This game is just so conflicting as a huge P4 fan. Almost everything about it feels so, so goodyou can just tell the amount of polish and extra work that went into Golden. Reviewing conversations, the fast-forward for cutscenes, re-organizing a Persona's skills, on and on.
But then, the hardcore Persona nut in me is driven a little crazy by the "casualization" that's also gone on in the game. No challenge in picking post-battle cards, MC death only wiping out progress on the current floor (versus progress since the last save), stuff like that. And then there are the bits of fan service that I'm not a fan of.
Unquestionably, this is by far the better version of Persona 4but it's also been interesting to see how my emotions have gone up and down at times during what I've played so far.