Reasons for lynching Seath:
- 1. Confirms or deconfirms he's a God
- 2. Prevents anyone else, such as Kyanrute, from playing the same way as him because they think we won't lynch him.
- 3. He's already lied about his role twice and refuses to roleclaim despite hinting at a role he's unlikely to achieve now that he's hinted at it.
- 4. We should have done it on Day 3 anyhow instead of letting him dance around the issue and mock us.
- 5. If he's un-lynchable, it confirms nobody else is a God.
Reason against lynching Seath:
- He might be un-lynchable.
- He might be a townie.
Got any other reasons beyond those two that we shouldn't lynch him? Do you believe Seath is a townie? Anyone else believe he's a townie?
1. What is the benefit to this?
2. There can only be 1 Peripseros, so this shouldn't stop us lynching anyone else. Lets say we lynched Kyan and he is indeed Peripseros. Well ok you got your god confirmation and we can just as easily lynch Seath tomorrow.
3. Lynch All Liars is a weak strategy, especially so in Gafia. I don't doubt he is scum, that isn't the point or a benefit to lynching him today.
4. No we shouldn't, this isn't a benefit.
5. This is the same point as number 1. Its a description of what you want to do rather than an explanation as to why.
Reasons not to:
A. He is Peripseros, so we might be able to remove him without wasting a lynch.
B. We get rewards for removing someone today if we bet on it. This gives us another opportunity for a mass claim, plus whatever benefits the rewards give us. We need all the help we can get at the moment.
C. We have to find all the scum without missing to win. One of the scum is Peripseros, so it doesn't matter whether we hit that one today or any other day (whether its Seath or not). I'd rather we tried actual scumhunting today as we lose another confirmed townie tonight.