• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Pretending there's no racism hurts kids

Status
Not open for further replies.

ShadowRed

Banned
Pretending There's No Racism Hurts Kids

Tue Dec 7, 2:30 PM ET Health - Reuters & Yahoo News


By Alison McCook

NEW YORK (Reuters Health) - African-American
preschoolers whose parents say they don't believe
racism is a problem are more likely to be depressed or
anxious, a new study indicates.

Racism is a reality," lead author Dr. Margaret O'Brien
Caughy said. "It does have impact on very young
children. And we have to acknowledge that," she noted.


Caughy said that there are many reasons why young
children may become anxious if their parents deny the
existence of racism. For one thing, parents who
experience racism but don't acknowledge it may be
anxious or depressed themselves, and pass that onto
their children, she noted.

Otherwise, young children may witness signs of racism
around them, and become upset when their parents'
opinions don't match their experience.

"If (children) see in their day-to-day lives that
racism is real, but their parents don't acknowledge
it, could that create anxiety?" Caughy asked.

Traditionally, people who report they have experienced
racism are more likely to have problems with their
physical or mental health. In order to investigate
whether denying instances of discrimination hurts
health even more, Caughy and her team interviewed 200
African-American families with children aged 3 or 4.

Caughy, who is based at the University of Texas Health
Sciences Center in Dallas, along with her colleagues,
asked parents how often they experienced racism and
how they coped with it, then measured children's
behavior.

Approximately 7 percent of parents denied that racism
was a problem for their friends and family, the
authors report in the American Journal of Public
Health.

In an interview with Reuters Health, Caughy explained
that parents who said they didn't think racism was a
problem for African-Americans in general were more
likely to have young children with problems such as
anxiety or depression.

She noted that parents who denied that they had
experienced racism personally were no more likely to
have children with these problems, and denying racism
in general did not increase kids' risk of so-called
"externalizing" behavior problems, such as aggression
or acting out.

Although the team did not measure whether or not
people had actually experienced racism, research
suggests that 90 percent of African-Americans who say
they are not discriminated against indeed are,
according to objective measurements.

Parents who responded to racism by confronting the
people involved or taking some kind of action were
less likely to report that their children had behavior
problems.

The findings suggest that parents should try to talk
to children about racism, on a level they can
understand, Caughy said. "Acknowledging it, that it's
real ... and then trying to help children develop
realistic coping skills" appears to do the most good,
she noted.
 

Loki

Count of Concision
Though I agree somewhat with the hypothesis (regarding the fact that a lack of correspondence between one's personal experiences and the beliefs of one's parents may lead to some measure of cognitive dissonance), also realize that there's a danger of going to the other extreme and viewing everything through a racially-tinged lens when behavior might be due to other considerations. It's a fine line, though obviously nobody's denying that racism exists and has a real impact on minorities.


I'd also question the validity of so-called "objective measurements" regarding the number of African-Americans who "say they are not discriminated against but in actuality are, according to objective measurements"-- intent is crucial when discussing racism/discriminatory behavior, and in the absence of evidence for that intent (something which I imagine people would be quite hesitant/unlikely to admit for the sake of a study, even an anonymous one), I find it difficult to believe that racism can/should be ascribed to people, excepting the most egregious/clear offenses (e.g., a clear disparity in the number of people hired for a position when it can be objectively proven that the minority applicants are similarly qualified etc.).

So if some African-Americans believe they are not being discriminated against, I'm inclined to believe their judgment as far as it goes ("as far as it goes" meaning that, for instance, one might not be aware of discriminatory hiring practices etc., so this would contribute to a discrepancy between actual and perceived racism/discrimination).
 
African-American
preschoolers whose parents say they don't believe
racism is a problem are more likely to be depressed or
anxious, a new study indicates.
This makes me think a bit about religion. Regardless of whether or not a religion is true, if a person really believes in it it can give them some comfort in life. Likewise, I wonder if people being indoctrinated into thinking their problems aren't their fault (whether accurate or not) makes them feel better about their shortcomings.
 

ShadowRed

Banned
Damn Loki while it is a honor to have you grace any thread with you wit and wisdom when I see that you have posted I uncontrolably throw my head back and brace for an hour long read.
 

Loki

Count of Concision
ShadowRed said:
Damn Loki while it is a honor to have you grace any thread with you wit and wisdom when I see that you have posted I uncontrolably throw my head back and brace for an hour long read.

Wtf? :lol :)

So it takes you an hour to read a few short paragraphs? Sucks to be you... ;) :p


Seriously though-- I'm at a loss to explain why you chose to comment on me rather than what I said in reference to your article. :)


Btw, I never claimed to be witty...or "wise", for that matter. :p
 

gblues

Banned
What? You mean that kids get confused when experience doesn't match what mom & dad says?

"If (children) see in their day-to-day lives that
racism is real, but their parents don't acknowledge
it, could that create anxiety?" Caughy asked.

You could substitute just about anything into this statement:

"If children see in their day-to-day lives that underpants gnomes are real, but their parents don't acknowledge it, could that create anxiety?"

"If children see in their day-to-day lives that the bullies get their way, but their parents say 'violence doesn't solve anything,' could that create anxiety?"

And of course, they're all true statements. I'm not disputing that. The only thing I dispute is that this is anything specific to race.

Nathan
 

ShadowRed

Banned
Loki said:
Wtf? :lol :)

So it takes you an hour to read a few short paragraphs? Sucks to be you... ;) :p


Seriously though-- I'm at a loss to explain why you chose to comment on me rather than what I said in reference to your article. :)


Btw, I never claimed to be witty...or "wise", for that matter. :p




No I'm making a point of all your post not just this one. Before I scrolled all the way down I saw your name and assumed because of your past pattern it would b a long winded poster. Not sure if you know this but you have a reputation of being a bit of a prolific writer. :D Anyhow I pretty much agreed with your post that's why I didn't respond to it's content.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom