Been looking at your page and I think you need more variety in pictures since the selfies ahoy aren't really doing you any favors. There's something about selfies/mirror shots that I personally don't like/find trite so I use a self-timer to take pictures of myself as you saw in some of my pictures. You're definitely not ugly by any means. I dunno why dudes on GAF like to downplay their looks so much as if it helps them in an ironic way.
As for your profile itself, I think you can leave a few sections blank such as"The First Thing People Notice About Me" and "Most private thing section." Also, I noticed some lack of proper capitalization such as Good Vibrations by Marky Mark and the Funky Bunch.
And personally, I would leave out video games but if you want to leave it in, then that's totally fine as well since ultimately your profile caters to a specific group of girls that will love that stuff.
Thanks dude! It's always nice to put a face gaffers so sorry about okcipid stalking a bit. I definitely need to get some new pics on there. I'm going to a wedding tomorrow so hopefully I can get a few pics of me in public dressed nice. If it not. I'll totally do the photo timer thing you mentioned haha. I figured dropping the video game thing was okay since it was sorta in passing and I only mentioned it once. I'll think of something clever for the "first thing people notice about me" section. It's kinda lazy. I appreciate the review!