One of Them Has to Go

Which Company Would You Sacrifice?

  • Total voters
    607
adamsapple said:
I think adding just "Bethesda" is reductive. Bethesda is a publisher that has multiple developers, From, R* and ND are all developers, not publishers.

If the poll had Bethesdsa Games Studio, that'd make more sense.
Click to expand...
Yes it would. Even then though my view remains the same.
 
Last edited:
Touch choice, but I don't play many From games.
 
Rocinante618 said:
Naughty Dog easy, all other have had a huge impact in the industry as well as culture - GTA, Elder Scrolls and Souls all are incredible and their own genre. What game has ND made that has non gaming casuals know about it? Nothing.
Click to expand...
Agents Of Shield Marvel GIF by ABC Network
 
Even a declared Bethesda (Studio, not the publisher that has id) like me sees more value in those games than every R* game combined aside the first RDR.
 
Naughty Dog for sure. They're were relevant up to the PS3 with Crash, Jak and Daxter, Uncharted, then Last of Us. They havent done anything great since then, just remake after remake after remake.
From Software is my 2nd choice. They ruined the gaming space introducing the "Souls Like" genre. Now every game wants to be a souls like.
 
It's between Rockstar and Bethesda.
Rockstar - I've never been into GTA, RDR was beautiful yet very, very boring
Bethesda - I've had good times with Fallout but their games are utterly lazy bank and Todd Howard is possible the biggest bullshitter in an industry of bullshitters.
 
Its pretty funny seeing the hate for Naughty Dog who literally haven't made a bad game in forever.

TLOU2 really broke some people's brains... like TDS level!
 
Only one of them brought into the gaming world shitty DLC with horse armor. Hopefully they go out of buisness soon, just yank that chain & let that turd slip away down the drain.
 
ND has never made a bad game and yet are winning the poll, they are making a brand new IP. Lol at voting for them.

FROM has made the same game over and over, and now everyone is copying them, they've essentially dumbed gaming down to a bunch of generic "action" games with NO SUBSTANCE/NO FLASH/NO STYLE. Their combat sucks. Their graphics are laughable. Their stories suck. Everything they make sucks.

BETHESDA hasn't made a good game in years. Starfield was amateur hour shit. Not a single screenshot for The next Elders Scroll, announced 8 fucking years ago.

ROCKSTAR is Rockstar. Lmao at anyone voting for them with GTA6 on the horizon. It will be the most revolutionary open world game since GTA3.

There is only one answer, its FROM. Because Bethesda is bad, but at least no one else is copying them.
 
Last edited:
It a toss up between bethesda and naughty dog.

But heres the thing: i actually loved skyrim, whereas i couldnt give a single flying fuck about the last of us
 
Represent. said:
ND has never made a bad game and yet are winning the poll, they are making a brand new IP. Lol at voting for them.

FROM has made the same game over and over, and now everyone is copying them, they've essentially dumbed gaming down to a bunch of generic "action" games with NO SUBSTANCE/NO FLASH/NO STYLE. Their combat sucks. Their graphics are laughable. Their stories suck. Everything they make sucks.

BETHESDA hasn't made a good game in years. Starfield was amateur hour shit. Not a single screenshot for The next Elders Scroll, announced 8 fucking years ago.

ROCKSTAR is Rockstar. Lmao at anyone voting for them with GTA6 on the horizon. It will be the most revolutionary open world game since GTA3.

There is only one answer, its FROM. Because Bethesda is bad, but at least no one else is copying them.
Click to expand...
Your take on ND is solid.
Your take on FROM is possibly the worst thing I've ever read.
I didn't keep reading.
 
bethesda
they dont make anything good anymore, and skyrim sucked too

was tempted to say rockstar though
one GTA every decade?
theyre turning into valve where they just make money from online crap
 
From Soft can go. I don't really like anything they do. I suffered my way through Elden Ring.
Jury is still out on Intergalactic. Naughtydog could win me back.
I would miss the other two if they went away.
 
Clear said:
Its pretty funny seeing the hate for Naughty Dog who literally haven't made a bad game in forever.

TLOU2 really broke some people's brains... like TDS level!
Click to expand...
Yes! it's fucking ridiculous, besides they always push the envelope in graphics, animation, sound, performance capture, voice acting has always been topnotch.
People lost their shit with the last of us part2, and never recovered and their irrational hate for Neil Druckman it's even more ludicrous, these are highly emotional whiny little bitches.
I have tried Bethesda games, And they always come short and boring to me. I dont like their games, but I would not want any company to go, fucking sun comes out for everybody.

Ms Pat GIF by BET Plus
 
Last edited:
vaibhavpisal said:
Elden Ring is like, my no 1 GOAT title.

And somehow have zero desire to play its expansion.

I guess putting a lot of hours into it did that.
Click to expand...
Yeah, I still need to finish the main game. I got to the (Ice?) giant part after the capital. It's fun, but I have a lot of other games and limited time to play them.
 
Naughty Dog easily.
With the other studios I feel like they have potential to create new and or exciting games that can surprise me.
Naughty Dog has settled into a place where a good chunk of the industry moved towards. TV/Movie script Cinematics.
They do it very well, but I can get that fix from almost anywhere now.
 
Bethesda, ND still has very tight gameplay, at least they did five years ago, it's been a long time hasn't it. Bethesda hasn't made anything great since Skyrim. The other two shouldn't even be on the list.
 
Last edited:
Magic Carpet said:
From Soft can go. I don't really like anything they do. I suffered my way through Elden Ring.
Jury is still out on Intergalactic. Naughtydog could win me back.
I would miss the other two if they went away.
Click to expand...
Intergalactic could be a huge awesome hit if they do the 80s verse theme, style culture, and art well. I'm curious about that game too even as someone that was never a fan of naughty dogs.

Just checked all of Fromsoft games on google and none of them are great or at least none interests me at all so yeah I'll pick them too.

GTA VI, Fallout 5, and Elder Scrolls VI would be the top 3 best and greatest games of all times. Witcher 4 could come close too but still won't be as great as those three. At least Witcher 4 would still mop the floor with everything naughty dog and fromsoft does.
 
ND makes serious violence childish and silly in the Uncharted series and TLoU 2 was way, way too depressing and just plain not enjoyable. Hopefully their new IP falls right in the middle but for now, they get my vote.
 
Bethesda.

I'm a big fan of Fallout 3 & 4, but Obsidian could take over Fallout for them.

I'm a big fan of Skyrim, but Warhorse Studios' more grounded take on the open-world medieval immersive sim with Kingdom Come Deliverance 2 puts Bethesda's to shame.

Unless Bethesda pulls off a miracle with their next game, I think their best years are behind them.
 
Currently ND even tho i loved all their games except tlou2, once they get rid of cuckman and start making games that cater to males again i will show up again :)
 
From Software.
P5AAUXwrLTvsQhWX.jpeg


With a statement from Miyazaki saying that gamers want easier games, with the best graphics, cinematic cutscenes, yellow paint everywhere, and NPCs/characters outright telling you the puzzle solutions and exactly what to do next. Gamers want GaaS, MTXs, season passes, dailies and gacha mechanics..... there is no place in this industry and medium for From Software.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Y’all got any of them
12
181
powder replied
Raccoon City or Silent Hill - You must go to one of them, which do you choose and why?
2
50
2K
Connificent replied
Trials of Mana: Don't team members use their abilities? And a question about which pts to attribute to them.
3
81
ReyBrujo replied
GoG announced One Click Mod. Curated selections of mods at one click.
32
748
Gonzito replied
Call of Duty WW2 On PC GamePass has an RCE exploit that lets people show them explicit content, shut downs their computer, and random pop ups.
2
50
580
DryvBy replied
Top Bottom