Skyward Sword review thread [Newest Reviews - Cubed3 10/10, GC: A, AusGamers: 7/10]

Like I said this is going to be the game that finally confirms that motion controls (when done right) can bring a different level of depth and enjoyment that was never attainable with a gamer-pad. It's amazing that it took this long, but I greatly anticipate and fully welcome the future of great gamer-pad games along with great motion-control games.
 
Empty said:
that said i find edge and gi announcing their score days before they release the (full) review weird. seems to help further devalue the text part by putting all the emphasis on the score, as well as make them seem even more of a proxy in a games marketing campaign. just post the whole review with the score when you can.

Totally understand this complaint and don't feel dissimilar, but the magazine's going to hit soon, meaning the score and text will be out there anyway. Essentially we just wanted to get the news out there before it's all over GAF/elsewhere anyway, like I said in the post. I can't wait to get the full thing out there though.
 
IceDoesntHelp said:
I don't see the joke...that seemed pretty serious.

I thought baby games was an easy tip off. Fine then. I can just help fill up the thread with more "Only 10/10? pre-order canceled" jokes everyone loves so much.
 
KefkaTaran said:
Yeah, to be clear, I have given out a 10 (technically an A+) once before when I was writing for 1UP/EGM. That was for Fallout 3, for those wondering.

Can't wait for others to start playing it so I can actually have some discussions about it!



I dig Darksiders. I wouldn't have given it a 10.

Have you played any of the other high profile end of the year games (UC3, Batman, Skyrim ...) Is Zelda your favorite?
 
otmane said:
Have you played any of the other high profile end of the year games (UC3, Batman, Skyrim ...) Is Zelda your favorite?

Finished Batman, have started Skyrim, starting Uncharted 3 this weekend, so still lots to play and too early to say. I'd be surprised if anything beats it for me, but there's a lot of good shit out right now!
 
KefkaTaran said:
Finished Batman, have started Skyrim, starting Uncharted 3 this weekend, so still lots to play and too early to say. I'd be surprised if anything beats it for me, but there's a lot of good shit out right now!
Truly - this is one of the best fourth quarters I can remember for games, and there are seemingly winners on every platform.
 
Lord Ghirahim said:
Lord Ghirahim better be one of those two.
Or... both? ;//
hopefully!!
 
Salmonax said:
Truly - this is one of the best fourth quarters I can remember for games, and there are seemingly winners on every platform.

Yeah, I told my brother last week that it's an "embarrassingly good time to be a gamer." Don't think it will be possible to find time to play everything I want to before the end of the year, but that's quite a great problem to have. I hope 2012 can be half this exciting.
 
KefkaTaran said:
Yeah, I told my brother last week that it's an "embarrassingly good time to be a gamer." Don't think it will be possible to find time to play everything I want to before the end of the year, but that's quite a great problem to have. I hope 2012 can be half this exciting.
Well with Pikmin 3, how can't it be?
 
KefkaTaran, if you don't mind me asking, how seriously has Nintendo dug themselves into a hole with the amount of spoiler material? I've been on a blackout for the few videos/images because I no longer trust them, but it really seems like they've blown the lid off the entire goddamn game.

I guess I'm just hoping there's some big surprises and cool stuff that they haven't gone and spoiled or alluded to already.
 
Maybe this Zelda might actually be interesting. I've found them quite boring. Is there a bundle that comes with the motion plus? I'm not paying extra for it.
 
Choo choo

Akainu said:
Maybe this Zelda might actually be interesting. I've found them quite boring. Is there a bundle that comes with the motion plus? I'm not paying extra for it.
You are not worthy.

Yes there is

which games did you play?
 
KefkaTaran said:
Yeah, to be clear, I have given out a 10 (technically an A+) once before when I was writing for 1UP/EGM. That was for Fallout 3, for those wondering.

Can't wait for others to start playing it so I can actually have some discussions about it!



I dig Darksiders. I wouldn't have given it a 10.
Hey, it's you!
Damn, you're so lucky, you got to play this game... We still have to wait sixteen days before we can play it ;___;
 
KefkaTaran said:
Yeah, I told my brother last week that it's an "embarrassingly good time to be a gamer." Don't think it will be possible to find time to play everything I want to before the end of the year, but that's quite a great problem to have. I hope 2012 can be half this exciting.


It will be for RPG fans. :-D
 
Bisnic said:
Pikmin 3.
Releasing every year since 2006.
It'll happen next year!
At E3 2012:
Miyamoto: Yes we are working on Pikmin 3 for the Wii U. That is all
Iwata: (laughs)
At E3 2015:
Miyamoto: Pikmin 3? Oh you mean that game, yeah its still being worked on
Iwata's replacement: (stares into your soul)
 
EatChildren said:
KefkaTaran, if you don't mind me asking, how seriously has Nintendo dug themselves into a hole with the amount of spoiler material? I've been on a blackout for the few videos/images because I no longer trust them, but it really seems like they've blown the lid off the entire goddamn game.

I guess I'm just hoping there's some big surprises and cool stuff that they haven't gone and spoiled or alluded to already.

Yeah, obviously can't (and wouldn't want to) get into spoilers, but there are some surprises left. Some very cool things that haven't been shown at all yet. Perhaps less than you'd like, but definitely some!

Gillian Seed said:
It will be for RPG fans. :-D

Yesssssss
 
KefkaTaran, not sure you can divulge on this. But when you say it stands above other Wii games, do you imply a different standard for Wii games? I was wondering because this game will be the one that proverbially burns the dust off my Wii. Is it an amazing game, or an amazing Wii game?
 
2011 has been full of disappointments but Zelda is here to change that. It's gonna save this year for me, hopefully!
 
KefkaTaran said:
Yeah, obviously can't (and wouldn't want to) get into spoilers, but there are some surprises left. Some very cool things that haven't been shown at all yet. Perhaps less than you'd like, but definitely some!

COOL
 
I don't think I've ever seen a game go from lukewarm reception to this level of OMFG.

I can't fucking wait. Picking up my game and my gold wiimote DAY ONE.
 
spekkeh said:
KefkaTaran, not sure you can divulge on this. But when you say it stands above other Wii games, do you imply a different standard for Wii games? I was wondering because this game will be the one that proverbially burns the dust off my Wii. Is it an amazing game, or an amazing Wii game?

Definitely the former. I'm not a fan of qualifying like that. "Well, it's a great game...for the Wii." Meh, it's either a great game or it's not IMO.
 
TheLastCandle said:
I don't think I've ever seen a game go from lukewarm reception to this level of OMFG.

I can't fucking wait. Picking up my game and my gold wiimote DAY ONE.
I know, right? What a complete turnaround from 'What the fuck did I just see, THAT'S what they want us to be hyped about?' to 'What the fuck did I just see? HOW WILL I WAIT ___ DAYS FOR THIS GAME?'
 
KefkaTaran said:
Definitely the former. I'm not a fan of qualifying like that. "Well, it's a great game...for the Wii." Meh, it's either a great game or it's not IMO.
Thank you. I am so sick of hearing the 'for the Wii' statement being appended to every Wii game review. I mean, a game is either good to play, or it isn't, what system it is on is flat out immaterial
 
pramath said:
In Europe? Or Japan?
I still have to wait 16 days.
And I won't even have Skyrim to tie me over until the release of this game. ;____;

EU, although I ordered from a retailer that I haven't used before so I don't really know when I'll be playing it.
 
Man, the cutscene with Zelda singing, even though I've only seen a few seconds of it, gives me chills every time. I just freaking love that theme.

The wait is even more unbearable than before now :(
 
Top Bottom