I hope you guys didn't put hundreds of dollars into Shenmue 3.
I have to ask, what's the logic behind this statement? How does MN9's reception translate into concerns about Shenmue III when all they have in common is a crowdfunding platform?
I'd like a progress report every once in a while. Bloodstained provides one regularly. As do other kickstarters and early access games. Shenmue 3's been a thing for a year and we basically have nothing.
?
C'mon, don't bullshit. The last Kickstarter update was May 31st, detailing the hiring of an Emmy Award winning animator onto the project.
We know from Shenmue III's Producer that they have
some form of playable build only 10 months into development.
The game looked
significantly visually improved when it showed last in late February, and they
waiting until the game is more polished to show it off again.
Healthy skepticism is fine, but you're reaching quite hard for a conclusion that doesn't have anything to back it up. Mighty No 9 began to look worse through its development (art style suffered, game got stiffer and slower, level design was unimpressive, etc), but other games like Bloodstained, Yooka-Laylee, and Shenmue III are moving in the opposite direction.
I backed Double Fine Adventure and didn't like what I got. Do you know why I'm not decrying every Kickstarter game under the sun because of that? Because I know a.) Kickstarter is usually the only common factor in these games and doesn't reflect how that money is used, and b.) I now know to pay attention to who is creating these games and figure out what their intentions are.
I should have known that Tim Schafer (and don't get me wrong, I like his games most of the time) would not have given me the "old school point and click adventure" that I wanted, and so wouldn't have been disappointed when Broken Age was a heavily story focused adventure game with context-sensitive controls suited to an iPad or smartphone. Likewise, I should have known Ron Gilbert would have been the one to give me the experience I wanted out of Broken Age, and should have backed Thimbleweed Park when it came to Kickstarter (since rectified by being a Slacker Backer).
Inafune is effectively someone who has piggy-backed on the success of others since the start of his career. I don't blame people for not knowing this, because he's very good at selling himself and it's become clear since the Kickstarter ended what kind of "creative" he is.
But talking down other Kickstarters because of his shortcomings is just dumb.