-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Legend of Zelda Mafia |OT| A Lynch to the Past
- Thread starter Sawneeks
- Start date
I don't know about Pop but he does seem like something I've seen recently, PK in persona mafia, also a new player (I know acorhs isn't completely fresh new but I would still put this in the new category). Missing easy things and instead of just admitting fault and dropping it, he keeps playing the funny/incompetence card. The not unvoting thing is whatever, I feel like we always have someone early in games that makes that comment and people never chomp down on it but his reaction to being caught either lying or just not paying enough attention? Nah.
VOTE: Acorhs
Not done with Bronx yet by the way but all he will keep doing for now is talking about himself and I want to hear what he has to say about others.
Man, if you're going to lynch me, would you mind getting my name right at least...
I was copying the other person who wrote it wrong since it was the only writing of it on this page, RIP.
VOTE: Acohrs
Melon and Sophia would probably be closest thing I have to town reads right now. I'm the easiest dude to start a train on, if they were scum they would've started tunneling me by now.
Something else to add ? I mean what are your thoughts on several players calling you out acohrs ?
I do not agree with that.
Ofc one could say that would be the easiest thing to do as scum. But since this a jam packed game I doubt scum would be dumb enough to jump prematurely onto a train that did not even started to head into the light.
Eh, there was scum last game that outright said "Hey, I got a PM saying there's a scum chat. Can someone explain that to me?"
So I mean, stranger things have happened.
I'm insulted, Bronx. The only time I've ever tunneled you is when I'm town.
Give more credit to scum!Sophia.
Waiting for you to prove me wrong.
It feels like he's bouncing back and fourth between "IDGAF ¯\_(ツ
Sophia what have you got to say to the people that find you suspicious?
AbsolutBro
Member
Damnit, I meant to quote CCS's initial question in that post. That was directed at CCS, not you. Hence finishing on 'vote camo'. My bad.
So you town read them because they commented on your case without siding against you? Did I stutter when I said I wanted to hear about others and not you?
Anyone else think it's super weird that Sophia acknowledged someone who commented on my vote and not my actual vote?
Or they know you're town and are getting easy brownie points? Because when does scum start a train at the start of day one and hope it keeps the whole day? Bad logic mate.
Nothing in particular that I haven't already said. If I jumped at everyone who found me suspicious, I'd get nowhere.
Some of them (CzarTim, CCS) I don't have a particular read on. Ty4on I have a slight gut town read, if only because of past experiences.
Dude, calm down. Those are the only reads I have right now. Though acohrs is looking pretty fishy to me tbh.
If I was another player watching my actions right now, I would definitely think the same as Sophia or Kyan. I've been all over the place trying to adjust to a very fast paced game, pop mafia was much easier in that regard! However, the reason I've made those mistakes is a desire not to sit back and just coast. Why play, if not to contribute a ton and have fun! So, need to think more about my output but not to decelerate my output that much as I want to mingle!
As for being between IDGAF and trying to help, just how I want to play the game. No particular desire to play one style and haven't played enough to have a style either, so just replying how I feel in the moment.
melonrabbit
Member
And now Bronx is town reading me...
This game is going to drive me insane isn't it?
This game is going to drive me insane isn't it?
Well that's a whole lot of posts.
Lots of jawing back and forth.
Not gonna try and be a big dick town leader with all these personalities around.
After a quick read of the thread, I'd be fine voting sorian and or Sophia until the next development.
Bronx strikes me as a non issue, achors is all over the place, melon seems slightly suspicious, and fuck Cabot.
And not a single hot take. Do love the lets lynch inactives after less than 18 hours lol.
Never change gaf.
Vote: cabot
As usual busy doing stuff and drinking on the weekend so I'll be less actively involved before like Monday.
Lots of jawing back and forth.
Not gonna try and be a big dick town leader with all these personalities around.
After a quick read of the thread, I'd be fine voting sorian and or Sophia until the next development.
Bronx strikes me as a non issue, achors is all over the place, melon seems slightly suspicious, and fuck Cabot.
And not a single hot take. Do love the lets lynch inactives after less than 18 hours lol.
Never change gaf.
Vote: cabot
As usual busy doing stuff and drinking on the weekend so I'll be less actively involved before like Monday.
Acorhs seems similar to how he was in Pop to me./QUOTE]
Man we already had a whole game together! I take back calling you honorary scum member in pop mafia.
What's worse? I'm all over the place making mistakes, or I'm all over the place and still nobody can spell my surname correctly...
Acorhs seems similar to how he was in Pop to me./QUOTE]
Man we already had a whole game together! I take back calling you honorary scum member in pop mafia.
What's worse? I'm all over the place making mistakes, or I'm all over the place and still nobody can spell my surname correctly...
That's my bad man I should have taken the time to look it up but I'm on mobile which makes it hard. Acohrs. Acohrs. Acohrs. Okay trying to get it into my memory.
Yea it's a first vote which I don't really give a shit about. I'll have a serious vote by day end but for a weekend day one, that's about all your getting out of me sorry. I like mafia, not enough to take an hour plus to build a case and show shit and multi quote on mobile while I'm at a friend's place and got shit going on. Not going to apologize for that. And it does take that long for me, figuring out cases and shit doesn't really come naturally to me so I gotta bust it out through slow reading and shit. Which I'm totally all about on weekdays. /shrug
.... are you fine with it because you know me and Sorian are town?
Vote: Kawl_USC
If you're fine with it, put your vote there.
Hmmmm. Sorian is someone I'm going back and forth on.
On one hand, he took a stupid joke I made to start the day with and immediately went "Aha! A classic scumtell!" which sounds like something a (very dumb) scum member would do to start tunneling.
On the other hand, dude has been chomping at the bit just going after anyone and everyone that even might be a suspect in his eyes and it's only D1.
He seems a little too....boisterous to me to be scum, I'd say? Scum usually lurks around the shadows rather than just fire out guns blazing. Sorian reminds me a lot of how Ouro plays town if I'm being honest.
On one hand, he took a stupid joke I made to start the day with and immediately went "Aha! A classic scumtell!" which sounds like something a (very dumb) scum member would do to start tunneling.
On the other hand, dude has been chomping at the bit just going after anyone and everyone that even might be a suspect in his eyes and it's only D1.
He seems a little too....boisterous to me to be scum, I'd say? Scum usually lurks around the shadows rather than just fire out guns blazing. Sorian reminds me a lot of how Ouro plays town if I'm being honest.
But why?
The one time I played with Scum!Ty he was a bit more all over the place, versus town Ty who picks at stuff more. It's an early gut read, but one that gives me a slight town feeling from him right now.
I'm fine with it because I find both of your play styles overly centralizing for games (more so sorian) and haven't really had anything sticking out it me enough to override that thus far.
See above about final votes. I'll vote how I please until the end of day one which is all that matters when you get down to it for the first day.
This post looks very opportunistic to me. Tim questioned acohrs for his easy unvote and fran jumps on the back of it.
Can you give examples of what you mean by him picking at stuff?
It sounds very similar to being "all over the place" to be honest.
Granted I don't have much experience, but Saw as mafia in Pop was quite vocal and that worked then, no?
Damn, that's a good point.
Stuff like this:
He picks at little stuff when he's town, but he didn't do that when he was scum. It's still early tho, and meta can change, so you could be right.
I didn't have a problem with the unvote, I had a problem with the justification of the unvote. After Tim questioned acohrs about his unvote the reasons he gave sounded wrong. It was not a prod neither a push for more participation. I stated that some post later.
Good morning everyone.
Current Vote Count:
natiko (0)
sorian 244 (264)
splinter (1)
melonrabbit 245
sorian (1)
ty4on 246
sophia 323 (477)
melonrabbit (1)
bronx-man 251
sophia (2)
pop-o-matic 253
czartim 364
bronx-man (0)
sorian 264 (453)
cabot (1)
ccs 268 (377)
kawl_usc 471
magnumboy20xx (0)
acohrs 277 (388)
acohrs (1)
natiko 362 (427)
sorian 456
kawl_usc (2)
cabot 370
sophia 477
absolutbro (1)
ccs 377
kawl (1)
acohrs 409
acorhs (0)
sorian 453 (456)
Day 1 Ends in:
Current Vote Count:
natiko (0)
splinter (1)
melonrabbit 245
sorian (1)
ty4on 246
melonrabbit (1)
bronx-man 251
sophia (2)
pop-o-matic 253
czartim 364
bronx-man (0)
cabot (1)
kawl_usc 471
magnumboy20xx (0)
acohrs (1)
sorian 456
kawl_usc (2)
cabot 370
sophia 477
absolutbro (1)
ccs 377
kawl (1)
acohrs 409
acorhs (0)
Day 1 Ends in:
Good point.
Does anyone with more experience of the other players have anymore meta points about how people are playing?
You didn't answer or even address my question at all. I'm asking where your initial bullshit of Sophia and I came from. I don't need grand multi quote non sense, I just need something that actually proves you didn't just pick two high profile people at random because let's be honest, it's obvious you did.
Please use the full and correct spelling of someone's name when voting so the Vote Tool can properly see it. Thank you.
Yes, that is correct.
We are playing a game of Mafia/Werewolf. We have an OT community if you are interested in joining or learning more. :3
Yes, that is correct.
We are playing a game of Mafia/Werewolf. We have an OT community if you are interested in joining or learning more. :3
Also we both know this is a lie. The second half, the first is at least something you could conceivably believe.
Sorry...
Is it kawl or kawl_usc? Player list says kawl
Kawl_USC.
It's always someone's full username.
That was also my fault and I've updated the player list with the correct username. I apologize.
Firm disagree. I meant both parts of that statement.
You're fine to imagine I just haven't voted yet then. I don't particularly care.