• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

NFL 2012 Week 4 |OT| Dewey Beats Truman

Kiryu

Member
http://www.q13fox.com/videogallery/72542094/Sports/Seahawks-catch-exclusive-angle

Another, better, angle. Still...

662896303.jpg


And in case you're stuck staring and wondering whose arm that really is, Golden Tate is not wearing black wrist tape and M.D. Jennings is, so that was how I determined whose arm+hand was on the ball.
That image is broken but I guess I was mistaken by that arm... I thought it was Golden Tate... but it was still simultaneous pass EVEN Jenning had more control of ball (and high chance of that call to be called) but it didn't... I guess I am going to stand on Simultaneous pass ruling.
 

desh

Member
It was the right call. Tate's one-handed catch was just as good as Jenning's two-handed one. Tate's got some really strong hands.
 

DrForester

Kills Photobucket
That image is broken but I guess I was mistaken by that arm... I thought it was Golden Tate... but it was still simultaneous pass EVEN Jenning had more control of ball (and high chance of that call to be called) but it didn't... I guess I am going to stand on Simultaneous pass ruling.

Other than him never having the ball under his control or against his chest, sure, it's a simultaneous catch.
 

desh

Member
Based on commentary I've been hearing on ESPN an other places, I have been led to believe that it's required in the whole simultaneous catch rule.

I hadn't heard that. If that's the case, then that changes everything. Is there actual documentation that backs this up, or just opinion?
 
dat salt.

Hey Fox is the htc 1x any good? I can get it for 1 bill if I extend my contract. My xperia is dying

The One X is a really nice piece of kit. It was my close second choice after the GS3.

niners. but then kap will take the job in the 3rd game of the pre-season

I'm surprised you don't want to take a shot at the Tebow.

Left-handed running QB + greatest QB mind we've seen in decades= Steve Young reincarnate, right?
 
We were all talking about resident evil 6 the other day and I said I thought it would suck.

Gamespot just gave it a 4.5/10. That's just one site but damn.

I just don't see how anyone could have been excited for this game.
 

DrForester

Kills Photobucket
I hadn't heard that. If that's the case, then that changes everything. Is there actual documentation that backs this up, or just opinion?

Just what I was hearing all the commentators saying. There's nothing in the videos to suggest that Tate ever had possession, and certainly not before Jennings did, even if Tate got a hand around it after landing.
 
We were all talking about resident evil 6 the other day and I said I thought it would suck.

Gamespot just gave it a 4.5/10. That's just one site but damn.

I just don't see how anyone could have been excited for this game.

Resident Evil 4 sucks so this is no surprise.


So glad that the drama and pain of Monday Night can be put behind me. Now I can focus on how shitty our offense looks!
 
I think the idea of Kap throwing a pass terrifies Harbs. I wonder if his conservative nature will hurt him during his career in terms of developing a young QB

i'm not even sure that i consider harbs the sole reason for our conservative play.... we have guys going deep and in many instances open. maybe he drilled it into alex to not turn the ball over and now alex is just scared to pull the trigger.

seems like the only person also will throw at deep is VD. what a shame, our offense could be pretty good if we had a QB that wasn't scared to succeed
 

squicken

Member
Resident Evil 4 sucks so this is no surprise.


So glad that the drama and pain of Monday Night can be put behind me. Now I can focus on how shitty our offense looks!

I wouldn't worry too much. SEA, SF and CHI have excellent defenses, and once McCarthey did what everyone in the world thought he should do you moved the ball vs SEA. Should be 2-1 vs tough opening schedule, and still have inside track on division imo
 

squicken

Member
i'm not even sure that i consider harbs the sole reason for our conservative play.... we have guys going deep and in many instances open. maybe he drilled it into alex to not turn the ball over and now alex is just scared to pull the trigger.

seems like the only person also will throw at deep is VD. what a shame, our offense could be pretty good if we had a QB that wasn't scared to succeed

http://www.footballperspective.com/...into-the-anti-joe-namath-or-jim-harbaugh-2-0/

did you read that when I posted it awhile back? Thought it was pretty interesting
 
there is no way you actually believe RE4 sucks. i can't accept that. RE5 was a piece of shit unless you enjoy some rock punchin'
It was really mediocre. And I'm not trying to be "that" guy that hates on something that everyone likes after the fact. I was so excited for it to come out at the time and was completely underwhelmed . The first town environment was cool but it just went off the rails shortly therafter. I just barely managed to push through the game. Still haven't played 5 because of it.

I wouldn't worry too much. SEA, SF and CHI have excellent defenses, and once McCarthey did what everyone in the world thought he should do you moved the ball vs SEA. Should be 2-1 vs tough opening schedule, and still have inside track on division imo

I tend to agree. Next week should be a breath of fresh air going against the Saints' "defense".
 
It was really mediocre. And I'm not trying to be "that" guy that hates on something that everyone likes after the fact. I was so excited for it to come out at the time and was completely underwhelmed . Still haven't played 5 because of it.



I tend to agree. Next week should be a breath of fresh air going against the Saints' "defense".

your opinion is wrong though
 

Fox318

Member
We were all talking about resident evil 6 the other day and I said I thought it would suck.

Gamespot just gave it a 4.5/10. That's just one site but damn.

I just don't see how anyone could have been excited for this game.

With the way Capcom treats their employees I can't see them making a good game until they change management.
 

Kiryu

Member
It was really mediocre. And I'm not trying to be "that" guy that hates on something that everyone likes after the fact. I was so excited for it to come out at the time and was completely underwhelmed . The first town environment was cool but it just went off the rails shortly therafter. I just barely managed to push through the game. Still haven't played 5 because of it.



I tend to agree. Next week should be a breath of fresh air going against the Saints' "defense".
Yo I herd Drew Bree is pissed. . .

Which is more pissed-off QB? Aaron Rodger or Drew Bree
 

Greg

Member
there is no way you actually believe RE4 sucks. i can't accept that.
It doesn't suck, but I really didn't like it - especially compared to the older RE games.

I remember starting it, playing for 10 hours, and then coming back to it months later to finish it only because I had nothing else to play. The only things I remember enjoying about that game was that it looked fantastic, and the girl in the game didn't have 'complete fucking moron' AI like most games with escorts.
 

squicken

Member
yeah i read it. i also read an article last year about alex smith compared with andrew luck at stanford and they had a lot of similar numbers. i don't want to say identical, and even if they were identical its kind of an uneven comparison, but it's really harbaughs system.

I think Luck is the classic "can't mess up the great ones" talent. I doubt Phil Fulmer helped develop Peyton, though I'm sure Luck benefited from Harbs. But he's so much different than Alex was as a rookie, and he's got a moron coach to deal with as well
 

KaYotiX

Banned
dat salt.

Hey Fox is the htc 1x any good? I can get it for 1 bill if I extend my contract. My xperia is dying

i have the 1X and i like it alot, my wife nabbed the S3 last week and its also sexy. We moved on from iPhone 4s's. Just wanted something different.

Also so glad they got a deal done.
 
Aren't you the one that likes Joe Buck?

Isn't Joe Buck the one that brought the Packers to the Super Bowl? He was our beacon of light in a sea of darkness, at a time when our playoff hopes were receding farther than Joe Buck's hairline. I sacrificed my sanity and endured endless ridicule for the greater good of Packers GAF because it needed to be done.

Yes, I do
 

Kiryu

Member
Explain this shit.

ramon.jpg



RE4 sucks. Sorry. In the immortal words of FMT, I don't give a fuuuuuuuck.

We should be celebrating the return of Ed Hochuli's Gun Show instead of talking about some overhyped game. I've said my piece.

Can you back up that claim with some evidence?
Well you could see Drew Bree's frustration in post-game with Saints team after 3 loses.
 
I've never been this excited about the Texans season. I feel like we really do the best squad to make it to the SB as the AFC champion. Also I was at the Texans/Jags game a couple weeks ago and ran into a few Texans fans that actually came from Houston to watch the game. I felt like a bad fan because I've never been to Houston to watch a game.
 

Kiryu

Member
I've never been this excited about the Texans season. I feel like we really do the best squad to make it to the SB as the AFC champion. Also I was at the Texans/Jags game a couple weeks ago and ran into a few Texans fans that actually came from Houston to watch the game. I felt like a bad fan because I've never been to Houston to watch a game.
Calling Titans Upset Texans....

Kiss of the #1 rating.
 
Top Bottom