Alright, time to go over the season as a whole. I ended up writing a pretty big post, so I broke it into sections for convenience.
Episodes
I haven't rewatched the season yet, but taking into account my previous posts and my current gut responses to the episodes, I'd rate them (bad < meh < OK < good < great):
1-2. The Crystalling - OK; it didn't gain potential future points due to not actually doing anything of note with Flurry Heart and Sunburst afterward.
3. The Gift Of Maud Pie - Meh; I was OK with the episode at the time, but in retrospect, I feel there's little notable other than some visual gags.
4. On Your Marks - Bad; when I looked at my episode review, I had forgotten a lot of the events I brought up. This is one I'll almost definitely skip when I watch the season with my family.
5. Gauntlet of Fire - Good; dragons didn't come up again, so it loses potential points for that.
6. No Second Prances - Good; I mention in my review that I don't like Trixie's voice, but I didn't mind it in "To Where and Back Again", so maybe I won't mind as much on a rewatch. Also, I notice in my roundup post, one piece of fanart predicted Discord teaming up with Starlight and Trixie.
7. Newbie Dash - Good; obviously a "your millage may vary" episode, but I was fine with the cringe humor.
8. A Hearth's Warming Tail - Great; in retrospect, they should have leveraged this episode to develop Starlight more, but still very enjoyable.
9. The Saddle Row Review - Great; up there among the best of the series, I think.
10. Applejack's "Day'' Off - Bad; 0% chance I'll rewatch this any time soon.
11. Flutter Brutter - OK; my review was positive, but over time my feelings have dimmed. Maybe I'll like it more again after a rewatch.
12. Spice Up Your Life - OK; good song, but nothing else stood out too much.
13. Stranger Than Fan Fiction - Great; justified Daring Do being real.
14. The Cart Before the Ponies - Meh; I still like the song, but the episode still seems weak.
15. 28 Pranks Later - Meh; still better than "The Mysterious Mare-Do-Well", and this might be something I like more on rewatch.
16. The Times They Are a Changeling - OK; in retrospect, there should have been another Thorax episode before the finale.
17. Dungeons and Discord - OK; some others have said this is better on a rewatch.
18. Buckball Season - Good; or maybe OK, I think it's right on the border.
19. The Fault in Our Cutie Marks - Good
20. Viva Las Pegasus - Good; definitely the surprise of the season for me.
21. Every Little Thing She Does - Good; I was a bit uncomfortable on first watch, mainly due to anticipating everyone else's response, but it should be better on rewatches.
22. P.P.O.V. (Pony Point of View) - OK; I still think they played their hand with Pirate Applejack too early.
23. Where the Apple Lies - Good
24. Top Bolt - Great; though closer to the good side, maybe
25-26. To Where and Back Again - Great; though I feel like this will change on rewatch.
In the end, I suppose season 6 was overall better than I was giving it credit for. In the first half of the season, it started out weak, had a strong middle, but then had a weak finish. Then while the second half started with a good episode, the next few after that were all pretty weak, then the last few episodes were all strong. Looking at season 5, that also had weak episodes, but there generally weren't more than two in a row.
Advancing the series
Season 5 advanced the series in various ways, including the unique villain in the premiere, how it presented the Main Six in as being older and more grown-up in some ways, how it quickly brought back stuff from the previous seasons and earlier episodes that season, and how it pushed side characters to the foreground. However, "Slice of Life" and "Amending Fences" didn't turn out to reflect the show's future, and out of all the non-Starlight characters introduced in season 5, it was only Spoiled Rich that got a major role in a season 6 episode. Ignoring continuity stuff, if season 6 episodes were shuffled into season 4, I think they'd be appreciated more.
But since I brought up continuity, I do have to commend the show crew for how many references to previous episodes were included without feeling awkward. In "The Saddle Row Review", for instance, we didn't have to wonder about Coco Pommel's absence because she was right there, and we got a bonus reference to "Too Many Pinkie Pies" that still works even if you hadn't seen the episode.
Compared to previous seasons, season 6 was much better about having various episodes come together in the finale, and Starlight's arc is unique for the series. For our episode guide, I imagine season 6 will have the largest number of "important" stories since season 1. Season 4 attempted to a story arc based on MacGuffins the heroes had to collect, but I feel the character-based arc in season 6 better fits the show.
Storylines and Character Usage
Comparing seasons 6 and 5, one thing that stands out to me is that while both have ambitious stories that bring about major changes, season 5 is better at making those episodes significant and, well, better. Compare the Cutie Mark Crusaders getting their cutie marks to Rainbow Dash becoming a Wonderbolt. The former was a big musical and is widely regarded as on the upper end of the entire the series. The latter got a mixed reception, and while I liked it, I can admit that it just didn't feel important. I'm not saying it should have been a musical, but they could have done more to make it a bigger spectacle. Of course, part of the problem is that we had several previous episodes of Rainbow Dash inching her way up the ranks, so it would have been hard to make it feel like a big deal no matter what. Still, as is, it doesn't feel like becoming a Wonderbolt mattered much for her character.
"The Times They Are a Changeling" was very important for the season, but it was just OK and had a very safe and straightforward story. In "On Your Marks", Apple Bloom's confusion about what's next should have been compelling, but it was mostly dull instead. This season had stories that impact the characters or plot, and great episodes. I think it would have been much more warmly received if the former were also all great, which I feel is something season 5 achieved.
This season set up a couple of plot threads that it didn't really follow through on. First of all, almost nothing from "The Crystalling" came up again, other than brief appearances from Flurry Heart and Sunburst in "The Times They Are a Changeling" and little more than mentions in "To Where and Back Again". "The Saddle Row Review" had Rarity open up a third shop, but while her Canterlot shop appeared a second time in season 5, neither shop did so in season 6. Rainbow Dash being a Wonderbolt didn't come up again until "Top Bolt", and made episodes like "28 Pranks Later" seem even more out of character for her. Despite "Gauntlet of Fire" doing some major world building, it wasn't relevant for the rest of the season. I don't consider this a huge issue, especially since it's what we expect from the show, but it's still an area to improve on.
There also appear to be fewer stories that do interesting things with the main characters. A common complaint about various individual episodes is that they play it very safe with characterization or revert to "classic" versions. However, I have to give credit to "No Second Prances" for its willingness to present Twilight as unpleasant at times, along with every Spike episode being at least decent.
Starlight Glimmer
Of course, one can't talk about season 6 as a whole without talking about Starlight. She definitely could have used one or two more episodes to better smooth out her character progression, but I thought she was handled in an interesting way. I've compared Sunset and Starlight in the past, but in brief, I think Starlight trying to be reformed while still having villainous qualities is a surprisingly bold move for this franchise, as compared to Sunset instantly being pure good. Discord still acts in villainous ways, of course, but you don't get the impression that he's trying to be good but failing.
The episodes focusing on Starlight are the premiere, "No Second Prances", "Every Little Thing She Does", and the finale. "A Hearth's Warming Tail" doesn't count. The premiere served to more or less reintroduce Starlight as a heroic character, and in that regard, I think it worked well. In the second story, making Trixie her closest friend worked out far better than I would have expected, for both characters. I appreciate the third story, but there definitely should have been a followup episode. She hasn't actually interacted with the non-Twilight Main Six much after that episode, so perhaps we'll get a scene of them being nervous around her in season 7, but that's still too much of a delay. The finale could have been slightly adjusted to better act as a followup, perhaps with her just mentioning to Trixie what happened after they leave her town, to explain why she was so nervous about taking charge.
It seems like Starlight will be sticking around, so it will be interesting to see what they do with her in the future.
Overall
Overall, I think one big issue with this season is that of prioritization. Some episodes should have been better to provide a better overall season, and some episodes could have afforded to be worse. You can't just redistribute episode quality, but episodes like "The Times They Are a Changeling" should have gotten more time and resources than it did, and they probably should have made Flurry Heart's introduction a single episode, so maybe the two-parter slot could have been used for the former story. But of course, it's very likely that would have been impossible given marketing and scheduling realities. And really, this season isn't bad for not doing what I'm suggesting.
There's also the issue that there were stretches of multiple weak episodes in a row, and maybe some rescheduling with that in mind could have improved my initial reaction to the season. However, the fact that some of the big "must watch" stories ended up being merely OK or getting a mixed reaction will prevent that from being a perfect solution.
I had a big post examining the previous seasons
here, where I gave the following ranking:
5 > 2 > 6 > 4 > 1 > 3
I believe that still applies for me. Despite how harsh I was on season 6 in this post, it's still pretty good.
==
Following up on things from my previous posts, Daniel Ingram posted that he wrote 3 villain songs and one would be in "A Hearth's Warming Tail". There were no other villain songs this season, so I guess both were for Legend of Everfree, counting both the Gloriosa song and one of Twilight's I suppose.
At the start of July,
there was this secret project that was hinted about. It turned out this was just Guardians of Harmony, which wasn't officially announced until then.
When the synopsis for "The Fault in Our Cutie Marks" was posted (after the "Stranger Than Fan Fiction" discussion), I posted an MLP Facebook image that depicted a bunch of griffons, one of which could have been Gabby. It wasn't.
For future reference, the missing image in
this post was a picture of Applejack's map, I believe, which had a bunyip on it.