-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Love Boat 2 [Mafia] |OT| Electric Boogalove
- Thread starter Burbeting
- Start date
Royal_Flush
Member
Unless there is a second silencer around, 100%. So, maybe 99.5%?
That's a thing you'll have to consider, I think. It would require quite some thinking ahead from my part, though.
I just want to point out that if you are indeed Town, that last sentence makes zero sense.
Royal_Flush
Member
I thought it would be. Because why would I think Scum would be informed what happens if Town is hit? Then I asked Burb and he gave an answer came that implied I was wrong. then Ouro knew what happens to Town PRs.I'm confused... you make it sound like your power can be used to scum hunt, but then you backtrack on it because of am ambiguous answer from Burb?;
Actually, if I thought that far ahead as Scum, I would have breadcrumbed my targets, no?
StarSketch
Banned
Wait does it mute the whole scum chat, or does scum not have a pair chat in addition to the main scum chat?
Are you even going to do anything else besides this ?
Hint: There might be a super-simple explanation as to why that is
LB1 only had a regular scum chat
This is a good question. If it mutes the whole scum chat, that means more than one pair is muted. Which means they need to figure out what to say about it.
You are a scum PR? 🤔
*headdesk*
You know, you have been all over the place on Day 3 with posts like this. I legitimately thought you were a new player by the way you've been doing things. I just checked now and you have played before. What's the deal?
Royal_Flush
Member
I'm telling you what our defense was going to be: "We can't be Scum. If we were Scum, we would never silence our own team"
Ah, ok.
This feels weird and TMI-y...
Anyway, LB1 I think gave scum everything they needed for a claim and it was deemed a game design mistake that the chat silence could be used to confirm townies (scum didn't claim) iirc.
hey_monkey
Banned
What would our win condition related to ending chats be?
The goal is to hit scum and transfer the silence to the whole scum team, which is why we targeted Ourokitty today. We thought they were scum. And I fished Schmuffin before they left and asked the replacements about their chats (including AbBro) hoping for a slip or reveal in case we were right.
Good morning everyone, how are we all doing toda-
oh
that's something to wake up to. ._.
oh
that's something to wake up to. ._.
Royal_Flush
Member
I'm going to go buy supplies for the festival now. Will be back in an hour or so. Sorry for that, but I originally wanted to go an hour ago. Stores are going to close soon.
hey_monkey
Banned
FYI: I unexpectedly got pulled into something and am semi following the thread but maybe bold something if it's for me for the next bit or so, I dunno :/
So you're still gonna leave your vote on me, after all that.
I've made weirder gambits *shrug*
Trying to make more sense of this. I'm only half awake and the most immediate thing that strikes out at me is how odd this claim is coming so late in the day. I'm aware of how it worked in LB1, but that doesn't necessarily mean it'd work the same way here.
Royal_Flush
Member
Oh fuck, the ends in one hour, not two. Well I guess I have to go shopping with my phone in hand then.
hey_monkey
Banned
I have doubts. I am looking at developments. I'm still here, just worried I might miss something (I'm teaching all week but not actively and just got pulled into more active teaching for a bit but I'm still following thread).
hey_monkey
Banned
oh have you now
I didn't play LB1 to those bringing it up so I don't know how close the role is. But we had limited shots so I assume that's different.
hey_monkey
Banned
It's possible that there's another silencer but at this point I doubt it since only our targets have reported.
I'm gonna sit with this for a minute and think. I'm curious about Ty4on now after some comments today and Trigger's half-participation here, half through chat/Ty/whatever's up there. I don't want to vote the replacements today. There's not a night kill on the line. I have doubts about Ourokitty but there are also still issues there. I am really just not sure about the best move right now.
People I'm NOT suspicious of at this moment:
Sophist
Dr. Fran
Darryl (except nin exists)
I'm gonna sit with this for a minute and think. I'm curious about Ty4on now after some comments today and Trigger's half-participation here, half through chat/Ty/whatever's up there. I don't want to vote the replacements today. There's not a night kill on the line. I have doubts about Ourokitty but there are also still issues there. I am really just not sure about the best move right now.
People I'm NOT suspicious of at this moment:
Sophist
Dr. Fran
Darryl (except nin exists)
I'm not really sure what Flush is trying to do here, so close to day end. Are you trying to save Ouro, or not save Ouro? Especially considering this sudden need to save himself, this seems like such a bizarre kneejerk.
I don't really see how we move on from today without Ouro flipped.
I don't really see how we move on from today without Ouro flipped.
God forbid I try to defend myself when I'm heading for a lynch
That was a really, really long post just to say "I have no idea if Ouro is town or not". Currently trying to decide if this is just a gambit as scum to try and save their bacon because Ouro/kk and Royal/monkey are the only scum pairs remaining and they could see the writing on the wall.
Considering in Heist, where I was scum with Flush, he just sat in the background and coasted the entire game and literally no one suspected him, I'd be shocked he'd do that (also assuming I'm scum in that scenario).
AbsolutBro
Member
Wait, why would my answers be useful? Did you target SexyCzarSketch?
hey_monkey
Banned
I do think we both thought there was two hours left instead of one. :/ So that's our bad. We were talking in our chat about handling this with him gone. But what this comes down to is that we're not going to defend ourselves; we wanted the info out there before Flush left but we're just town. We're doing what we can to find scum. I'm not really sure why people might have suspected him before I got here because my context is different reading after the fact, but during this day phase, I've been trying to find the truth on Ourokitty and others and the reveal of our power is part of that.
Why, you, of course.
Er, wait, Dr. Worm previously unvoted. 2 more for hammer.
Ahhh of course. I misread my PM.
Ahhh of course. I misread my PM.
hey_monkey
Banned
No, in case your chat was locked if y'all were scum. We targeted Ourokitty because we hoped we might hit the whole scum team.
fake edit while I wait for cooldown: Ouro has a point. We're not hookers (still hate that word) and they say they're not, for whatever that's worth.
Since we're close to a hammer and I'm still writing other replies
To make sure I'm understanding you correctly.
Originally you were planning to unvote Ouro and lie about some theory that Town PRs are only silenced during the Day and that's it because.....?
But instead you fully claim now as Chat Silencer and your original goal was to be a pseudo-cop because Scum is silenced differently than Town? And you were looking for differences when people claimed?
am I getting all that right?
To make sure I'm understanding you correctly.
Originally you were planning to unvote Ouro and lie about some theory that Town PRs are only silenced during the Day and that's it because.....?
But instead you fully claim now as Chat Silencer and your original goal was to be a pseudo-cop because Scum is silenced differently than Town? And you were looking for differences when people claimed?
am I getting all that right?
AbsolutBro
Member
Thank you for putting in words what a reread had me wondering about. It feels a little sketchy to have two players essentially posting through only one of them. I feel like it allows half a pair to basicall avoid posting and leaving actual discussion trails. Any "why didn't you X" can be met with "well, I told so and so in lover chat". Or vice versa "why didn't you" "well in lover chat I did...".
Now granted my memory is fuzzy and I think Trigger has always been rather quiet. Ty4on not so much. It's more a general observation, triggered (pun fully intended) by the post disparity between Trigger and Ty4on.
Again, did you read his post? I didn't read his post as a way of giving a read, but rather giving information for everyone to deliberate on, considering, iirc, he won't be present over the next day phase.
I was holding out voting for Nomadic because I didn't really feel anything toward you.
Vote: Natiko
This post, however, rubs me in a lot of wrong ways.
hey_monkey
Banned
I don't want to speak for him but per our discussion, yes, to fish for possible extra information re: what happened to the people we silenced.
Also, for the record, we're shipping Cersei and Jon Snow, which is DEFINITELY nonsensical. Too much angry/broody face in that one.
Also, for the record, we're shipping Cersei and Jon Snow, which is DEFINITELY nonsensical. Too much angry/broody face in that one.
I don't know how much D1 you read, but I think you just made Kark the happiest player here.