Surprisingly well-written at times too
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Manga News/Discussion |OTX| Attack on Titles
- Thread starter dramatis
- Start date
- Status
A Huge Battleship
Member
Aunt Tits 103
Nisekoi 100
Yep, that's the huge and exciting development I was expecting from chapter 100 of this.
Minamoto is fucked. In more ways than one.
Nisekoi 100
Yep, that's the huge and exciting development I was expecting from chapter 100 of this.
Dedication Through Light
Member
Gakuen Heaven Revolution 18 (end)
And so our time at BL Academy comes to an end. It was a wild ride with an explosive final chapter and a reveal that made me have to pause and leave for a bit. Completely unbelievable at the Chairman reveal. Needless to say I wasnt expecting it and it delivered. I dont even think there were any hints anywhere to even suggest that that was the character to be Chairman.
Ill miss my time with Keita, Kazuki, and everyone else through these past one year with the manga and definitely thought it was a great school life type series with sweet drama and nice friendship going on.
And so our time at BL Academy comes to an end. It was a wild ride with an explosive final chapter and a reveal that made me have to pause and leave for a bit. Completely unbelievable at the Chairman reveal. Needless to say I wasnt expecting it and it delivered. I dont even think there were any hints anywhere to even suggest that that was the character to be Chairman.
Ill miss my time with Keita, Kazuki, and everyone else through these past one year with the manga and definitely thought it was a great school life type series with sweet drama and nice friendship going on.
Dedication Through Light
Member
I dont understand the question, or really the concern that one would need a reason to have a desire to read the original version to [insert franchise name] media adaptation of a series?
BassForever
Member
Same reason people watch the 03 version of fma when brotherhood exists
dont get me wrong, i want to read it, currently reading and watching other series adding another one would fry my brain, and i will read it. im just wondering if anyone wants to know what happens dont they just have to go look at the original or is the new author using the same story but inserting stuff in the middle? im not dissing it, im trying to understand the psychology of reading a series that's already published.
yes. but my true and ONLY question is, are the chapters exactly the same or is there stuff added?
They are essentially the same. Though one chapter of the original doesn't equal one chapter of the new version.
Yeah One draws much better.
ColossalLazy
Member
There are some extra chapters with some side stories that are only in the new version.
curlyfriski
Banned
One is godly, Murata is trash
dakkumauji
Member
The Gamer 12
He's really getting into this.
His mom will probably be the greatest mystery.
He's really getting into this.
His mom will probably be the greatest mystery.
Dedication Through Light
Member
The Flow Stream 23
Staying at the school is the best option for keeping the story good but now to want to drop out, I hope he can be convinced to stay, he can form new friends with the two others on the team.
Staying at the school is the best option for keeping the story good but now to want to drop out, I hope he can be convinced to stay, he can form new friends with the two others on the team.
Dedication Through Light
Member
Soul Cartel 98
Its so hard to keep up with all these, but epic chapter as usual. I dont know how the humans will fit into this with Mephisto and Beelzebub fighting, but I kind of want to see if all three can take on the third archdevil.
Hachi 5
Drak is the best of the new characters introduced, funny personality. Unfortunately, I dont know if it is the saving element this series needs to completely not fall to the bottom of JUMP.
Its so hard to keep up with all these, but epic chapter as usual. I dont know how the humans will fit into this with Mephisto and Beelzebub fighting, but I kind of want to see if all three can take on the third archdevil.
Hachi 5
Drak is the best of the new characters introduced, funny personality. Unfortunately, I dont know if it is the saving element this series needs to completely not fall to the bottom of JUMP.
He's all gentlemanly like that.
Dedication Through Light
Member
Ikezu Kareshi no Otoshikata 2
Tanaka, the editor, knows the best type of work, good chapter. SLight role reversal for Yukio leading to a good result actually made the chapter 2 the best one yet and probably most memorable of the theme so far. Looking forward to more writers tackling the manga editor writer happenings. Best face.
Tanaka, the editor, knows the best type of work, good chapter. SLight role reversal for Yukio leading to a good result actually made the chapter 2 the best one yet and probably most memorable of the theme so far. Looking forward to more writers tackling the manga editor writer happenings. Best face.
Angry Grimace
Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
Dedication Through Light
Member
Fairy Tail 361
Well I was completely wrong on what what would happen. The council member is terrible though, kind of almost would have wished he saw an unhappy end.
Kokushi Musou 3
The pacing is glacially slow, though Kid is hilarious. I would like for him to go back to Ro at least as I think thats vital for escaping this place, assuming the writer wants to ever advance there.
Well I was completely wrong on what what would happen. The council member is terrible though, kind of almost would have wished he saw an unhappy end.
Kokushi Musou 3
The pacing is glacially slow, though Kid is hilarious. I would like for him to go back to Ro at least as I think thats vital for escaping this place, assuming the writer wants to ever advance there.
Jitsu wa Watashi wa 6
Yeah, she must be screaming internally after hearing that
I wish we had spent just a few more chapters with the secret staying between just the two of them, but if the next chapter is exceptionally fun, then I'll be fine with class rep knowing about the vampirism so early.
Yeah, she must be screaming internally after hearing that
I wish we had spent just a few more chapters with the secret staying between just the two of them, but if the next chapter is exceptionally fun, then I'll be fine with class rep knowing about the vampirism so early.
FlutterPuffs
Member
Dude, it's just like watching a remastered version of a movie.
It could be great like Beauty And The Beast 3D, or shitty like Star Wars Remastered.
Dedication Through Light
Member
The Gamer 12
He reminds me of me when playing some rpgs, the excitement of getting good exp and then titles. Hopefully ps4 can get in on the rpg love so I get these same feelings again.
He reminds me of me when playing some rpgs, the excitement of getting good exp and then titles. Hopefully ps4 can get in on the rpg love so I get these same feelings again.
astrogamer
Member
Tonari no Seki 1-13
Cute and quirky manga. I like that Seki never talks. its all the obsevation of the reader and Yokoi's narration. He does some amazing things. I also like his weaknesses they are cute and he isn't a bland god character. These kind of characterizations are adding a bit more fun with each chapter
Cute and quirky manga. I like that Seki never talks. its all the obsevation of the reader and Yokoi's narration. He does some amazing things. I also like his weaknesses they are cute and he isn't a bland god character. These kind of characterizations are adding a bit more fun with each chapter
dakkumauji
Member
Soko wa Chuumon no Ooi Ryouriten
An one-shot about a girl who frequents a diner where she thinks the owner doesn't like her.
Well a quick one-shot. Nice use of food and the ending was pretty cute.
Hot Ice Tune
An one-shot about the relationship between a guy and the girl whose moving away.
Kinda cute, a nice little romantic story of course.
An one-shot about a girl who frequents a diner where she thinks the owner doesn't like her.
Well a quick one-shot. Nice use of food and the ending was pretty cute.
Hot Ice Tune
An one-shot about the relationship between a guy and the girl whose moving away.
Kinda cute, a nice little romantic story of course.
Dedication Through Light
Member
Ace of Diamond 1 - 19
Well its just as good as the anime, will definitely keep following along both anime and manga.So many good feelings of determination, passion for baseball and just good comedy. Kuromachi for best roommate and best energy, along with Furuya, Miyuki, Eijun, and Takigawa Chris Yuu, and Kominato for my favorites. Really good baseball story.
Well its just as good as the anime, will definitely keep following along both anime and manga.So many good feelings of determination, passion for baseball and just good comedy. Kuromachi for best roommate and best energy, along with Furuya, Miyuki, Eijun, and Takigawa Chris Yuu, and Kominato for my favorites. Really good baseball story.
astrogamer
Member
The Gamer 12
Fairly cool, actiony episode. Looking forward to next chapter
Funny if this became meme, just replace girl with anything
Art adds a whole new dimension to the story.
astrogamer
Member
Log Horizon - Nishikaze no Ryodan
Harem kings never die. Now the start of a wave of PKs
Harem kings never die. Now the start of a wave of PKs
dakkumauji
Member
Tonari no Kaibutsu-kun 46
Wut, at that ending for this chapter.
While it totally isn't out of character for this, it still was pretty silly how this chapter ended.
Pretty great chapter nonetheless, since we're reaching the homestretch, we're gonna get all these relationships resolved and nothing makes me happier to see that for this series.
Wut, at that ending for this chapter.
While it totally isn't out of character for this, it still was pretty silly how this chapter ended.
Pretty great chapter nonetheless, since we're reaching the homestretch, we're gonna get all these relationships resolved and nothing makes me happier to see that for this series.
chicagocubsfan
Member
Awesome One Piece ad in today's issue of New York Times to celebrate 300 million copies in print.
Dedication Through Light
Member
Please resize...
Dont understand why they watermark in the center in comicsans in nov 2013.
Dont understand why they watermark in the center in comicsans in nov 2013.
Hatarakanai Futari 1-8
A NEET pair of siblings bum around all day. A rather amusing collection of 1-3 page chapters ensures.
Magdala de Nemure 5
catgirl heretic moe
Sinbad 15A
Ugh, just as things were starting to get good, the publishers decide to split these biweekly chapters in half for a weekly release which kills the ebb and flow of each chapter. It's almost as if the publishers don't want this to succeed. Dropped.
A NEET pair of siblings bum around all day. A rather amusing collection of 1-3 page chapters ensures.
Magdala de Nemure 5
catgirl heretic moe
Sinbad 15A
Ugh, just as things were starting to get good, the publishers decide to split these biweekly chapters in half for a weekly release which kills the ebb and flow of each chapter. It's almost as if the publishers don't want this to succeed. Dropped.
Infinite Justice
Member
I thought you guys would have given up on KNIM by now?
You don't know MangaGAF very well do you
dakkumauji
Member
Saito-kun wa Esper Rashii 15.5
Being a main character is so easy these days.
Being a main character is so easy these days.
dakkumauji
Member
Tonari no Seki-kun 42
The OTP to end all OTPs.
The OTP to end all OTPs.
Akame ga Kill
Man, that ability is so cheap. How in the world will they ever be able to beat that?!...
Vinland Saga
Thorfinn and co. are finally off Farmland Saga, I presume. As much as I loved the series at its start, I wasn't sold on pacifist Thorfinn (I'm still not sold). It's not quite that I want the series to be blood 'n guts violence or anything like that, but I feel like the current happenings are dragging and dreary.
I don't feel connected to the current side-characters like I was in Planetes, so almost all of the events of the current arc feel hollow to me. I could not invest any emotion at all into the proceedings. I certainly like my slow-paced, contemplative fiction (but not like this).
Man, that ability is so cheap. How in the world will they ever be able to beat that?!...
Vinland Saga
Thorfinn and co. are finally off Farmland Saga, I presume. As much as I loved the series at its start, I wasn't sold on pacifist Thorfinn (I'm still not sold). It's not quite that I want the series to be blood 'n guts violence or anything like that, but I feel like the current happenings are dragging and dreary.
I don't feel connected to the current side-characters like I was in Planetes, so almost all of the events of the current arc feel hollow to me. I could not invest any emotion at all into the proceedings. I certainly like my slow-paced, contemplative fiction (but not like this).
Passive Assassin
Member
farmland saga 2 coming up.
Minamoto 104
awww shit. Something has to go wrong when they get back though.
People just had a 2-3 page argument over the big 3, so..... yeah.
awww shit. Something has to go wrong when they get back though.
I thought you guys would have given up on KNIM by now?
People just had a 2-3 page argument over the big 3, so..... yeah.
Crash Station
Member
Anagle Mole 37-41
It takes talent to consistently pull off shounen strategies without making them feel contrived. Fukuchi knows what he's doing.
This needs an anime.
It takes talent to consistently pull off shounen strategies without making them feel contrived. Fukuchi knows what he's doing.
This needs an anime.
curlyfriski
Banned
Aunt Tits 104
Obviously the house is going to be decorated with the skins of every woman who's ever touched Minamoto.
Obviously the house is going to be decorated with the skins of every woman who's ever touched Minamoto.
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked