molasar
Banned
AvP 1999
AvP 2001
AvP 2010
Even concrete jungle was fun
All had SP and still playable, if this game fails, servers will be shut down and you'll never be able to play again, so in that respect they're already better
You probably do not even remember those games enough.
AvP 1999 was good for its time gameplay wise (arcade style) but it is outdated now. It did not replaced Jaguar's AvP which is a survival-horror game from marine perspective.
AvP 2's gameplay was not good like its predecessor's but it had a better plot and expansion. Nothing special nowadays.
AvP 2010 was never special to start with. Based on an aesthetically crappy film. Compare it to the first AvP comic book series from 1989.
Concrete Jungle good for its time. Partially spoiled by aesthetics of crappy AvP film but it has nothing on P:HG. It was already dethroned by it.
Also what a strange way to rate games based on probability of their servers being shut down in the future. What about other games that require patches, etc.?