VisualFidelity
Member
My thoughts exactly!!! I hate westerns and feel the same way about this. Closest thing to living in a game
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Red Dead Redemption II |OT| Who knew horse testicles had such a crunch?
My thoughts exactly!!! I hate westerns and feel the same way about this. Closest thing to living in a game
JimmyJones
Banned
Just finished the first chapter and reached the horseshoe camp. God damn is the gameplay SLOWWWWW!
JORMBO
Darkness no more
It gets better starting with where you are now.
JimmyJones
Banned
I'm glad to hear it. They ripped it with the slow walking sections.
RPGCrazied
Member
Ordered the hard drive and the game. Should get by early next week. Can't wait to play. RDR is one of my fav games on the 360.
v0mitg0d
Member
JDTR1992
Neo Member
Turn hdr off
WaterAstro
Member
Are you fucking kidding me, post office?
Catphish
Member
Yeah I did that, too.I could not stop laughing when this happened to me today.
Catphish
Member
Im very impressed with the game. It's an even greater technological marvel than GTAV. I only wish I could play it on my gaming rig with kb/m. I don't find first person view to be practical with thumbsticks for anything other than sight-seeing while standing still.
Will be double-dipping on the PC version for sure.
Will be double-dipping on the PC version for sure.
Chairman Tickles
Banned
How is performance on vanilla PS4? I guess I'll check out digital foundry for a detailed answer. I'm keen to be cowboy, but not sure I have the constitution to buy this then have to buy it again on PC later for a superior experience. I can wait.
Edit: 26fps? No. no dude. Not going to happen.
Might borrow my friends game when he's done with it. He has PS4 version. Then buy it a year from now on PC.
Edit: 26fps? No. no dude. Not going to happen.
Might borrow my friends game when he's done with it. He has PS4 version. Then buy it a year from now on PC.
Last edited:
recklesscognition
Member
I don't like the controls at all. It feels like my body and head move at two entirely different speeds, it sucks. I also don't understand why I should have to push and hold down a button for minutes on end while in cinematic camera during a mission. Just let me enjoy it.
Last edited:
JimmyJones
Banned
I thought the exact same but the game has definitely picked up. Just done the mission with the girls in Valentine and I'm starting to get into it! Time for bed but.
Chairman Tickles
Banned
I broke. I'm buying it now. Too much hype.
YayNJ
Banned
Without posting any spoilers, I'm onto Chapter 2. I know it's not far in, just a slight scratch on the surface, but I have to be honest - I'm not blown away so far by any means. It looks good, but not really 4 or 5 years after GTA 5 good. The sound is stellar. The controls are terrible, fiddly and clunky. The game is also slow. SO SLOW.
Still - Chapter 2 awaits, lets see what happens.
Still - Chapter 2 awaits, lets see what happens.
ABrokenToy
Member
Whats everyones HDR setting? Im on a TCL 55” with local dimming and set it to 300. Maybe too washed out? I dunno.
Codes 208
Member
Day 22: the game is now 80% installed.
I was just about to say. You'd probably be waiting more than a year for a pc port. Assuming a pc port happens. (We may get one with next gen just like gta5)
Definitely.
mistuhcahlos
Member
Just started playing Witcher 3 a week ago and noticed a lot of these similarities also.
Heimdall_Xtreme
Hermen Hulst Fanclub's #1 Member
Hey guys, actually im installing RDR2, But is such much time.
Can i play a game in hard disk and this will still installing?
Can i play a game in hard disk and this will still installing?
GribbleGrunger
Dreams in Digital
People will tell you it gets better. Continue and find out for yourself ...
The dullest game I've ever played in my life. LOL.
Last edited:
WaterAstro
Member
Went to Bestbuy, bought the game, will return this late shipped copy later.
Starting it up.
Funny thing is that 5 people were in front of me for the same reason, because the national post office is on strike, so they're all doing the same thing. All PS4 copies lol.
Starting it up.
Funny thing is that 5 people were in front of me for the same reason, because the national post office is on strike, so they're all doing the same thing. All PS4 copies lol.
zwiggelbig
Member
Lol I kinda hated that to in the first hour..
Silent blades
Member
Turned off aim assist. Dead eye still targets the body to many times and causes me to shoot far to many bullets into it. Is it supposed to do that?
Northeastmonk
Gold Member
It's easier if you just go with the flow. Don't worry so much about having to do anything unless it actually prevents you from progressing. It's harder if you're trying to do it all because you have the option. The first thing I started to care about was my appearance. It all blends together once you get further into the game.
I thought about the way Arthur pulls his gun out and points it, he doesn't have a rubber/automatic feel to it. Which I guess is why it feels different. It feels like he's carrying the weight of the gun and he's extending his arm to aim. It's very realistic in that his body has to prepare itself for what's ahead or whatever consequence his physical actions have.
Xaero Gravity
NEXT LEVEL lame™
I see what you're doing there
Last edited:
888
Member
I’m about 16 percent completion now. I have to say. I like Arthur more than John. I swear every time I have been into the saloon has been amazing. You all know the part if you have been there. One of the best sequences in the longest time that I can remember.
I will say. I wish the trigger was punch and not quick shot. I have gotten the law on me a few times just trying to punch.
Also it showed him shooting with a pistol and then quick swapping to a rifle in a trailer. I have gotten him to hold the rifle in one hand and the pistol in the other buy haven’t figured out the firing yet.
I will say. I wish the trigger was punch and not quick shot. I have gotten the law on me a few times just trying to punch.
Also it showed him shooting with a pistol and then quick swapping to a rifle in a trailer. I have gotten him to hold the rifle in one hand and the pistol in the other buy haven’t figured out the firing yet.
Last edited:
DeepEnigma
Gold Member
The attention to detail in this game is so, so good. All the little nuances, all the little things, individual tree branches moving when you disturb them, snow falling off the branches, all the animations for the horses, how they get flustered/agitated with danger, THEIR DYNAMIC POOP!
Snow accumulating on your character and horse, then when you enter warm areas it slowly melts off creating a wet sheen before drying. It even melts slower indoors that have no fire or heat than places that do.
Snow accumulating on your character and horse, then when you enter warm areas it slowly melts off creating a wet sheen before drying. It even melts slower indoors that have no fire or heat than places that do.
Last edited:
So I'm early on. When does the game actually become enjoyable, cause I'm thinking of dumping this on eBay and going back to Yakuza.
- The movement is so fucking slow.
- Why is the text so tiny?
- I don't like Arthur's voice actor at all
- The controls just feel like there's molasses in everything. Auto aim is pretty much mandatory
- I haven't done a single interesting thing. At all. I've spent most of my time moving slowly and talking to characters I don't give a shit about it.
- Why is every animation so damn slow? Why can't I loot all when I open a cabinet?
- The horse system is stupid. Why can't I just carry all my stuff instead of having to keep it all in my horse? Why can't I just call my horse from anywhere and have him come? It discourages me from getting off my horse and exploring.
- The menus are just clunky and feel like they were designed 5 years ago by someone who hasn't played a game since
- The image quality on the PS4 Pro is fuzzy as hell.
Honestly, this is starting to feel like GTA4. Tons of praise on release, but the game was actually dogshit, especially when compared to other open world games of the time, like Saints Row 2.
- The movement is so fucking slow.
- Why is the text so tiny?
- I don't like Arthur's voice actor at all
- The controls just feel like there's molasses in everything. Auto aim is pretty much mandatory
- I haven't done a single interesting thing. At all. I've spent most of my time moving slowly and talking to characters I don't give a shit about it.
- Why is every animation so damn slow? Why can't I loot all when I open a cabinet?
- The horse system is stupid. Why can't I just carry all my stuff instead of having to keep it all in my horse? Why can't I just call my horse from anywhere and have him come? It discourages me from getting off my horse and exploring.
- The menus are just clunky and feel like they were designed 5 years ago by someone who hasn't played a game since
- The image quality on the PS4 Pro is fuzzy as hell.
Honestly, this is starting to feel like GTA4. Tons of praise on release, but the game was actually dogshit, especially when compared to other open world games of the time, like Saints Row 2.
camelCase
Member
This game is good. But it is nothing more than good because of how much it cripples itself with all of the boneheaded design decisions that affect the gameplay so much.
Wanna loot something? Ok, wait 6+ seconds (avg 6. can be in the 10 second area) to get your loot, for which you can only get 5 max of.
There is so much unneeded garbage in this game, holy shit. I like it but it could be a lot better if not for the constant shit. The controls are laggy and unresponsive and i often end up not killing the animal i had my reticle on for like 3 seconds because of some stupid restriction (reticle was on horse)
It's good but ... they just fucked up so bad on so many counts. You have to be a hardcore, slimy mouthed fanboy to defend half the crap this game makes you swallow. It's a good game that could be great if not for the the offensive busywork it makes you swallow to get to its good parts. Waiting 6 seconds to loot a creature is stupid, plain and simple.
I shouldn't have to say this but nonetheless I feel obligated; it is a good game. But it is hampered by some legitimately stupid design flaws. IMO it's a 6/7 for me right now.
Wanna loot something? Ok, wait 6+ seconds (avg 6. can be in the 10 second area) to get your loot, for which you can only get 5 max of.
There is so much unneeded garbage in this game, holy shit. I like it but it could be a lot better if not for the constant shit. The controls are laggy and unresponsive and i often end up not killing the animal i had my reticle on for like 3 seconds because of some stupid restriction (reticle was on horse)
It's good but ... they just fucked up so bad on so many counts. You have to be a hardcore, slimy mouthed fanboy to defend half the crap this game makes you swallow. It's a good game that could be great if not for the the offensive busywork it makes you swallow to get to its good parts. Waiting 6 seconds to loot a creature is stupid, plain and simple.
I shouldn't have to say this but nonetheless I feel obligated; it is a good game. But it is hampered by some legitimately stupid design flaws. IMO it's a 6/7 for me right now.
Silent blades
Member
Same exact problem! So if you figure it out please let me know
JDTR1992
Neo Member
I think we need to level up the deadeye, i was reading the manual and level 2 of dead eye has manual painting of targets!
Also pretty dissapointed there is no liars dice...
EDIT: here
Last edited:
Xaero Gravity
NEXT LEVEL lame™
I had a feeling the focus on realism would alienate some folks. Personally I'm a sucker for little details like that, but I can understand why it would wear some people down.
Pejo
Member
what are you guys doing with your animal pelts? I just keep stacking them on my horse's ass, but I'm not sure if I should be selling them or keeping them or what.
Also, is there a way to store them in your inventory instead of on your horse? I lost a legendary pelt because I couldn't figure out what to do with it, i set it by the campfire, and it disappeared.
Also, is there a way to store them in your inventory instead of on your horse? I lost a legendary pelt because I couldn't figure out what to do with it, i set it by the campfire, and it disappeared.
WaterAstro
Member
Anecdote lol.I see what you're doing there
unknownphysicz
Member
Same I couldn’t stop laughing lol, but is it just me or anyone else i don’t want anything to happen to my horse lol, when I get into gun fights I leave my horse far away from the fights lolI died from laughter in saloon drinking mission, it's masterful
bitbydeath
Member
It sure is slow but I like how Dutch sounds like Lotso from Toy Story 3.
The_Observer
Member
Yes, it's insanely immersive.
noonespecial
Member
This game is basically a Western/cowboy/outlaw sim/RPG. And it's almost near perfect. It is a shame that so many people are finding it not to be enjoyable. Guess it's just not their style.
JangoRain
Member
Really want to enjoy this game but I’m having trouble, maybe Gaf can help?
In chapter two and it just seems like there’s so much micromanaging with the camp, bathing, grooming, keeping cores up, hunting, etc. Should I just try to push through the missions until more options open up!?
In chapter two and it just seems like there’s so much micromanaging with the camp, bathing, grooming, keeping cores up, hunting, etc. Should I just try to push through the missions until more options open up!?