Is an tablet a good replacment for an laptop?

Status
Not open for further replies.

DR2K

Banned
Really thinking about getting one. I use my laptop for routine things, movies, music, internet, etc. . . the occasional word, but that's about it. Are Ipads(or any tablet) more suplimental to a laptob or can they totally replace it?
 
For those uses, yes. Without question.

If you don't need to do heavy computing or serious deep document work then a tablet would meet your needs. I use my iPad 95% of the time, barely need to touch my MacBook Pro anymore. I'd honestly say the iPad is my favorite computer I have ever used in the past 20+ years I been using computers.

I have a windows dell laptop for my needs at work, but at home it's all iPad all the time.
 
If that's all you're doing then sure, they're pretty good. Buy some external speakers though, tablet speakers aren't great.
 
I would say more supplemental. I would be incredibly annoyed at doing half the tasks that I do on a laptop on a touch screen. Nothing replaces a good laptop at this moment IMO.
 
I'd think not having a proper keyboard would be the biggest issue.


Also, a tablet. A tablet.

apple-ipad-keyboard.jpg

zagg_zaggfolio_ipad_2_keyboard_case_1.jpg

Logitech-Keyboard-Case-For-Apple-iPad-2-Turns-Your-Tablet-Into-A-MacBook-Air.png


Plenty of options, I am using a zaggfolio keyboard on my iPad 2 as I post this.
 
I'd think not having a proper keyboard would be the biggest issue.


Also, a tablet. A tablet.

I picked up a wireless (Targus) bluetooth keyboard to go with my iPad. I did find typing on the touch screen to be problematic, especially posting on GAF.
 
Really thinking about getting one. I use my laptop for routine things, movies, music, internet, etc. . . the occasional word, but that's about it. Are Ipads(or any tablet) more suplimental to a laptob or can they totally replace it?

You've basically described an ideal tablet user. Unless you mean downloading movies and music in a non-iTunes way, and in that case, no, stick with a laptop.

Wait one month for the iPad 3 if you simply mean listening and watching to movies you get on a desktop or laptop and would transfer over...
 
I picked up a wireless (Targus) bluetooth keyboard to go with my iPad. I did find typing on the touch screen to be problematic, especially posting on GAF.

With a keyboard it's fantastic. Swiping a screen is way more enjoyable than a mouse, keyboard makes all typing easy and for watching media undocking it and just holding a screen in your hands is unbeatable for personal media.

For someone like him with his needs I don't see why he wouldn't go with a tablet over a laptop.
 
apple-ipad-keyboard.jpg

zagg_zaggfolio_ipad_2_keyboard_case_1.jpg

Logitech-Keyboard-Case-For-Apple-iPad-2-Turns-Your-Tablet-Into-A-MacBook-Air.png


Plenty of options, I am using a zaggfolio keyboard on my iPad 2 as I post this.
eh, half of the appeal of typing on a laptop is laying at weird angles on couches etc. Though it would be fine for desk use, obviously.

OT: tablets are great for lazy internet browsing and such. I don't think I would toss my macbook pro yet, the power isn't quite there. But further down the road, maybe.
 
You've basically described an ideal tablet user. Unless you mean downloading movies and music in a non-iTunes way, and in that case, no, stick with a laptop.

Well, not just downloading movies. If he means streaming movies like on Netflix, Hulu+ , HBO Go, or YouTube iPad is fantastic at that.
 
Was good enough for me to ditch my laptop for, but then I've a beefy desktop and the laptop only saw very minor use anyway.

I use my ipad daily, for media streaming (via Air Video), pdf/ebook reading and web browsing from the couch or bed, for anything else I use my desktop PC.

Well, not just downloading movies. If he means streaming movies like on Netflix, Hulu+ , or YouTube iPad is fantastic at that.

Or just streaming from PC to tablet too, hell I have both Air Video for standard streaming, a lightweight Web server running on my desktop to grab anything else that I want off it, and a RDP client (iTap RDP) to remote control the PC so I don't even need to get out of bed when I'm finished at night, just log on with the ipad to it via RDP and shutdown from bed XD
 
If you are a student: absolutely not
If you need productivity for work: absolutely not
If you only care about internet and multimedia and nothing else: feasible

With that said, a tablet is more a supplement to a computer and at present it cannot replace it.
 
You've basically described an ideal tablet user. Unless you mean downloading movies and music in a non-iTunes way, and in that case, no, stick with a laptop.

Wait one month for the iPad 3 if you simply mean listening and watching to movies you get on a desktop or laptop and would transfer over...

I know a tablet can do all those things, I just don't know how effecient they are or how much of a change it'll be for them.
 
If you are a student: absolutely not
If you need productivity for work: absolutely not
If you only care about internet and multimedia and nothing else: feasible

With that said, a tablet is more a supplement to a computer and at present it cannot replace it.

All the stuff he lists in the original topic fit that third criteria, and I'd say its a bit more than feasible. It's more enjoyable I'd say for most to watch movies and browse the internet on a tablet than a laptop

I know a tablet can do all those things, I just don't know how effecient they are or how much of a change it'll be for them.

iPad 2 is pretty damn speedy at streaming media and loading web pages, it's more than efficient. iPad 3 will be even better than that.
 
I wouldn't say so. Unless you do very little productive with your laptops. At best, you can write some papers and made some presentations with one. Beyond that, you'll be begging for some deeper features that tablet apps just don't offer at the moment.

Or, wait and see what these Windows 8 tablets are about.
 
I honestly can't get into the tablet love. I love the comfort of my laptop keyboard, not having to hold it always and being able to adjust the screen, the mouse is right by the keyboard which is more natural than touching the screen sometimes, multitasking is easier, I just love the freedom.
 
It depends on what you use your laptop for.

If you just use it for mostly light tasks: web-browsing, music, videos, a little light word editing; than hell yeah an iPad could be a laptop replacement.
 
ipad 1, original model is limited to 720p via the HDMI cable, no idea about the ipad 2.
 
apple-ipad-keyboard.jpg

zagg_zaggfolio_ipad_2_keyboard_case_1.jpg

Logitech-Keyboard-Case-For-Apple-iPad-2-Turns-Your-Tablet-Into-A-MacBook-Air.png


Plenty of options, I am using a zaggfolio keyboard on my iPad 2 as I post this.

So basically you turned your tablet into a laptop while making it more cumbersome because of multiple parts.

Tablets are a fantastic adjunct. They aren't replacements for laptops/desktops yet.
 
Yeah, I do the same stuff and I rarely use anything other than iPad. I've gone a month on iPad alone and love it. Wait a month or two for iPad 3.
 
Tablet Thread? Tablet Thread.

Iv been looking at picking a tablet up as a ... gadget (for lack of a better term) for sometime. Until now i was deadset on a ipad but im starting to think a Windows 8 Tablet might be the way to go.

Gaming is covered with PS3/360/Wii and PC
Handheld gaming is covered with a DS+PSP (and soon a vita and possibly a 3DS)
Im running a pretty well spec'd windows pc that doubles as a HTPC (linked up to my main display and a secondary 20inch monitor) for all my media usage
Iphone 4 for a phone/media player.

Something Android would be nice but id imagine im going to get more power from a Windows 8 tablet.

Im new to tablets completely so any advice at all would be nice, Pros and cons for

Android Tablet
Ipad
Windows 8 Tablet

would be great, and some recommendations on actual models of android tablets (no real price range, nothing crazy)

If you think id be better off with a Laptop/notebook/Macbook than a tablet id appreciate the input aswell.
 
Tablet Thread? Tablet Thread.

Iv been looking at picking a tablet up as a ... gadget (for lack of a better term) for sometime. Until now i was deadset on a ipad but im starting to think a Windows 8 Tablet might be the way to go.

Gaming is covered with PS3/360/Wii and PC
Handheld gaming is covered with a DS+PSP (and soon a vita and possibly a 3DS)
Im running a pretty well spec'd windows pc that doubles as a HTPC (linked up to my main display and a secondary 20inch monitor) for all my media usage
Iphone 4 for a phone/media player.

Something Android would be nice but id imagine im going to get more power from a Windows 8 tablet.

Im new to tablets completely so any advice at all would be nice, Pros and cons for

Android Tablet
Ipad
Windows 8 Tablet

would be great, and some recommendations on actual models of android tablets (no real price range, nothing crazy)

If you think id be better off with a Laptop/notebook/Macbook than a tablet id appreciate the input aswell.

It's generally a good idea for your tablet and phone to have the same OS since there's little to no learning curve but if you're willing to mess around and learn, then it's worth it to try out everything and see what you actually want.

Windows tablets will use the same ARM processors as the Android tablets (likely Tegra 3) but there will be some tablets with x86 processors. The ones with the x86 processors will have more processing power and will be able to run normal Windows programs, the disadvantage is that you're probably looking at only a few hours of battery life while a tablet with a Tegra processor is probably going to last around 10 hours.

Android tablets can use the same apps as those made for Android phones so that's a nice thing. Also widgets.

The iPad has a very smooth, consistent experience and it'll probably feel very familiar to you. Any apps have to be remade for it though.

Those are just the general differences. Go to the stores and try out all the tablets that are in your size/price range as most of your decision will come down to how it feels to use.

Honestly, it would be best if you just wait about 6 months though. The 1080P Android and iPad tablets will be out and Windows 8 tablets should also be out by then.

lol what is this crap?

Well dual-touchscreens aren't a completely new concept. Take the Kyocera Echo:

kyocera-echo.jpg


The idea behind it is that you can simultaneously run two different apps.
 
I'd say yes, but just wait for the iPad 3. We'll be hearing something about it within a month, maybe two, but super soon either way. WAIT.

[edit] and obviously waiting is important even if you don't want an iPad 3, because you'd be able to get an iPad 2 for a lot cheaper.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom