Sorry, I make up my own mind and don't pay attention to review sites, especially when a good number of those reviews are from people who 1 - simply suck at the game, 2 - were dismissive of the game's core concept from the jump, and so they never intended on giving the game a fair assessment. That's my personal opinion based on what I've read.
I don't need a review to tell me anything about Quantum Break because my opinion is the only one that matters really. I only really look to reviews out of curiosity, or to see which review I agree with the most after I've already made up my mind about a game that I've played. Quantum Break was easily one of the best games I've ever played in the 3rd person action genre, or any genre of game for that matter. The story and characters were handled fantastically. I took my time with the game and experienced all there was to experience, and I plan to do so again. I read the optional content, a lot of which adds tremendous depth and background to all the game's events (and characters) in a way that simply went over the heads of many of the reviews people keep harping on about.
The gameplay is top notch and was fun the entire way through. Just so fast paced and fun and plain brilliant in its overall mix of super powers and gunplay. Nothing feels quite like Quantum Break does. It separated itself at a time when just about every 3rd person shooter these days feels like the same damn thing. Quantum Break feels different, and it's better as a result. So, yea, to hell with what the reviews said because I feel if you have a true appreciation for great games with great gameplay and solid storytelling, there's no way you come away from Quantum Break thinking they didn't nail that shit. And there's so much potential for it moving forward. There is so much left to touch on based on where they left us. The sky is the limit for them if they continue the series.