• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Larry Wachowski publicly debuts as... Lana Wachowski

Status
Not open for further replies.
I guess I'm one of the people that just doesn't get it. I have no problem with it, it's a personal choice, but if you're born with male or female genitalia I can't help but think of you as being stuck in that gender. You can cosmetically modify your body but IMO that doesn't magically turn you into the gender you want to be. It will be interesting to see what neuroscience can tell us about this phenomenon because the plasticity of the human brain is not very well understood.

Being female means more than just looking or sounding the part; a transgender female will not menstruate or be able to give birth to a child. Until we develop artificial or replacement organs including sex organs (which may very well happen in the future for a variety of reasons) I can't consider a transgender fully transformed from one gender to the other. And because of that, I think a lot of people feel there is a deception there and that that is where a lot of the prejudice against it comes from.

There are biological women who cannot reproduce nor menstruate due to ovarian issues. Not to mention intersexed individuals who get made into women as babies or have internal testes. You might want to do some reading about just how many people at birth are a bit intersexed and have been modified to fit the gender binary society has set up.

I do not particularly care for such narrow definitions of womanhood even as a cis woman. Being a woman is not about periods and child rearing.
 

lexi

Banned
Sorry lexi, I am not familiar with your history, so if you don't mind me asking: am I correct to assume you are a trans? Are you a man before and now a woman or the other way around? Is your avatar you?

Ah, I apologize if this question is perhaps too personal.

I am trans, yes, MtF.

My avatar is not me, no :p
 

Dead Man

Member
Bans themselves are based on completely subjective means, I realize that. However, I do believe there is a very loose mantra that most bans fall under.

Edit: I agree, but what if this bigotry falls under a person's religion. I'm playing devil's advocate. For example, wouldn't subjecting a devout evangelical to concede to the more liberal viewpoints of others be a prejudice in of itself.

Bigoted against bigots? Again? And so what if it is their religion? They are still bigots. If someone has a religion that thinks human sacrifice is needed are they not still murderers if they do it? If a religion had a tenet that said Jewish people were less than human, would they not still be racists? Requiring the religious person to adopt the belief of the other would be pretty shabby, but convincing the religious person and showing them how they are wrong is not requiring anything. If someones belief is held AND it impacts others happiness negatively, it does not get to be protected. If it does not impact anyone, they can believe whatever they want.
 
I feel fortunate that I never had to struggle with gender identity. I can't imagine anything that would be more difficult and trying to experience. So when people like Lana are able to overcome and become the person they truly are I can't help but feel an immense amount of pride for them. Lana and other people like her are true symbols of both the human spirit and our ability to persevere.
 
Not off topic but a side note to this.

I don't know the truth behind this or not, maybe someone can verify? Rooster teeth brought this up recently on a podcast, and there was in interesting fact concerning the matrix era for the wachowskis.

Apparently the character switch was intended to only be female in the matrix and then male in the real world. Though after casting the actress to play switch they liked her performance they altered the script to make her a all female character. Just thought it was interesting.

Back on topic, this is great. Especially combined with the recent news of being a transgenderd man or woman (correct inoffensive term?) is no longer a mental illness. Hopefully our world will continue to let people be whom they are and express themselves as such.

I do have to agree, I don't think she made the greatest transition although I think it's just the hair mainly. The other picture of her looks like any (not attractive sorry) 40 something soccer mom, but It's still fairly obvious.

Although after moving to Los Angeles I have met many transgenderd people and some I had no idea until either they or someone else had told me. It's amazing for these people that we have the ability to truly help them make such great transformations into their true physical identities.
 

iirate

Member
Not off topic but a side note to this.

I don't know the truth behind this or not, maybe someone can verify? Rooster teeth brought this up recently on a podcast, and there was in interesting fact concerning the matrix era for the wachowskis.

Apparently the character switch was intended to only be female in the matrix and then male in the real world. Though after casting the actress to play switch they liked her performance they altered the script to make her a all female character. Just thought it was interesting.

Yep, it's true. There's a video earlier in this thread in which Switch's actress confirmed it.
 

beje

Banned
After reading this whole thread, I can't help to facepalm at how most "normal" (lol) people, when confronted with any kind of gender issue, always focus the whole discussion on SEX itself ("hurr durr penis goes in vagina") instead of taking 2 minutes to look at the whole picture (affective relationship, mental well-being or self-image to name a few). We're almost on the verge of overcoming it on homosexuality especially through the normalization of marriage equality, but there's still a lot of education to be done in the other 3 scales of that gingerbread man.
 
There are biological women who cannot reproduce nor menstruate due to ovarian issues. Not to mention intersexed individuals who get made into women as babies or have internal testes. You might want to do some reading about just how many people at birth are a bit intersexed and have been modified to fit the gender binary society has set up.

I do not particularly care for such narrow definitions of womanhood even as a cis woman. Being a woman is not about periods and child rearing.

Right ...

This reminds me of that poor athlete runner who lost all her awards because they found she had testis which increased her testosterone. She was born with her female genitalia and lived her whole life as a female and lost everything due to our societies rigid gender definitions.
 

Chuckl3s

Member
This thread...

Anyways good for her. Here is a couple of pics that haven't been posted.

3Etpk.jpg


49FnF.jpg


I'd hit it!
 

Izick

Member
Now if only we can get another good movie written and directed by them again! I want a new Matrix movie, but only if it stays more in-line with the first one. I know it can happen, and that universe seems like it's rich enough for something.
 

Platy

Member
Someone having surgury to change their body to look like something it's not just seems like an unhealthy extreme to me.

This is basicaly the biggest probelm of lack of understanding in the world regarding trans people

What chooses who we are (or the closest we have for a soul, scientificaly speaking) is our brain. Our brain tell us what we are.

So our body is seen and understood by our brains and for other people's brain.

So if someone brain's is male, than the person is male and vice versa.

So nobody is changing anything to look like something they are not.

I guess I'm one of the people that just doesn't get it. I have no problem with it, it's a personal choice, but if you're born with male or female genitalia I can't help but think of you as being stuck in that gender. You can cosmetically modify your body but IMO that doesn't magically turn you into the gender you want to be. It will be interesting to see what neuroscience can tell us about this phenomenon because the plasticity of the human brain is not very well understood.

Besides all the "I have an uncle who can't have kids and the president of my country is old enoght so she don't menstruate .. this means that they are males ? =O" that already been said, every advance towards gender diferentiation in neuroscience proves that :

Women (cis and trans, post or pre anything) have the same basic brain.

Males (including males taking drugs to lower the testosterone to treat prostate cancer) and Transmales (as in female to male) have the same basic brain.

There is a very interesting and educational video about a neuroscientist telling this, but my google fu (would that be youtube fu ? =P) fails me now ...

Were you girly looking before? And how old are you? Isn't it the older you are the harder it gets for transition to look normal.

Actualy the human body tends to androginy in 2 poins of it's life : before puberty and after menopause/andropause.

So a considerably old person has the same chances as a considerably young person.

That said, there is an old lady that lives in my grandma's street that looks EXACTLY like her

But the results are more dependant to genetics than anything else

Pics? :) I mean pre and post :)

Asking for pre pics is one of the most non polite things a person can do to a trans person. Same with asking "your real name" .... would be like asking for the boy who had a gun destroy his genital "so ... you have your penis destroyed .. can I see pics of what is left ?" ...
 

J10

Banned
When watching the Matrix films (which I do quite often) I always wonder how people born inside the system knew what they were supposed to look like - their residual self image. I guess your brain knows on some level whether or not you're male or female and where all your body parts are supposed to be, but to have their physical bodies match their virtual ones so closely was something I always thought was odd. For a while I thought maybe it happened that way through an assist by the system for the sake of maintaining order.

Looking at it through the lens of this conversation, I suppose it's the same way some of us know we're supposed to be boys or girls even though we're not always born with the "appropriate" parts. The brain just knows somehow.
 

bengraven

Member
http://blog.sfgate.com/dailydish/2012/09/05/lana-wachowski-opens-up-about-sex-change/

More info about her change. Found myself actually emotional about it. The weird "best marriage" line is kind of creepy, but actually also kind of cute in a way due to the fact that they're finding they work better now that Lana isn't "projecting her issues" onto him. Better films? Maybe.

She opens up quite a bit.

Except about her junk:

'I know that many people are dying to know if I have a surgically constructed vagina or not, but I prefer to keep this information between my wife and me.'

Word, girl. Some things are better kept in the bedroom.






Edit: removed the Daily Male link since the rag is banned. Put up the San Fran Chrono story instead, but that's missing a lot of her and her family's quotes. I don't want to post the entire story since the site is banned, despite it being an interview given in front of a group of journalists and verified - don't want to violate any TOS.

Original full story at this link if you just put in the right words: http://www.*****************/tvshow...case-family-reject-her.html?ito=feeds-newsxml
 

bengraven

Member
I thought this happened years ago.

Good for her.

They were notoriously private about it and she didn't speak on it until just recently, after her public revealing in the Cloud Atlas video. This is the first interview given as Lana about her gender identity issues.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom