DeafTourette
Perpetually Offended
Well let's see, I just smoked a jay and have some time to vibe on this. Gonna just try and remember all of the heroes and major villains in rough (key word rough) order as they appeared. Green is they were already stars, red is a point to Tarantino, yellow is a toss up
- Iron Man | Robert Downey Jr | Was already one of the most popular actors in the world, and an icon
- Pepper Potts | Gwyneth Paltrow | Was a huge star
- Nick Fury | Samuel L Jackson | Icon
- Captain America | Chris Evans | Was already a household name for the millennials who Marvel was targeting, but probably wasn't terribly well known amongst people Tarantino's age
- Thor | Chris Hemsworth | Tarantino has a point here
- Jane Foster, The Mighty Thor | Natalie Portman | Was already a huge star
- Loki | Tom Hiddleston | Point Tarantino
- Hulk | Mark Ruffalo | Was already a well known dramatic actor
- Black Widow | Scarlett Johannessen | Was already a huge star
- Hawk-Eye | Jeremy Renner | Among movie buffs he was well known. Furthermore his movie right before Thor was The Town, in which he was a nominee for an Academy Award for best supporting actor
- The Falcon | Anthony Mackie | Was already a star. Maybe not a big star in terms of accolades and the caliber of films her worked on. But he had been in a slew of films and was immediately recognizable
- Scarlet Witch | Elizabet Olsen | Point Tarantino
- Quicksilver | Aaron Taylor-Johnson | Pretty well known, in that he was one of those actors who's face many recognized but didn't know his name. Toss up
- Spider-Man | Tom Holland | Toss up, because it's not really fair. Dude was practically a kid and this was his first major film role, and to my knowledge first work outside of the UK
- Star Lord | Chris Pratt | Was definitely a big star from
The OfficeParks and Rec alone. In fact more people still probably remember him from that moreso than Marvel stuff- Gamora | Zoe Saldana | Had already been a lead in her own films, and was in Star Trek
- Groot | Vin Diesel | Was already a huge star
- Rocket Raccoon | Bradley Cooper | Was already a huge star
- Drax the Destroyer | Dave Bautista | As far as his film work goes, sure, newcomer. But he was well known as a wrestler and fighter. Toss up
- Ultron | James Spader | Was already an icon like his pal Downey Jr
- Thanos | Josh Brolin | Was already a huge star
- Doctor Strange | Benedict Cumberbatch | Was already am international star
- Wong | Benedict Wong | He was a already a journeyman actor, but not well known. Point Tarantino
- Black Panther | Chadwick Boseman | As far as I recall this was his first real role. Point for Tarantino
- Shuri | Letitia Wright | Point Tarantino
- Ramonda | Angela Basset | Was a star and icon
- Erik Killmonger | Michael B Jordan | Was already a huge star
- Ant-Man | Paul Rudd | Huge star already
- The Wasp | Evangeline Lilly | Was already a huge star from Lost
- Hank Pym | Michael Douglas | Icon
- The Vulture | Michael Keaton | Icon
- Captain Marvel | Brie Larson | Point Tarantino
- Yonn-Rogg | Jude Law | Was a huge star
- Kang the Conqueror | Jonathan Majors | Toss up. His star was rapidly rising, but wasn't quite well known yet. He's looking to be a major star in the making however
OK that's all I can take. I probably missed a bunch. Final tally:
He's right: 7
He's wrong: 23
Toss up: 4
Conclusion: old man yelling at clouds
Edit: added a bunch I forgot
Only things I'll note are these:
Chadwick Boseman was famous before Black Panther... He came up from TV and then his breakout role (on the big screen) was Jackie Robinson in "42" ... Then he was in "Get On Up" as James Brown.... Then "Draft Day" with Kevin Costner... He had "Message from the King" come out the same year as "Civil War"... Then "Marshall" where he played Thurgood Marshall... Then post " Endgame " he had "Ma Rainey's Black Bottom", "21 Bridges" and "Da 5 Bloods".
He was already a bonafide movie star before his first moment in an an MCU film.
Also, Brie Larson was an academy Award winner for Best Actress before she was cast as Captain Marvel... And had been in multiple movies before being cast in the MCU as well...
That's all I had to say concerning your list.
I THINK that's all I had to say...