Matt, why so terse, bro? Out of character
Sorry, my computer has uncharacteristically broken. Unfortunately I am unable to search all of a user's lists on mobile (as far as I can tell), which makes the process of going through the thread quite a bit more frustrating. I also accidentally marathoned The Last Guardian, which ate up a lot of time.
I'm checking up on Matt Attack. He was quite quick, a little too quick to offer an alternative lynch candidate.
I mean, I've gone on the record saying that I leaned town on both Star and Buzzard. I also wanted to lynch Zipped/Sept since the day beforehand. It's not like my vote came out nowhere.
a reads list:
11037: Null, sort of leaning scum. Posts too frequent, but there's an okay feeling of effort in most of them. I still can't get much of a read on him though, which I find concerning. This may partially be due to the presence of our more controversial lynch candidates, but I feel like 11037 has not gotten due attention. I would probably normally list you as town, but I feel like there's a good chance that if one of our remaining scum is one of or more active and talkative players, the other would want to hide in plain sight, taking care not to make waves... maybe it could be you? Usually I can call up a player's name in my mind and say what I think about them, but that's hard to do for you.
BlackBuzzard: Town. D1 position on Style looks good, and he himself seems like he's been a bit too common and easy of a target. His actual play has been not always ideal in terms of depth and frequency, but little seems overtly scummy to me. This backfired on me with Style, but I do think Buzzard is town.
FEP: Town. I was initially concerned about you on D1 but you didn't take long to push me in the opposite direction. I felt like you were one of the few voices of reason on D2, and ever since I've felt like you've been putting your posts to good use for the benefit of town. Feeing pretty solidly on you for now.
WhereAreMahDragonz: Town. Has claimed ordinary, has played like an ordinary without as much time to put into the game. D1 play with Exodu5 gives a pretty good look for her imo.
PK Gaming: Town. One of my more consistent reads. I've thought he felt like newbie town since D1 and... that hasn't changed. Is his play always optimal? No. But I'm not getting scummy vibes at all.
plop: Scum. I find Hyper's case against you fairly convincing. There are a lot of points he brings up that fit together decently well, and considering you've claimed being a Doctor who has unfortunately been unable to protect somebody thus far, we don't have any way to verify you yet. I am not opposed to delaying your lynch a day to give you another shot and try to prove your ability, but I do think that you're gonna have to go if you can't.
Hyperactivity: Probably town, semi-conditional to plop's flip. Your argument against plop is pretty strong, and I don't see us lynching you until he flips town, in which case a much more detailed analysis of your posts would be warranted. This isn't a very detailed read but you have a lot of posts and I'm kind of panicking imagining going through them all on my phone... For now, I don't see you getting lynched before plop.
Verelios: Scum. Your posts, from the beginning of the game until now, have seemed town at first glance. But I'm just realizing how different our reads on people have been. You've got serious suspicion on Star, you've got BB suspicion, you've got PK suspicion. I feel like these are people scum team would have loved/would love today to get rid of. (We haven't seen BB or PK's flips but I believe they are town). There's more than just read differences too. You easily hopped on the Sept bandwagon (or at least attempted to since you misspelled your vote), for instance. Exodu5 town read you, and while you did vote for him, it was at the very last possible moment. I'm picturing you being an opportunistic scum. Before people's flips you look like you're doing good work, but I feel like afterwards, your record may not look so clean.
IMO, assuming 2 scum left, the most likely scum configuration would go like the following: plop/Hyper/FEP + 11307/Verelios. In other words, one player who I would classify as a discussion leader, and another who I would say is simply a solid presence. Some of them (like FEP) are kind of long shots, but I included anyway because I can't discount the possibility. I'm currently in favor of scum team being plop + Verelios, btw. Strongly so.
A lot of my reads list probably seems like rambling. I admit that being stuck to only mobile makes it a little tough, I usually use my PC for my longer posts. I will say I intend to do a more thorough analysis of Verelios, since I'm not really super satisfied with how my section on him came out. I think he's scum and he deserves that much.
lop