Zaptruder said:
Sorry, I'm a MMA outsider, so all I hear are the names that have been thrown around... right now I'm not sure how they all fall together.
So... where do people like Sapp or even Butterbean fall into the MMA ranking continuum?
No prob.
Where does Sapp lie? He's not a contender, either in MMA, or in kickboxing (and it's been kickboxing that he seems to have been focussing on recently, and where he's had comparatively more success).
When he first burst on to the scene, he wowed people. Here was this huge, powerful man, full of raw aggression. It was thought that as he became more skilled and trained, he might become unstoppable. His biggest MMA fight was against Nogueira, who was Pride Champion at the time, and still ranked #2 or 3, depending on who you ask.
They had one of MMA's most epic wars, with Nogueira finally winning by armbar.
However, apart from that amazing fight, Sapp has not done anything competitive in MMA.
His record is 7-2-1. It breaks down like this, with his opponents' records in brackets:
Win over Yoshihisa Yamomoto (6-13)
Win over Kiyoshi Tamura (13-8) Tamura only weighs 195 lbs, Sapp weighs about 350.
Loss to Antonio Nogueira (25-3-1)
Win over Yoshihiro Takayama (0-4)
Win over Stephan Gamlin (0-2)
Win over Sumiyabazar Dolgorsuren (0-2)
Loss to Kazuyuki Fujita (10-4)
Draw with Jerome LeBanner (1-1-1). This fight was half-MMA, half-kickboxing
Win over Min Soo Kim (0-2)
Win over Alan Karaev (0-2)
So he only has one win over an opponent with a winning record, and he outweight that fighter by over 150lbs. The opponents he has beaten/drawed have a combined record of 20-34-1, while the two who have beaten him have a combined rank of 35-7-1.
Butterbean is a complete joke. He's only had 2 MMA fights, and is 0-1-1. He lost quickly to Genki Sudo, who is a top-10
155 lbs fighter (Butterbean weighing about 350 lbs), and scored a draw with a guy who is 3-0-1.