SuperBonk said:Wouldn't this mean that game critics also don't understand the market or the industry?
Did they ever?
They never did. Which is why review scores were, from the beginning, entirely worthless.
SuperBonk said:Wouldn't this mean that game critics also don't understand the market or the industry?
Did they ever?
Penguin said:I don't know how to phrase this, but I think this thread shows Nintendo doesn't need Zelda as a holiday title. I mean when you think about it Donkey Kong Country probably wouldn't have been most people's ideal choice for a holiday title before the success of New Super Mario Bros wii.
Nintendo had a stellar holiday season without a title with Mario in it and without a title with the word Wii in it (what the hell happened to Wii Party anyhow)
I think Nintendo doesn't need to rely on Mario and Zelda as much as they did during the Cube era.
Eternia said:Unit sales overall I suppose it did not, however, so far it had >15% decrease in sales while competing with apparently only one other big software release which was Black Ops, benefit of releasing during the holiday sales period, first new entry of the series on current hardware, and had close to the same number of days on sale as its predecessor.
Eternia said:I personally don't think it bombed or flopped in America but a huge IP continuing to trend downwards in two significant regions shouldn't be ignored or shrugged off with 'it still sold well enough'. Maybe it's too late to change the trend but that's something else entirely.
Stumpokapow said:FWIW since I've been name-called, here's a list of non-budgetware/non-shovelware third party Wii exclusives, or multiplatform games where the Wii version could conceivably be the one to get based on unique / exclusive features:
The Conduit 2 - February 2011
TrackMania Wii - February 2011
...
...
...
And the possibilities for distant support, titles to be localized, etc:
The Kore Gang - out in EU, no publisher in US, unlikely to come to US
Earth Seeker - Not announced for US release
Milestone Shooting Collection 2 - Not announced for US release
Inazuma Eleven Strikers - Not announced for US release.
Ikenie No Yoru (Balance board controller horror game by Marvelous) - Not announced for US release.
Dragon Quest Monster Battle Road - Not announced for US release
Dragon Quest X - 2011? 2012? Who knows.
The Grinder - I'll be very generous here. The current state of affairs is that we have a game that is supposed a multiplayer co-op horror FPS, that was Wii exclusive, then was PS360Wii, then was a Gauntlet style topdown game on the PS360 while remaining a multiplayer co-op horror FPS on the Wii. It's pretty generous of me to incude this here, since it's pretty clear no one has a clue what's going on with this.
Don't believe me? Check Amazon. Check GameFly. Check GameFAQs. Name a publisher and then check their release list. This is it. There's of course a handful of decent multiplatform titles (next up: You Don't Know Jack! <-- I'll be getting this for 360 on the grounds that I have 4 controllers for both Wii and 360 and the 360 version is, frankly, likely to be better and have a better chance at DLC support)
Retro and Sora won't have anything for holiday 2011 on Wii. They've got plenty of B titles like Rhythm Heaven, Fatal Frame, Last Story and Mario Sports. And I'm sure plenty of new stuff will come out at E3 just like it did last year.apana said:Well care to tell me what that holiday 2011 game could be if it's not Zelda? We at least knew that Retro or Project Sora were working on something. People had speculated on Donkey Kong and Kic Icarus revivals also. Pikmin/Starfox/Diddy Kong Racing probably couldn't be a holiday game. Wii Relax is a definite possiblity but Nintendo would need to balance it with a "core" game.
apana said:The original Donkey Kong Country sold better than any Zelda game ever. They already avoided using Zelda by sending out DKCR this christmas, they can't just send out someone from the B or C list for the holidays.
SuperBonk said:Wouldn't this mean that game critics also don't understand the market or the industry?
Balb said:Most Mario games do sell pretty well. That doesn't really explain why Mario Kart is so popular though.
Depends on the context. Games intended for the core that metacrit below the 80s rarely become hits.jman2050 said:They never did. Which is why review scores were, from the beginning, entirely worthless.
Didn't Sega say the next Mario & Sonic won't be an Olympics offshoot?Mockingbird said:What of Mario & Sonic at the Olympic Games 3 for Wii? Sega's the publisher.
Aaron Strife said:Didn't Sega say the next Mario & Sonic won't be an Olympics offshoot?
If it isn't a platformer they're blowing a huge opportunity.
Both of those assertions are completely false. Of course the Move and Kinect are in direct competition. They are both new motion control systems released at the same time for competing systems. They couldn't possibly be MORE in direct competition than they are.Vinci said:No one with a clue outside of console fanboy wankery considered Kinect and Move in direct competition with one another, or that Move would come anywhere close competing with Kinect even in a vague way. The fact that MS keeps harping on it just comes off as immature as hell.
kame-sennin said:Not necessarily. The problem with metacritic is that the review scores are derived from the most avid core gamers. They represent the most demanding customers in the entire market. Developers and publishers value their reviews because they know that satisfying the most demanding customers usually means that the rest of the market will be satisfied as well. The problem is that in any industry, the needs of the most demanding customers eventually overshoot the needs of the least demanding customers. They demand features that the rest of the market either doesn't care about, or worse, finds to complex to use. Further, many products that would please the low-end of the market simply do not meet the standards of demanding customers, and thus are considered to be low quality.
The problem is that, in most markets, the low-end makes up the majority of the market, so following your best customers can lead you off a cliff. The metacritic score for Wii Sports is 76, yet Wii Sports is the biggest killer app of the generation - perhaps of any generation. If we went by general customer excitement, the score would be in the high 90s. But because Wii Sports was designed for low-end customers, it fails to meet the demands of high-end game reviewers (simple graphics, no character movement control, no online, ect). There's nothing wrong with developers and publishers using metacritic when designing games for their most demanding customers. But if they want to make games with mass appeal, especially games on Wii for low-end customers, then they should understand that game reviewers are simply not qualified to make an accurate assessment of the game's marketability. It doesn't mean that the Wii market is "unpredictable", it means that the needs of game reviewers does not reflect the needs of the Wii market.
Maxwell House said:They should have rebadged a ton of the japan market 360 units to america. Of course, that might have only amounted to like a hundred thousand units but that would be a hundred thousand more sales.
Penguin said:I don't know how to phrase this, but I think this thread shows Nintendo doesn't need Zelda as a holiday title. I mean when you think about it Donkey Kong Country probably wouldn't have been most people's ideal choice for a holiday title before the success of New Super Mario Bros wii.
Nintendo had a stellar holiday season without a title with Mario in it and without a title with the word Wii in it (what the hell happened to Wii Party anyhow)
MYE said:I dont want that blue piece of shit tainting my Mario platformers.
FUCK OFF SONIC
"About one fifth of PS3 sales included bundles with Sonys Move controller, suggesting a modest third month (we have chosen not to subscribe to peripheral data). About half of Xbox 360 sales included bundles with Microsofts Kinect peripheral, as Xbox 360 Kinect console bundles outsold PS3 Move console bundles by 5:1," Pachter said.
"Microsoft announced that it has shipped 8 million Kinect units since launch (in November), which was raised from its earlier goal of 5 million. More significantly, in our view, the top two selling Kinect software titles outsold the top two Move titles by over 13:1."
itxaka said:wow. I expected Kinect to success but I didn't expect it to do so good. MS has a hit in their hands if they manage it correctly. Can they do it?
Has any other games aparts from launch ones, appear for Kinect? Seems like the market is there but it needs a more steady releases. Only the launch games are out in the last 2 months aren't they?
Boney said:Retro and Sora won't have anything for holiday 2011 on Wii. They've got plenty of B titles like Rhythm Heaven, Fatal Frame, Last Story and Mario Sports. And I'm sure plenty of new stuff will come out at E3 just like it did last year.
And sweet jesus at that graph.
you seem to have forgotten Kevin Butler's ads.Vinci said:No one with a clue outside of console fanboy wankery considered Kinect and Move in direct competition with one another, or that Move would come anywhere close competing with Kinect even in a vague way. The fact that MS keeps harping on it just comes off as immature as hell.
szaromir said:I didn't see MS mentioning Move in their PR releases? How are they harping on it?
Mockingbird said:You forgot Samurai Warriors 3 Moushouden. It should be different enough from the PS3 version.
What of Mario & Sonic at the Olympic Games 3 for Wii? Sega's the publisher.
Stumpokapow said:FWIW since I've been name-called, here's a list of non-budgetware/non-shovelware third party Wii exclusives, or multiplatform games where the Wii version could conceivably be the one to get based on unique / exclusive features:
The Conduit 2 - February 2011
TrackMania Wii - February 2011
...
And the possibilities for distant support, titles to be localized, etc:
The Kore Gang - out in EU, no publisher in US, unlikely to come to US
wazoo said:Just to nitpick, Trackmania is out in EU.
Whats the source of the numbers for MS/Sony? The whole entertainment division? Are they based on console sales?TunaLover said:
Graphs normally are just a bunch of cold data, but this one is different, just look that beautifull curves, a work of art.
wazoo said:Just to nitpick, Trackmania is out in EU.
This put even more shame to list of future releases for the Wii.
Aaron Strife said:Didn't Sega say the next Mario & Sonic won't be an Olympics offshoot?
If it isn't a platformer they're blowing a huge opportunity.
Gadfly said:you seem to have forgotten Kevin Butler's ads.
Nintendo will never allow another company to develop a platformer with Mario.Aaron Strife said:Didn't Sega say the next Mario & Sonic won't be an Olympics offshoot?
If it isn't a platformer they're blowing a huge opportunity.
This already kind of happened 20 years ago.Chris1964 said:Nintendo will never allow another company to develop a platformer with Mario.
wrowa said:This already kind of happened 20 years ago.
confuziz said:What is your point? No matter what you guys say this thing will keep on selling to 110-120 million in the next few years. I mean, we are talking about the sales here since this is a SALES thread right?
Gamecocks625 said:Kind of crazy to see Sony go down in a blaze of glory after the good ol' years of the PS1 and PS2.
Looks like it's an Apple/Nintendo future with Microsoft taking the rest of Sony's pie.
"since FY/E 1998" ;-)Kenka said:I must be reading this wrong.
Or maybe Sony did indeed lose all its treasure chests it gathered from 1994 to 2006 when the PlayStation 3 started to sink.
edit : there must be something wrong though : Nintendo has probably earned a lot more than 2 billions and something with the GB, the NES and the SNES or maybe even the N64 from 1983 onwards.
edit 2 : are the numbers inajusted to inflation ?
Entertainment division in the case of MS and Sony, entire Nintendo for Nintendo ( basically they do only videogames ).infinityBCRT said:Whats the source of the numbers for MS/Sony? The whole entertainment division? Are they based on console sales?
Source?pgtl_10 said:Maroikart is simple, fun, easy to get into and if you work with it you'll master it. It really the predecessor to Smash in concept.
Also those posts comparing GT to Mariokart. From my understanding Mariokart was either the best selling GCN or one of the best. Officially it outsold Melee but I'm not sure if it counts bundles.
Stumpokapow said:Yeah, I thought about mentioning that. It was supposed to be out in NA months ago but it suffered some weird last minute delays.
Stumpokapow said:Yes, sales. Including software sales. And what that means for support. And if third parties are making the right decisions or not. And what will drive new owners in the coming years.
The train of conversation was very clear here:
- Claim: "Third parties should pay more attention to the Wii on the basis of Epic Mickey / Just Dance 2 sales"
- Counter-Claim: "But they're not. Whether that's a good move or not, they simply aren't."
- The list, which is evidence used to evaluate the claim and counterclaim.
On the other hand, I'm not sure what your point is. The Wii is going to sell lots of hardware worldwide? Duh. Everyone knows that. Why repeat it? To remind the "Wii haters" how "pwnt" they are?
confuziz said:Nintendo doesn't care about them (3rd party software sales), they will get their money anyways, so why should we care?
Pureauthor said:Nonsense.
A company's goal is not to make a profit, it's to maximise profit. The dearth of 3rd party games and sales has demonstrably hurt the Wii in terms of how long it can remain a viable platform on the market worldwide, and Nintendo did not want that to happen.
The Wii is selling well, but it's not selling as well as it could be, and that's what matters to Nintendo.
confuziz said:Nintendo doesn't care about them (3rd party software sales), they will get their money anyways, so why should we care?
I think making a list like that was just to show the Wii only gamers how screwed they are atm if they want non-nintendo games this year.
Also, the dumbest people in the world could have guessed that was going to happen, so why the need to show it?
Stumpokapow said:Look, if you think I have an angle (which presumably based on the degree to which you're pressing me on this, would be some sort of anti-Wii pro-Sony angle or something), go ahead and call me out on it instead of beating around the bush.
Stumpokapow said:Yeah, I thought about mentioning that. It was supposed to be out in NA months ago but it suffered some weird last minute delays.
TunaLover said:http://i55.tinypic.com/95wwi1.png[IMG]
Graphs normally are just a bunch of cold data, but this one is different, just look that beautifull curves, a work of art.[/QUOTE]I've known it before but it really is genius how Nintendo has always been cashing it in so hard during the N64 and GC days
Teetris said:I've known it before but it really is genius how Nintendo has always been cashing it in so hard during the N64 and GC days
Zune, Kin Phone etc. Who would have thought a couple of years ago that the 360 would be keeping that division from collapsing?HocusPocus said:Hrmm. The losses for Microsoft are about what they make in profit each quarter. Looks like they getting better with all their entertainment products over the last 4 years. Xbox 360 is a money maker so I'm not sure what's still holding down their profits.
confuziz said:The 3DS is coming and I'm sure they got their new console ready as well. I don't think they care too much really.