We went and checked out a local game store for the first time and ended up getting a few games.
Cacao we bought basically just based on the box, we had never heard of it but it just looked cool. Very colorful, interesting jungle theme, circular player boards, wooden pieces of cacao, it just looks really interesting on the shelf.
The game itself is pretty fun, you take turns playing tiles that have meeple on them which determine whether you can take advantage of adjacent tiles that give resources. It's extremely quick which is nice, and it's fun fighting over resources and screwing people over at the end when it's possible to play tiles on top of old ones to change the board. It's really light, really awesome filler games.
We got
Lost Cities which is every bit as great as I had heard.
And we also picked up
Castles of Burgundy which we haven't played yet. It's really highly rated on Board Game Geek, which is why we bought it (also it was pretty cheap at the store, about $10 less than the price on Amazon) but it looks pretty boring honestly, looks like you role dice and use resources to do stuff sort of like Catan without the trading. Looking forward to try it out though.