This is just reiterating what's been said repeatedly already.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Persona Mafia |OT| Memento Mori
- Thread starter CrimsonFist
- Start date
This is just reiterating what's been said repeatedly already.
I'm not saying I want them off the island, I was just singling them out as key players. Would players really be willing to vote for active players? That seems counterproductive to me, since there's a low chance of them actually being scum.
Remember my earlier question? It's because I know personally Sketch. I'm not acquainted with any of the other players who haven't really stood out.
Style has made several unnecessary moves, such as claiming that he's "following Sorian's lead" and admitting to going with the flow. That to me, feels like he's he's cracking under pressure and trying to deflect.
Guess i'll make it official then:
VOTE: Style
Is this some kind of subtle hint or threat. Why did you post that?
Interesting line of thought. What do you think it could be a "subtle hint" towards?
Idk, maybe there was just more to it. Never mind then.
Is there any chance playing the death Arcanum would be considered a command of some kind? Or do all commands need to be highlighted?
I'm not feeling Style at this point. It's pretty typical for a new player and especially a townie to be indecisive and flip votes a lot in my experience. I don't get a particularly scummy read.
PK Gaming seems a bit more suspect in my eyes. Style seems like the easy vote and it seems overly bandwagonny at this point. Possibly scummy and trying to take attention off of fellow scummates.
I'm not feeling Style at this point. It's pretty typical for a new player and especially a townie to be indecisive and flip votes a lot in my experience. I don't get a particularly scummy read.
PK Gaming seems a bit more suspect in my eyes. Style seems like the easy vote and it seems overly bandwagonny at this point. Possibly scummy and trying to take attention off of fellow scummates.
The chance of any active player being scum is not low at all. Experienced players will be more confident in playing an active role as scum.
The reason to leave active players alone at the start of the game is two fold: more discussion is always good for town, and active townie will be scum targets at night anyways. Those that aren't targeted may become more and more suspect as the game progresses. This, again, is more useful information for town.
WhereAreMahDragonz
Banned
Hello. Please give me some time to read up thank you <3
BlackBuzzard
Banned
VOTE: ii-vanguard-ii
Has not said anything in the thread after his rng vote, for somebody that rng votes within the first day to then become completely silent makes him suspicious.
Also welcome WhereAreMahDragonz
Has not said anything in the thread after his rng vote, for somebody that rng votes within the first day to then become completely silent makes him suspicious.
Also welcome WhereAreMahDragonz
Welcome fam
Highlighted or send through PM. It's being overthought, it was probably just a joke.
Michael F. Assbender
Banned
PKGaming being mostly gone, then posting almost immediately after getting called out for it (meaning he's likely been lurking), then following that up with a vote on the suspect du jour has me heavily leaning in his direction at the moment.
Michael F. Assbender
Banned
I meant to say PKGaming casting a bandwagon vote on the suspect du jour**
Also, welcome WAMD!
Also, welcome WAMD!
BlackBuzzard
Banned
You need to unvote before voting again remember.
I don't disagree, but I don't want to just pile on so I'm going to see what else develops before the day end.
Unvote
exmachina64
Banned
Hey, welcome to the game.
BlackBuzzard
Banned
Nvm i was wrong you only unvote if you don't want to vote on somebody else. Sorry my bad guys should have read the rules more carefully.
19. To remove a vote from a player, you must present in the following format: UNVOTE: playername, via use of the highlight tag. It must also be in an entirely separate line from any other text. It is not necessary to unvote before casting new vote for a different player; unvoting is simply to remove a vote without casting a new one.
19. To remove a vote from a player, you must present in the following format: UNVOTE: playername, via use of the highlight tag. It must also be in an entirely separate line from any other text. It is not necessary to unvote before casting new vote for a different player; unvoting is simply to remove a vote without casting a new one.
Michael F. Assbender
Banned
I'd still like to hear more from Rats Off To Ya, 11037, and Matt Attack to try and see who they're suspecting and all that.
They've been extremely quiet.
They've been extremely quiet.
They both replied on last previous page with their readings.
Style just seemed like the most likely suspect and I just wanted to move the game further rather than have the votes split even further.
And as I've stated earlier, I was never gone.
Michael F. Assbender
Banned
I know but a couple posts just seems pretty quiet, compared to everyone else openly sharing thoughts.
flatearthpandas
Member
The person voting for me is full of scumtells. More at 11.
Michael F. Assbender
Banned
Not gone, just not active. Maybe nothing. Maybe avoiding the spotlight.
That sudden vote just screamed "Hey guys, not me! Remember Style? He's the one you want! I vote Style!"
exmachina64
Banned
The two who stand out most to me now are Style and PK Gaming. Style seems pretty frantic at this point, which could just be normal townie behavior if he's worried. Like others have said, PK Gaming jumped in at just the right moment to say he's still around and shift attention to Style.
Jumped in at the right moment?
I made my post in response to these posts:
It was the perfect springboard to jump in and let people i'm still here, rather than stay inactive.
exmachina64
Banned
exmachina64
Banned
Also, is Royal_Flush's voting tool not working for anyone else?
It's amazing how hard you are trying to not engage a discussion. I hope I'm not the only one on this.
exmachina64
Banned
And I'm talking about when you did that today.
Ah, thank you. It stays disabled on GAF, but not on the tool.
I'm inclined to give PK a pass. It was bandwagonny, but I'm not sure it was a scummy vote.
Style...you said Rynam and Rats posted in the last page with reads. I'm not seeing it.
I think Rynam is still suspect #1 for me. He's given himself away easily in past games and he's maintaining his silence this time around... and yet we've still ignored him completely.
Vote: Rynam
Style...you said Rynam and Rats posted in the last page with reads. I'm not seeing it.
I think Rynam is still suspect #1 for me. He's given himself away easily in past games and he's maintaining his silence this time around... and yet we've still ignored him completely.
Vote: Rynam
And what exactly is wrong with responding to Natiko's post considering he was directly talking about me?
Again, the narrative that I was "mostly gone" is patently untrue. I've been following this thread closely from day one, and responding to posts concerning me.
exmachina64
Banned
The narrative isn't that you're mostly gone, it's that you're lurking and maintaining silence.
And you just admitted to it.
So when someone mentioned you today, you chimed in and attempted to deflect suspicion.
exmachina64
Banned
VOTE: PK Gaming
II-Vanguard-II
Member
Dude i've have posted several times after my vote check the thread again and you'll see plus isn't it kinda hypocritical of you to call inactive on me. i just haven't changed my vote because style hasn't given me a reason YET.
Also
Welcome to the game WhereAreMahDragonz.
Votes are a bit stagnant, I will agree there. Style has cracked about as much as anyone can expect. Anyone sitting on him at this point is doing nothing pressure-wise. Inactive hunting is meh though. Will there be scum in the inactives? Yes, probably one at least, the issue is what Verelios said, it's a grab bag, you're shooting into luck and handwaving it with "we were probably going to hit town anyway!" is lazy and such an easy excuse for scum to hide behind. Pressure them, that's all well and good, we still have two days, but voting at day end to lynch inactivity because you'd rather kill someone who isn't contributing is lazy unless you actually think the person has done something suspicious.
I'd say Vanguard is just as inactive, all of 6 posts if I saw right and he's parroted others (the OMGUS thing with exmachina for example) and he's slid right into that Style vote all cozy but let's not forget that he started on there as a complete RNG vote when the game was already enough in swing that he saw behavior he didn't like but still opted to RNG instead of voting that behavior.
You might answer on this next page I'm going to read but why?