As much as im enjoying the game from a gameplay aspect, I'm really left scratching my head at the design philosophy, or lack thereof, of things in the game, namely the squadmates.
The fact that the whole Andromeda Initiative is mostly motivated by "just because....reasons" as oppose to what a lot of people saw as the obvious attempt at being a sort of back up plan for the reaper invasion of the Milky Way Galaxy is weird but i understand why they didn't go with that as they wanted this whole thing to feel new so if the crux of the whole plot is to side step the reaper invasion then at some point you're going to have to address that somewhere down the line.
That being said, in an attempt to make good on this whole "new" feeling and perspective, why the fuck are the squadmates direct carbon copies of their trilogy counterparts?
- Garrus was a principled and professional Turian? Great so is Vetra
- Wrex was an action junkie Krogan who loved to get his hands dirty? Great so is Drack
- Liara was a mildly socially awkward Asari researcher. Great! PeeBee is a socially awkard Asari but rather than focus on her intellect, we'll make her carefree and noncommittal. Progress!
At this point i figured maybe I was being too harsh. After all, the alien races have distinct traits that they share. The turians are from palaven and are very militaristic so it would make sense Garrus and Vetra are principled professionals. Krogans by design were bred to be formidable soldiers so it would make sense Wrex and Drack are aggressive and have that "boots on the ground" mentality. Ok, well what about the humans....
- Jacob was a black male military brat who was motivated by his sense of duty. Liam is a black male cop who got recognized for his efforts and sense of duty in his HUSTL crisis response unit
- Miranda was a white professional guarded female who felt betrayed by her father that led to her feeling conflicted and outcasted due to her biotic powers.
- Cora is a white professional guarded female who feels betrayed by Alec Ryder who she looked up to and admired because he inspired her when she felt conflicted and outcasted due her biotic powers and feels nepotism got in the way of her being classed as the next pathfinder.
- Suvi is basically a palette swap of Chambers
HOW DOES THIS HAPPEN?! It's remarkable that they didn't make Kallo a fast talking scientist.
Surely they
HAD to have known that people were going to compare this game to the trilogy. They had to. So what the hell is with this lazy coat of paint? I thought this was suppose to be new and fresh? Why do we only have
ONE new alien race? Makes no sense. All or at least most of our squad mates should be new races and if somehow you can't do that
DON'T make poor 1:1 copies of beloved characters from the trilogy.
It also doesn't help that all the characters feel like adolescents. I feel like the trilogy is "Scooby Do, Where are you?" and Andromeda is "A Pup named Scooby Doo"
The potential is there and that's what makes it so frustrating. They kept pushing this "I'ts completely new" narrative in the marketing and lead up to release but at the same time it feels like they're playing it too safe and as a result completely fuck up both the new and the old.