SwiftDeath
Member
No it's not mathematically possible because MK8 is on 1 system so how the hell would it chart higher than a game that sold more than it did on 1 platform?
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
NPD Sales Results for May 2014 [Up1: Wii U Hardware]
- Thread starter Nirolak
- Start date
No it's not mathematically possible because MK8 is on 1 system so how the hell would it chart higher than a game that sold more than it did on 1 platform?
"Mario Kart 8 came in as the No. 3 best-selling software SKU in May."
NPD orders platforms by sales. So for Watch_Dogs: PS4 SKU > XBO SKU > 360 SKU > PS3 SKU > PC SKU.
Because MK8 is #2 in NPD as a single SKU, its SKU numbers must be higher than #3 - #10 in NPD.
Therefore, the only SKUs that could be greater than MK8 is PS4 Watch_Dogs and XBO Watch_Dogs.
This. There's no other way it makes sense.
Jimmyfenix
Member
We really need numbers to change the flow of this thread.
September , October & November will be the results i am looking forward to.
No. MK8 outsold all combined SKUs of MLB, so it's not possible.
Habib Marwan
Banned
lol wow, good point haha I'm a dumbass
FinalStageBoss
Banned
Doesn't look like we're getting any #'s. Oh well
Karsticles
Member
I learned it from watching the MLP documentary on Netflix, in my defense...
shinra-bansho
Member
MK8 at third best selling SKU is higher than the sum of MLB, it's impossible for one of its SKUs to be the second highest SKU. It's Watch_Dogs XBO as Aquamarine has shown.
It would have charted above MK if true.
Yeah, and the new $399 SKU is missing the one big thing that differentiated it from the PS4. There's no evidence to suggest that "Xbox should win June or something is wrong".
JetBlackPanda
Member
I guess I don't understand what is happening. isn't MK8 being #2 with only 2 days of sales pretty good?
Orthogonal
Member
"Mario Kart 8 came in as the No. 3 best-selling software SKU in May."
NPD orders platforms by sales. So for Watch_Dogs: PS4 SKU > XBO SKU > 360 SKU > PS3 SKU > PC SKU.
Because MK8 is #2 in NPD as a single SKU, its SKU numbers must be higher than #3 - #10 in NPD.
Therefore, the only SKUs that could be greater than MK8 is PS4 Watch_Dogs and XBO Watch_Dogs.
It's interesting to see how much the lack of Digital sales skews the results as well. From the Watch Dogs PC scandal thread someone posted that Ubi financial report has sales of PC as the number 1 platform for Watchdogs.
Would love to konw how much MK8 did in digital, probably fairly well.
Not possible. Read Aqua's explanation again. There are no other games that could be greater the MK8 because it is placed number 2 overall.
Is that from a Final Bosman show?
SDCowboy
Member
Well yeah, the PS4 will likely still win June easily, but if the lower priced Xbone SKU doesn't noticeably increase the sales, that would be extremely troubling.
JetBlackPanda
Member
no its literally Nintendo right after E3.
Pound_lb003
Member
So we need sales numbers for MK8, to get an idea of how well Watch Dogs sold on next gen.
reptilescorpio
Member
Watch Dogs only came out like 2 days before MK8 so not sure why that's shocking.
The PS4 version is likely to have been quite a high percentage of the sales, in the UK it took 49% of the sales compared to 27% on the X1 (and lower again for 360/PS3)
360/PS3 could have only been 30ish% of the Watch Dogs sales.
nope, that's NoA
Rich, formerly of IGN, tweeted it actually
https://twitter.com/GCNStorm/status/477246240971702273
it's funny (or sad) because all three current gen consoles have both a chalkboard and a standing outside in the rain pic (PS4 in Japan)
SwiftDeath
Member
For what platform?
Mike Works
Member
Are we seriously not going to get actual hardware numbers this month?
Crimson_Gold
Member
No one is talking and the cream hasn't arrived yet
Poimandres
Member
What does everyone think for Wii U sales next month? I'm going with 80K from the rest of the MK bump.
PhoenixDawn
Member
I'd be highly surprised if there wasn't. The Luigi Death Stare going viral didn't happen until after launch (June) plus they had an excellent E3 showing in which a lot of their games, admittedly coming out in the distant future, were trending on the internet (Twitter, Facebook) so the Wii U definitely had a much higher public awareness than it usually does.
AgentP
Thinks mods influence posters politics. Promoted to QAnon Editor.
I don't see how the data says that, I must be missing a piece. You only know sum (W_D) > MK8, how do you know about any single SKU in WD? If all W_D SKUs sold 10m each and MK8 was 5m, how would the list change (assuming #3 was <5m)?
SDCowboy
Member
I'm guessing 75K. I don't think it will be much different than May.
Oh, that's awesome. Hope they make those a Club Nintendo reward or purchasable item! :lol
AcademicSaucer
Member
UK is the last place we should use to measure the popularity of nintendo games ...
And yes, its good for mario kart , but its not going to save the wii u
"2 days of Mario Kart 8 sales" was on the chalkboard?
June is 5 weeks, so if it was flat to May (4 weeks), that'd be 80K. A MK bump would put it over that somewhere.
Relaxed Muscle
Member
I'm still waiting for Kojima to cancel the PS3/X360 version of MGSV. I know is coming.
reptilescorpio
Member
Yeah it's funny rather than sad, it's just a bit of fun for sales threads. No one actually thinks Nintendo/MS/Sony are going out of business any time soon.
SwiftDeath
Member
So of individual Platform SKUs MK8 is third which makes PS4 WD and XB1 WD 1 and 2 respectively
Canis lupus
Member
what are you doing swiftdeath, staahp
Don't be shocked, PS360 versions probably made up 1/5th of the sales like in the UK.
Captain Smoker
Member
That's true, but the question is if it's going to translate into sales.
Highest spike is June 11 (during E3)
Second highest spike is May 31 (right after Mario Kart 8 launch)
Google Trends - USA only
last gen systems still have long legs, for many publishers, specially square enix is difficult to ignore an install base of 120+ million consoles, theres plenty of people that usually upgrade to a new console late in the life cycle so im sure it will move enough copies to make a profit
shinra-bansho
Member
Depends. Taking out the "Mario Kart factor" for May using tales from my ass mathematics, being flat would probably put it more at 50K, so something like 85K would probably already factor in some level of sustained increase or alternatively a diminishing impact over the course of the month (e.g. 30, 20, 15, 10, 10.)
Even at $350 I doubt it will change much at this point.
Killing_Joke
Member
PS4 SW and HW still killing it.
Wii U....I really expected a bigger bump. The 2 days excuse is weak. Even if it hits 100k in June (which i doubt), the May bump should have been bigger. #2 selling game for the month and only 60k? There's no games pushing this system. It's absolutely crazy.
X1.... I need to see this number. Dat tweet. Anything below 100k will blow my mind.
Wii U....I really expected a bigger bump. The 2 days excuse is weak. Even if it hits 100k in June (which i doubt), the May bump should have been bigger. #2 selling game for the month and only 60k? There's no games pushing this system. It's absolutely crazy.
X1.... I need to see this number. Dat tweet. Anything below 100k will blow my mind.
reptilescorpio
Member
I'll go for 70k, not sure what's releasing next month tbh.
PsychoSoldier
Banned
As much as I get that we're not owed anything and that NPD data is proprietary, it's still disappointing we have to wait around for leaks for any substantive numbers.
Not for system warz or anything like that, just because I find data fascinating in general.
Not for system warz or anything like that, just because I find data fascinating in general.
