trying to create artificial dirt on AB? Well, we now know that AB was town.
OOOO interesting move from acohrs! So Kawl is confirmed town too!
AB seems to be the subject of a lot of shade already...from Splinter and Kyan too.
Sky low-key trying to protect Kyan?
So far, Splinter is giving me town vibes, and I think I'm fairly good at reading him.
Some back-and-forth between Cabot and CCS, which doesn't read like scum vs scum to me. Turns out CCS was a neutral.
So far not feeling Flame's posts. Why wait on the vote? Why Bronx in the first place? The only noteworthy thing he had done was back-and-forth with Blarg, and Flame doesn't mention Blarg at all.
Bronx's Dusk vote literally comes out of nowhere. Such blatant bandwagonning can't be a scum move right?
I died XD
Not feeling great about the timing or reasoning behind this vote. Kyan also voted a few posts prior but prior to that he was toying with the idea, saying he had some gut feelz about Flame.
So, Dusk gets voted out, the vigilante. I didn't even think his posts were that bad lol. As a replacement player, I love how I can come in and take the moral high ground
AB was runner up. I know that he and Time died N1. AB would have been a good Vig target, but the vig was dead at this point.
Ugh I think I'll have much better reads on players after reading D2. Playing catch up is tougher than I thought.
Well, it makes sense that Batsnacks died tonight, he was the innocent child. Maybe scum feared if they targeted him earlier there would be a doctor on him? Maybe they thought the time was ripe given the number of PRs who have died so far, including the doctor.
I've only played one other game with Isaac so it's unfair for me to generalize, but he seems uncharacteristically enthusiastic so far (still reading D1, maybe things have changed now, will get there).
Kawl bringing attention to one of his own scumtells because he is maybe acting actively against it?
Ahhh, I missed Kyan's quality shit posts (is that an oxymoron?)
Cabot's first point is really stretching it. Trying to create artificial dirt on AB? Well, we now know that AB was town.
OOOO interesting move from acohrs! So Kawl is confirmed town too!
AB seems to be the subject of a lot of shade already...from Splinter and Kyan too.
Sky low-key trying to protect Kyan?
So far, Splinter is giving me town vibes, and I think I'm fairly good at reading him.
Some back-and-forth between Cabot and CCS, which doesn't read like scum vs scum to me. Turns out CCS was a neutral.
So far not feeling Flame's posts. Why wait on the vote? Why Bronx in the first place? The only noteworthy thing he had done was back-and-forth with Blarg, and Flame doesn't mention Blarg at all.
Bronx's Dusk vote literally comes out of nowhere. Such blatant bandwagonning can't be a scum move right?
possibly BUT LOOK AT THE DASHES, CCS
WHY would these 8 particular players have regular dashes between their names and their timezones, when everyone else has em dashes there?
Especially with acohrs, a now-confirmed Power Role, as one of the 8??
I died XD
Not feeling great about the timing or reasoning behind this vote. Kyan also voted a few posts prior but prior to that he was toying with the idea, saying he had some gut feelz about Flame.
So, Dusk gets voted out, the vigilante. I didn't even think his posts were that bad lol. As a replacement player, I love how I can come in and take the moral high ground
AB was runner up. I know that he and Time died N1. AB would have been a good Vig target, but the vig was dead at this point.Ugh I think I'll have much better reads on players after reading D2. Playing catch up is tougher than I thought.
naaah