• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

MLB 2015 Regular Season |OT2| NES Baseball, Best Baseball

zychi

Banned
Depends on how many voters are still clueless enough to care about wins. Kershaw and Greinke winning Cy's with 16 wins, and King Felix with 13, in the recent past, means the tide might be turning.

Currently the second lowest era of all time in the franchise, threw a no hitter, and is a huge reason the Cubs have a better record than Giants or Dodgers.
 

3N16MA

Banned
Yeah, well if you take away Batman's mask he's Bruce Wayne. That's not how awards work

Franchise records and no hitters should not be deciding factors. Overall season stats should and Kershaw is right there if not better than Arrieta. Arrieta has Kershaw beat in run prevention (ERA) and that is about it.
 
Currently the second lowest era of all time in the franchise, threw a no hitter, and is a huge reason the Cubs have a better record than Giants or Dodgers.

Kershaw has been leagues better than Arrieta (or any other pitcher in MLB this year) and it's probably not even close.

I imagine Arrieta and Greinke split the 2nd and 3rd place votes, maybe getting a 1st place vote here and there as well
 
Really don't understand the need to "let people get their work in" when you're trying to win games.

The bottom of the lineup up sucks shit right now. Pennington is a garbage hitter but he's still better than Bannerman Kawasaki.
 
Didnt answer the question.

Grienke is having a better year, so I don't get the love for Kershaw for Cy

Advanced stats say he is having a better year.

Not to mention strikeouts.

It's a shame Arrieta is having one of the best seasons by a Cubs pitcher ever, while Kershaw continues to dominate.
 
Well Price & Archer gonna get me the Gaf league title. Who needs those big 3 pitchers.
I just messing.. But I can't let a Giant fan beat me
 
Didnt answer the question.

Grienke is having a better year, so I don't get the love for Kershaw for Cy

I mean, I'm a Cardinals fan, and don't particularly like the Dodgers at all, but Kershaw is the best pitcher on the planet and having maybe his best season yet

Greinke is only having the best season if you look at ERA, he's probably the 3rd best behind Kershaw and Arrieta if you look at peripherals. Still gonna get paid this offseason though

I kinda feel bad for pitchers in the NL, because Kershaw is just so good. If he wins this year it'll be his 4th CY yeah?
 
Now I am no Yankees fan but I miss the Betances from the first half. His stuff was incredible (still is) but it seems like he struggles constantly now since he gets used so fucking much, when it was an automatic 1-2-3 inning earlier in the season
 

zychi

Banned
Jake has a lower second half ERA than both, has a no hitter this year too.

Wins dont usually mean much, but to hit 20 in a season is pretty big
2015 League Ranks:
• 1st in NL in W (19)
• 3rd in NL in IP (207.0)
• 4th in NL in SO (209)
• 2nd in NL in ERA (1.96)
• 3rd in NL in WHIP (0.92)
• 2nd in NL in W% (.760)
• 2nd in NL in CG (3)

Greinke:
2015 League Ranks:
• 2nd in NL in W (18)
• 2nd in NL in IP (207.2)
• 1st in NL in ERA (1.65)
• 1st in NL in WHIP (0.85)
• 1st in NL in W% (.857)
• 8th in NL in CG (1)

Ker:
2015 League Ranks:
• 6th in NL in W (14)
• 1st in NL in IP (215.0)
• 1st in NL in SO (272)
• 3rd in NL in ERA (2.18)
• 2nd in NL in WHIP (0.90)
• 7th in NL in W% (.667)
• 2nd in NL in CG (3)

It looks to me like G is having a better year.
 
Top Bottom