Only one scum left most likely. Probably another neutral as well, but they don't matter at this point.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Overwatch Mafia |OT| Keep Your Vote On The Payload
- Thread starter Sorian
- Start date
You didn't think Cabot still being here was strange? Confirmed town, unknown PR, discussion leader.wat?
I don't understand what happened to Zeke if nin is indeed scum.
I say we lynch Cabot first though. He's been keenly pointing out "if nin is killed it confirms me!" for days, even though he'd be a top NK candidate even without the cop check. It was all for the sake of justifying his and nin's continued survival.
Interesting. Fran do you just have bad reading ability or are you missing the scum on purpose
Just bad reading it seems. But I was right with Eze, so give me some credit. Cherry Bomb dissapering for the entire phase threw me off. One would expect a mafia player to be at least a little participative and her companions asking for help.
For the record I switched Mazre with Kingkitty.
And I think AB hit one scum. It's the only way it make sense his death. Also we can confirm Splinter and melon.
I would like to hear from Blarg but I'm voting Stanley this day.
AB was a big target throughout almost every day, so it's pretty likely scum NK'd him.
On the other hand, it seems pretty likely that he targeted to hide behind scum and died immediately.
The PM literally says if he chose to hide behind scum, he dies immediately.
Yes that proves he could have hidden behind scum and died. He'd only be NKed if scum knew he want hiding behind someone which is very unlikely.
You didn't think Cabot still being here was strange? Confirmed town, unknown PR, discussion leader.
I don't understand what happened to Zeke if nin is indeed scum.
I say we lynch Cabot first though. He's been keenly pointing out "if nin is killed it confirms me!" for days, even though he'd be a top NK candidate even without the cop check. It was all for the sake of justifying his and nin's continued survival.
You've been dead wrong all games lover. I can buy you being wrong one more time.
I don't see how that's relevant to the conversation.You've been dead wrong all games lover. I can buy you being wrong one more time.
You didn't think Cabot still being here was strange? Confirmed town, unknown PR, discussion leader.
I don't understand what happened to Zeke if nin is indeed scum.
I say we lynch Cabot first though. He's been keenly pointing out "if nin is killed it confirms me!" for days, even though he'd be a top NK candidate even without the cop check. It was all for the sake of justifying his and nin's continued survival.
He just seemed like typical town cabot so the check solidified it to me. The lack of a NK is also weird.
Absolut if you don't respond in time: please check one of Cherry, Blarg, and Stan
I would like to see if AB followed this advise. Cherry was mafia and I don't see Blarg been scum after his bold play yesterday so I'm leaning Stanley.
I don't see how that's relevant to the conversation.
It isn't but it'll bring me joy
I can see that being suspicious if you haven't read the rest of the game.The night ends and Splinter immediately goes "Hey gus, let's kill Cabot. Like let's really really kill Cabot. Y'know cause he's scum and all."
Nothing suspicious here at all.
The night ends and Splinter immediately goes "Hey gus, let's kill Cabot. Like let's really really kill Cabot. Y'know cause he's scum and all."
Nothing suspicious here at all.
AB cleared Splinter so I'm willing to believe he and melon are town.
The lack of NK is interesting, worth investigating I think.He just seemed like typical town cabot so the check solidified it to me. The lack of a NK is also weird.
He posted after that to explicitly rule it out.I would like to see if AB followed this advise. Cherry was mafia and I don't see Blarg been scum after his bold play yesterday so I'm leaning Stanley.
Wow I skipped right over the bolded. Fuck that noise. Cabot/nin can wait.I would like to see if AB followed this advise. Cherry was mafia and I don't see Blarg been scum after his bold play yesterday so I'm leaning Stanley.
VOTE: Blargonaut
I'm not gonna fight it, we're in a good position. My top scum is Fran.
Good luck.
Go after fran. Feel free to Lynch me in order to clear Cabot or vice versa. The thing is though. You lynch either me or Cabot and the one that is not lynched will likely get nk.
Other than a big told you so you will be at the same position that you are today.
The hider targeted you or Cabot last night and now he's dead. Ignoring that information is the only thing that's "retarded"Hurts to see that *splinter is indeed confirmed town. his bad play is now solidified by him being confirmed. But sorry mate. This won't you get a free pass for trying to Lynch Cabot. sorry but that's retarded.
I'm not gonna fight it, we're in a good position. My top scum is Fran.
Good luck.
We have a leverage so if everyone want to lynch me I'm good. I'm just a town switcher and I haven't lied, all the switchs are what I said. If all of you want confirmation I'm ok.
I still think Stanley is the remaining scum. Maybe someone can gives us more info because there was no NK last night. If there is a roleblocker we can finish this now.
Blarg was trying to make a tie. I guess Sorian chose not to count his unvote? But if that unvote had counted (and I hadn't voted) it would have been a tie.Stupid as it was, wasn't Blarg part of the reason we got another scum member?
Wow I skipped right over the bolded. Fuck that noise. Cabot/nin can wait.
VOTE: Blargonaut
Are you saying Blarg threw Cherry under the bus? Because he was the one who forced the vote on her.
melonrabbit
Member
I'm leaning Fran or Blarg.
Cherry seemed like she was sacrificed to clear some scum hiding as "town". Her lack of response and willingness to be lynched is very troubling to me. I think we should keep that in mind with the decision we make today.
I will be away until this evening but will try my best to keep up with the thread.
Cherry seemed like she was sacrificed to clear some scum hiding as "town". Her lack of response and willingness to be lynched is very troubling to me. I think we should keep that in mind with the decision we make today.
I will be away until this evening but will try my best to keep up with the thread.
Blarg posted gifs and voted wherever he could tie the vote. He didn't force a lynch on anyone.Are you saying Blarg threw Cherry under the bus? Because he was the one who forced the vote on her.
Blarg was trying to make a tie. I guess Sorian chose not to count his unvote? But if that unvote had counted (and I hadn't voted) it would have been a tie.
I'm guessing Sorian didn't count it because it was Unvote: Ty4on when his vote was on Cherry.
Yeah I had to reread the rules to see if it was even debatable.I'm guessing Sorian didn't count it because it was Unvote: Ty4on when his vote was on Cherry.
Personally I'd've counted it (or mod-killed for intentional misuse of highlight tag).
Fran being a scum switcher gives us an alternative explanation for AB's death. I'm not entirely against testing that first.If Splinter is cleared, then my top scum would have to be either fran or stanley.
Blarg posted gifs and voted wherever he could tie the vote. He didn't force a lynch on anyone.
He unvoted Tyon before deadline. All the 3 votes were at the same time.
It could be him lynching her to get town credit. Maybe that's why he didn't post all day. He could have been waiting for her to talk in the scum thread?
No, his vote was on Cherry. "Unvote: Ty4on" was misdirection, and Sorian chose not to count the unvote.He unvoted Tyon before deadline. All the 3 votes were at the same time.
It could be him lynching her to get town credit. Maybe that's why he didn't post all day. He could have been waiting for her to talk in the scum thread?
Mazre and myself swung the vote yesterday (it's a shame we are both already confirmed -.-)I wouldn't be against a fran or Blarg lynch today. Leaning fran because of switcher stuff and Blarg sorta saving me yesterday.
But why would "saving" you be suspicious anyway?
Fran being a scum switcher gives us an alternative explanation for AB's death. I'm not entirely against testing that first.
But I couldn't target AB. I can switch individual targets so I can only switch his targets. My switch goes before his hide but his action is still in place. So if I target AB I just switch him with someone else and then he hide behind his target. To kill AB I should know his target and switch it with a scum.
Right, so the accusation is that you switched either Cabot or nin with scum.But I couldn't target AB. I can switch individual targets so I can only switch his targets. My switch goes before his hide but his action is still in place. So if I target AB I just switch him with someone else and then he hide behind his target. To kill AB I should know his target and switch it with a scum.
The fact that I have to explain this means either Fran is town and hadn't considered this or he's scum and playing dumb. I'm really not hopeful about our chances on a Fran lynch.
Mazre and myself swung the vote yesterday (it's a shame we are both already confirmed -.-)
But why would "saving" you be suspicious anyway?
Not suspicious, but weird for a scummate to do.
No, his vote was on Cherry. "Unvote: Ty4on" was misdirection, and Sorian chose not to count the unvote.
Fuck. I didn't realize that. I saw he did it before but I didn't realize the second time.
Just realised I misread your post. Fair enough, but I disagree he was trying to save you.Not suspicious, but weird for a scummate to do.
Right, so the accusation is that you switched either Cabot or nin with scum.
The fact that I have to explain this means either Fran is town and hadn't considered this or he's scum and playing dumb. I'm really not hopeful about our chances on a Fran lynch.
We don't know who he targeted. That's why I wanted him to give us one between 3 options. As there could be only one scum I'm hoping he played more aggresively and targeted someone he thought scum.
Just realised I misread your post. Fair enough, but I disagree he was trying to save you.
Yeah, I didn't think about trying to create a tie last night.
He told us he was going back to his original plan (ie. Cabot or nin). Doing anything else after that would be inviting a disaster.We don't know who he targeted. That's why I wanted him to give us one between 3 options. As there could be only one scum I'm hoping he played more aggresively and targeted someone he thought scum.
I'm just wondering what would happen if Cabot commuted, and both AB and scum targeted him. Does AB somehow get hit by the scum kill? That sounds like nonsense. Would Sorian be nonsense?
Would he?
I clarified.if he hit me when commuting it'd be the same as doing nothing. He'd only die if scum targeted him
He told us he was going back to his original plan (ie. Cabot or nin). Doing anything else after that would be inviting a disaster.
OK. I'm okay with a lynch this phase. Last night I switched Mazre with KK. After I flip and all of you are certain the next phase lynch either Nin of Cabot.