NeoGAF Ban Review/Justice Project

Status
Not open for further replies.
I'd like to since when is pointing out fanboys attacking each other, considered console warring?

One person makes a thread criticizing Sony and first reply is

Post in thread 'Jim Ryan and the denigration of Playstation.' https://www.neogaf.com/threads/jim-ryan-and-the-denigration-of-playstation.1583673/post-261713247

Op responds and this is how user replies again. Where's the actual discussion?

Post in thread 'Jim Ryan and the denigration of Playstation.' https://www.neogaf.com/threads/jim-ryan-and-the-denigration-of-playstation.1583673/post-261713271

Here's another

Post in thread 'Jim Ryan and the denigration of Playstation.' https://www.neogaf.com/threads/jim-ryan-and-the-denigration-of-playstation.1583673/post-261713313


Post in thread 'Jim Ryan and the denigration of Playstation.' https://www.neogaf.com/threads/jim-ryan-and-the-denigration-of-playstation.1583673/post-261713715

Post in thread 'Jim Ryan and the denigration of Playstation.' https://www.neogaf.com/threads/jim-ryan-and-the-denigration-of-playstation.1583673/post-261713934

Post in thread 'Jim Ryan and the denigration of Playstation.' https://www.neogaf.com/threads/jim-ryan-and-the-denigration-of-playstation.1583673/post-261715431

Post in thread 'Jim Ryan and the denigration of Playstation.' https://www.neogaf.com/threads/jim-ryan-and-the-denigration-of-playstation.1583673/post-261718356

Thats just a couple of the posts in there attacking op for his opinion. If they want to be offended by someone's opinion, maybe they belong on another forum.

So how was my post about sony fanboys being cannibalistic wrong and how does that even fall under "console warring "? Bill O'Rights Bill O'Rights Soapy Wooder Soapy Wooder
 
Anyway, I believe you have a good heart but your debates are pretty exhausting and I don't like it when it's not constructive, especially when you're not just a simple poster but a real expert in graphics and that tag also has its own prestige that you seem like not sticking to.


Warm greetings.

Wow. Dude got even Bo Hazem tired to console warring.

The guy is legendary.
 
I lost the count.
VFX after coming back from another ban:
613a866f7900950422be27c5091dddb0c8ac84ac.png

But let me tell you why the PS5 is bad...
 
VFX after coming back from another ban:
613a866f7900950422be27c5091dddb0c8ac84ac.png

But let me tell you why the PS5 is bad...
This guy is just saaaaaaad.

He is gafs jehovahs witness who tries to convert sony fans. Never xbox or nintendo fans,nooo its always sony fans.

Well guess what . You can win me over if you would be a mormon. Multiple consoles multiple wifes......thats more like it.
 
Hello EviLore EviLore

I noticed that VFXVeteran VFXVeteran got a temporary ban for complaining about Sony fans. I think it would be a good idea to modify his tag that way it would give him an incentive to change his behavior. While I do enjoy having industry professionals contribute to this forum, I don't enjoy it when they derail threads with unprofessional behavior.

I would hate to see him terminated from GaF so I think giving him an incentive to change his behavior might help him out.

Thank you for taking the time to read this.
 
There cannot be a market of ideas when posting left means you're trolled out of the forum. Positions are exceptionally entrenched and stubborn refusal to concede even the most minor of points is a reality, when it comes to left vs right. Something that over time I've become guilty for, as well.

I don't think putting a blanket ban on trolling people, no matter whether -Arcadia- -Arcadia- believes they deserve to be trolled or not, is heavy handed moderation. No one wants another reset and I'm a socialdemocrat.



I don't want to relitigate anything from politics, try a heel turn and go hard left for 6 months and see what happens. Suddenly trolling doesn't seem as bad when you're being trolled on a daily basis.

And I'm done with the conversation about the contents of politics.



I am genuinely sorry. I reported and moved on.

I'm kinda old school left - class is everything. I've argued left wing positions, left wing cases for Brexit, etc without problems.

I'd get run off ree but here I'm welcome. Calling bullshit.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Hello EviLore EviLore

I noticed that VFXVeteran VFXVeteran got a temporary ban for complaining about Sony fans. I think it would be a good idea to modify his tag that way it would give him an incentive to change his behavior. While I do enjoy having industry professionals contribute to this forum, I don't enjoy it when they derail threads with unprofessional behavior.

I would hate to see him terminated from GaF so I think giving him an incentive to change his behavior might help him out.

Thank you for taking the time to read this.

YsZs3mO.jpg
 
Last edited:
Getting banned on Christmas sucks, but the rules are the rules. Plenty of people have offered constructive replies, so I'm just going to offer him a Merry Christmas, and hope his day was super fun.
 
Whenever I click into any thread to do with graphics or technical specs I just know I'll see VFXVeteran fighting alone against the Sonygaf hoards :messenger_tears_of_joy:

horde%2B1.gif



I think it's worth asking: if VFXVeteran really is the problem, then how come he never seems to have any beef with the Nintendo or Xbox crowd on here? Why is it always VFXVeteran v Sonygaf? It's only a week long ban, so not worth making a huge fuss over (I'm sure he's just enjoying his leftover turkey, alcohol and playing Cyberpunk at ultra settings anyway), but I think he is a little hard done by sometimes. Although his posts can come across as a little abrasive at times, when viewed in light of the frequent goading and insults he gets, I think he is actually fairly restrained in his posting behaviour.
 
Whenever I click into any thread to do with graphics or technical specs I just know I'll see VFXVeteran fighting alone against the Sonygaf hoards :messenger_tears_of_joy:

horde%2B1.gif



I think it's worth asking: if VFXVeteran really is the problem, then how come he never seems to have any beef with the Nintendo or Xbox crowd on here? Why is it always VFXVeteran v Sonygaf? It's only a week long ban, so not worth making a huge fuss over (I'm sure he's just enjoying his leftover turkey, alcohol and playing Cyberpunk at ultra settings anyway), but I think he is a little hard done by sometimes. Although his posts can come across as a little abrasive at times, when viewed in light of the frequent goading and insults he gets, I think he is actually fairly restrained in his posting behaviour.
Nah he straight up loves it. The guy is just obsessed with going back and forth with people over the dumbest graphical arguments. He is literally that guy who HAS to justify his 4000 dollar setup. The only reason he isnt arguing with ninty and xbox fanboys is because they havent had any big graphical showcases as of late. The moment Xbox gets a game that people claim looks/runs as good as the PC version...hell be here downplaying it and claiming it looks like shit.
 
Hey, I got a theory on why it's just the SONY crowd he needs to argue with... hear me out... Nintendo and XBOX Gaf know their place on graphics... Nintendo isn't even competing visually and since all XBOX exclusives go to PC it is constantly forced to be acknowledged the PC version looks superior. SONY has exclusive games, though, that aren't on PC so the argument for "best looking game" in a given year is down to PC and SONY meaning they're his only enemy.
 
Hey, I got a theory on why it's just the SONY crowd he needs to argue with... hear me out... Nintendo and XBOX Gaf know their place on graphics... Nintendo isn't even competing visually and since all XBOX exclusives go to PC it is constantly forced to be acknowledged the PC version looks superior. SONY has exclusive games, though, that aren't on PC so the argument for "best looking game" in a given year is down to PC and SONY meaning they're his only enemy.
I think it is because Nintendo has games that aren't just in 3rd person.
 
Hey, I got a theory on why it's just the SONY crowd he needs to argue with... hear me out... Nintendo and XBOX Gaf know their place on graphics... Nintendo isn't even competing visually and since all XBOX exclusives go to PC it is constantly forced to be acknowledged the PC version looks superior. SONY has exclusive games, though, that aren't on PC so the argument for "best looking game" in a given year is down to PC and SONY meaning they're his only enemy.

Well, he has said many times that more and more Sony exclusives will be coming to PC (and within a much shorter timeframe too), so your theory may soon be put to the test. In a way it would be a nice and fitting end to the war - a PS5 console exclusive also gets an amazing PC port with all the bells and whistles, which VFXVeteran then declares to be the best looking game on PC. That way, the best looking PC and PS5 game will be one and the same, and peace will reign throughout the Neogaf lands!

Actually, maybe that is a little optimistic, as it still wouldn't please the PS5 "secret sauce" guys, but at least the Sony game studio fans will be happy.
 
Nah he straight up loves it.

There is definitely a love/hate thing between Sonygaf and VFXVeteran. I think most of the former would miss him if he really was permabanned. I think he relishes the verbal sparring too, on occasion. They should probably just sleep together and get it over with.
 
I think it's worth asking: if VFXVeteran really is the problem, then how come he never seems to have any beef with the Nintendo or Xbox crowd on here? Why is it always VFXVeteran v Sonygaf?
For Nintendo fans to live in the illusion that their hardware of choice is extremely powerful would require an even greater delusion than for Sony fans. Also, I'd guess there are more Sony fans than Nintendo and Xbox fans summed up.
 
metroid is dead
LLdqYFp.gif

I trusted you, Tess.

For Nintendo fans to live in the illusion that their hardware of choice is extremely powerful would require an even greater delusion than for Sony fans. Also, I'd guess there are more Sony fans than Nintendo and Xbox fans summed up.
It is almost as if people make decisions based on more than on datapoint and there are people who want each of the three consoles. I'm trying to be better about engaging with good posts and calling out console warring when it begins to take over a thread.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom