The funny thing here is that Call of Duty Ghosts is a game that looks like it's from 2008 and it runs like shit (on PC and PS4).
Polygon COD: Ghosts Review update: (XBONE better version)
- Thread starter skynidas
- Start date
- Status
The funny thing here is that Call of Duty Ghosts is a game that looks like it's from 2008 and it runs like shit (on PC and PS4).
Posts like this make me think some take this shit a bit too seriously and that's what makes it so funny.
what he's actually saying is that no one should trust his opinion since he can't tell if it's reality or just his delusion.
captainraincoat
Banned
I have a titan..and the game still runs into issues on the PC...probably the most noticeable is the weird texture pop in ...it either loads or you get a pink tile
Tried re-installing a number of official drivers and 3rd party ones but still to no avail
The MP also has some framerate issues....when you paid nearly 1k for a card on release you feel pretty stupid when it stutters when someone uses a noobtube on you
plagiarize
Banned
No COD game has been 60 fps stable on any console. Still, I do believe that the drops are more common and obvious on the PS4 version, as enough people have noticed the difference.
I'd be shocked if the Xbox One version doesn't drop frames when things get hectic. Shocked!
Gaf cares, because... NUMBERS!
plenty of reviews out there (IGN for example) that state there is a CLEAR difference between the two
Wishmaster92
Member
Glorious downsampling, same framerate.
iJudged
Banned
Lmao I agree, it's just not optimized, seems like it. This game should be able to run on 4k 120fps on both consoles by the way it looks.
Glass Shark
Banned
When there is a general consensus among reviewers, GAF assumes everyone was paid off. When reviewers disagree, GAF loses their freakin' minds.
popcorn.gif
Nymphae
Banned
I can't speak for everyone, but to me this is more about the credibility of the journalists reporting the facts.
Oddly must have missed frame rate issues too, was he in a hurry?
plagiarize
Banned
I have no issues with people who favour framerate over resolution. Zero.
Your inference that anyone who feels differently is a fanboy is baseless and insulting.
Zatoichi's Cane
Member
Glass Shark
Banned
The fact is that one version has more pixels than the other. Whether they feel they can perceive the difference on a particular TV at a particular viewing distance during normal gameplay is completely subjective.
Sure, I agree no video game site should belittle the difference between 720p and 1080p. At the same time, though, it's a data point that should be considered and weighed against various circumstances, from how the difference in resolution stands out in the context of usual gaming habits, to how the difference stands out in the context of rigorous side by side comparison. There is undoubtedly a subjectivity to how someone factors in resolution differences, and I would certainly say there's hardly anything unusual about the similarities far outweighing the differences in a case like this one.
And yes, the PS4 is more powerful than the X1, but is your latter paragraph mostly about resolution issues? I mean, is it that difficult to imagine X1 development in time crossing a threshold where pulling off 1080p on the device becomes much easier and more common?
Beer Monkey
Member
Exactly.
1) No CoD console game has ever been locked 60fps.
2) CoD:Ghosts has drops at 720p on X1. Not surprising.
3) CoD:Ghosts has even more drops at 1080p on PS4 because PS4 isn't 2.25x as powerful as X1. Also not surprising.
Teapot, meet tempest.
Mobius and pet octopus
Member
You'll have black bars unless they allow you to set the resolution to 720p than upscale it. This is a feature I don't think is available on ps4 but maybe there is a way to do it.
Raoul Duke
Banned
Well... actually, I'm not surprised... I'm just shocked most people give a shit what Polygon has to say. Their credibility was horribly lacking, even before the sim city debacle.
Beer Monkey
Member
You won't have black bars!
Nymphae
Banned
Absolutely. But this sentence:
Just fucking say it polygon. The PS4 version is sharper based on the technical data. You don't care about that? Fantastic.
Maninthemirror
Banned
Jeff craps all over reviewers trying to get ahead by scoring rather than waiting for the patch
clearly great developers..........dots dots
Lord Error
Insane For Sony
There's no doubt about it. The difference between 720 and 1080 is stupidly big on a 50"TV, especially when the AA solution is poor/nonexistent, like it seems to be the case here. However, the only comparison screens available now show that both versions are really 720p.
I trust dark10x almost more than my own eyes, so I'll take it from him that Dualshockers have just fudged something in their videocapturing process.
yeah on the PS3 for instance. MLB The Show.. it displays at 1080p Native, but even the Devs recommended to output it at 720p for a smoother framerate...and let the T.V. upscale it to 1080p if need be.
Actually, I don't think you do.
on the PS3, you could go to the display settings and uncheck 1080p and force 720p.
Sylverstone14
Member
Yup. Its fun., although overshadowed by the many good and even most better medicore shows. It's a good season to watch
Yeah, I'm watching like 10 shows this season, and UMD really managed to carve a niche with me. Still, with shows like Kill la Kill and Kyoukai no Kanata, this season is just beyond amazing.
after all gaf threads about 1080p?...the game would refuse to start
(ps in reality yes...sure it should)
Latvian Hitman
Member
One has over twice the pixels of the other. This has dramatic effects on other parts of IQ as well, such as aliasing, perceived texture res, etc.
I have no quibble with a reviewer or anyone else leaning towards a version with a more stable frame rate, but to say that he can't see a difference in IQ is kind of baffling to me. Surely he's not reviewing games on a 24" monitor from 8 feet away?
Hahahahaha
I actually think 1080p will become less common on XB1 due to memory constraints.
GrizzleBoy
Banned
Jeff Gerstmanm also said that the PS4 version has frame rate issues.
But its getting patched.
But its getting patched.
plagiarize
Banned
He's not saying he didn't see a difference in IQ, he's just saying that if he did he possibly just imagined it.
Because LOL.
Beer Monkey
Member
It's like today is the day that millions of console owners learned that there is a tradeoff between resolution and framerate. PC master race looks on in great amusement. Resolution and framerate are still tradeoffs on PCs that cost 3x as much as PS4.
It's absurd for anybody to think that all PS4 multiplats can be 1080p without ever taking a framerate hit versus platforms that are targeting a lower res.
My PS4 arrives in three days. I don't expect everything to run 1080p, at least not without taking a hit.
Lord Error
Insane For Sony
Dark, did you actually get to see CoD on both machines?
"The early reviews of Call of Duty: Ghosts--including mine--mentioned that the PlayStation 4 version of the game suffers from occasional frame rate issues. For me, it usually showed up whenever there were a lot of particle effects on screen, but it'd pop up at random, too. I'm told that Infinity Ward is working on a patch to correct the performance issues. As our review currently doesn't apply to the PS4 version of the game--I want to play that and the Xbox One version on real multiplayer servers before assigning it a number--I'm going to see if that patch makes its way live this week and see if it helps. Currently, I'd call it a toss up between the Xbox One and PS4 versions--the Xbox One version has a smoother frame rate, but I'd rather play the game on a Dual Shock 4. Getting that frame rate pegged would definitively swing things in the PS4's direction, even over the PC version, which is sort of a mess. Of course, we're talking about minor differences in a game that has much more significant issues than mere frame rate, so you probably shouldn't take any of this as a ringing endorsement of the release without reading my review first."
http://www.giantbomb.com/articles/a-few-last-minute-bits-of-playstation-4-info/1100-4785/
http://www.giantbomb.com/articles/a-few-last-minute-bits-of-playstation-4-info/1100-4785/
IndigoStyle
Banned
Cant believe a game that basically looks like 360/PS3 has issues on next-gen consoles.
Aren't the next-gen systems like 5 times more powerful?
Graphics wise im not worried at all though since we have Killzone, Infamous, Ryse and Quantum Break coming up.
Aren't the next-gen systems like 5 times more powerful?
Graphics wise im not worried at all though since we have Killzone, Infamous, Ryse and Quantum Break coming up.
killer rin
Member
Read that last night. It was an amazing piece.
MaximusPayne
Member
Whaaaa....?
- Status