Aikman put up pedestrian numbers by any standard playing with HOF talents. I dont think he ever threw 20 TDs lol never mind yards td/int ratio etc..Yea but nobody could throw a Bang 8 post like Aikman (except Fouts).
In all seriousness, maybe the criteria for who gets in needs to change. Does post season success matter for a HOF bid? I assumed it does, and thus my opinion of Rivers' bid.
Edit: I just remembered who you are. Now I don't know what to do.