• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Sports question for US GAF

I have a question for US GAF

I'm watching ''All or Nothing' on Amazon at the moment.

I'm trying to understand the NFL drafts.

In football (soccer) if you want to buy a player you make an offer and it's accepted you talk to the player who will usually accept etc.

In NFL it appears teams all take turns to buy a player? Does a player have any choice? Presumably that means some poor guy is the last chosen player?

If a team wants a player from a different team - can they do it via drafts?

There's ALOT more parity in NFL than the european soccer leagues due to draft, salary caps, trades, free agency and so on. The Pats dont win the most super bowl because they have the most money or fans ( it's because they cheat the most ) 😁😁😁
 

vikki

Member
In order:

Football: Your world champion New England Patriots

Baseball: Boston Red Sox

Hockey: Boston Bruins

Basketball: Boston Celtics


A toss up between Fenway and Gillette to see a game. Fenway is just like a cathedral of baseball. Gillette is awesome. Gillette is so much nicer than the old Foxboro Stadium.

I'll second this, although I'm least likely to follow or watch hockey. I'd say NFL is my favorite because there are limited games even though Baseball is my favorite sport. Living in NY, sometimes watching Boston games is tough. Also, living in NY, no one really gives a shit about my Red Sox apparel, but I do get comments on my Patriots attire sometimes.
 
I'll second this, although I'm least likely to follow or watch hockey. I'd say NFL is my favorite because there are limited games even though Baseball is my favorite sport. Living in NY, sometimes watching Boston games is tough. Also, living in NY, no one really gives a shit about my Red Sox apparel, but I do get comments on my Patriots attire sometimes.

Man did i ever get many comments in NYC wearing my Cowboys apparel when i wore a Witten jersey and Cowboys baseball cap. Most comments were obviously When i went to the concerts at Metlife lol.

Most were from the ushers saying stuff like "Hey this is Giants country, you cant wear this here" "Hey man you can go around here wearing a Witten jersey" all in good fun of course.
 
I have a question for US GAF

I'm watching ''All or Nothing' on Amazon at the moment.

I'm trying to understand the NFL drafts.

In football (soccer) if you want to buy a player you make an offer and it's accepted you talk to the player who will usually accept etc.

In NFL it appears teams all take turns to buy a player? Does a player have any choice? Presumably that means some poor guy is the last chosen player?

If a team wants a player from a different team - can they do it via drafts?
Each team has an exclusive contract with their players, and no other team can get that player from another team unless they complete a trade. Usually, this means trading one or more players and/or one or more draft picks.

Once that contract is up, a player can be a free agent and can sign with whomever they want (some restrictions apply depending on the contract).

In the NFL, rookies (typically) who are entering from college enter into the NFL Draft. There are rounds where each team, based on its record from the previous system, gets to choose which player to have exclusive access to signing. The team then enters into a contract with that player for a specific amount of time and a specific amount of money (there is a "pay scale" now in place to make that process easier).

The team with the worst record picks first, then next worst, and so on. If teams have equally bad records, they have different tie breakers to figure out which team was worse and that team gets the better pick.

Teams don't always pick in each round if they have traded that pick to a different team or they've been punished for one reason or another (see: New England Patriots), and there are also compensatory picks if a team lost a big player in free agency the year before, but that's a bit more in depth.

There are seven rounds and then the draft is over. After that, all players without contracts are free agents (rookies are called UDFA, undrafted free agents) who can sign with whatever team they want.
 

vikki

Member
Man did i ever get many comments in NYC wearing my Cowboys apparel when i wore a Witten jersey and Cowboys baseball cap. Most comments were obviously When i went to the concerts at Metlife lol

I've met plenty of Giants fans that joke a little, but the Jets fans are just disappointed. Jets fans just kind of shrug. I have met a few NY native cowboys fans, thought it was funny. Their explanation is that they were the team to watch when they started watching football. I also live in queens. There are a lot of Mets fans, a good number of which don't like the Yankees. Makes it a little easier on a Sox fan.

And the worst ribbing Igor was from some 5 year old kid at a playground. He was yelling Patriots suck, but then he had a million questions about the Patriots.he knew a bunch of players so that was impressive.
 
Each team has an exclusive contract with their players, and no other team can get that player from another team unless they complete a trade. Usually, this means trading one or more players and/or one or more draft picks.

Once that contract is up, a player can be a free agent and can sign with whomever they want (some restrictions apply depending on the contract).

In the NFL, rookies (typically) who are entering from college enter into the NFL Draft. There are rounds where each team, based on its record from the previous system, gets to choose which player to have exclusive access to signing. The team then enters into a contract with that player for a specific amount of time and a specific amount of money (there is a "pay scale" now in place to make that process easier).

The team with the worst record picks first, then next worst, and so on. If teams have equally bad records, they have different tie breakers to figure out which team was worse and that team gets the better pick.

Teams don't always pick in each round if they have traded that pick to a different team or they've been punished for one reason or another (see: New England Patriots), and there are also compensatory picks if a team lost a big player in free agency the year before, but that's a bit more in depth.

There are seven rounds and then the draft is over. After that, all players without contracts are free agents (rookies are called UDFA, undrafted free agents) who can sign with whatever team they want.

Very good post. Also there are other parity factors such as salary cap and other things but im sure other people here know more in depth about that than me so.
 

spongy185

Neo Member
Football - New Orleans Saints

NCAAF - Miami Hurricanes (my mom's Alma mater)

Baseball - Miami Marlins

Hockey - Florida Panthers

Basketball - Miami Heat

From Miami, always hated the Dolphins, then lived in New Orleans a long time.
 

LionPride

Banned
Favorite Sport? To play it's Rugby or basketball To watch, it's basketball, shit's an art

Football: I'm a die hard Detroit Lions fan, also a Titans fan, and I want to see a couple more teams do well. College? I guess UT-Knox now

Basketball: Timberwolves and Grizzlies. Was a big Cavs fan during Kyrie's first years by himself, also was a Warriors fan the two seasons before they got to the finals

Soccer: Any team, I just enjoy watching

Hockey: Any NHL team with a black player has my fandom

Baseball: I just watch at this point
 
Very good post. Also there are other parity factors such as salary cap and other things but im sure other people here know more in depth about that than me so.
Right, there is a LOT of things that could be discussed on contract terms, salary cap, salary cap transfers, minimum salaries, etc. It's a convoluted business, which is why people who really understand it well are paid EXTREMELY well to help guide writing contracts.

But I figured he asked about the draft and how teams can get players from other teams. So I tried to keep it as simple as possible (and it still came out convoluted!)

Goes without question if you win one Super Bowl ��
Brad Johnson. Elite QB.

Football: I'm a die hard Detroit Lions fan, also a Titans fan, and I want to see a couple more teams do well. College? I guess UT-Knox now
Oh no! Don't succumb to the dark side! No fruit sucks like the Big Orange!
 
There's ALOT more parity in NFL than the european soccer leagues due to draft, salary caps, trades, free agency and so on. The Pats dont win the most super bowl because they have the most money or fans ( it's because they cheat the most ) 😁😁😁

you're banned from visiting Boston ever again!
 
Right, there is a LOT of things that could be discussed on contract terms, salary cap, salary cap transfers, minimum salaries, etc. It's a convoluted business, which is why people who really understand it well are paid EXTREMELY well to help guide writing contracts.

But I figured he asked about the draft and how teams can get players from other teams. So I tried to keep it as simple as possible (and it still came out convoluted!)


Brad Johnson. Elite QB.

Yeah its bit messy, but the reason why i enjoy watching NFL so much is the parity between the teams. The biggest franchises isnt allways the most sucessfull atleast not in the long term (Cowboys, 49ers, Raiders.. etc)
 

ch4fx_

Member
Patriots_Football-086f7-1852.jpg


Goes without question if you win one Super Bowl 😏

What about 5?
 

Slo

Member
Football - NFL or NCAA Football? Favourite team?

Favorite teams are the Vikings and the Gophers, but I'm a fan of watching all games from both leagues. Like, I watch 20+ hours of football a week during the season.

Baseball - Major or Minor League, College, or some other leagues you like to watch? Favourite team?

Baseball? Never heard of it. Is that the thing they play in India with the canoe paddle and the rock?

Hockey - NHL or AHL? Favourite team?

Basketball - NBA or NCAA basketball? Favourite team?

Wild and Timberwolves, I guess but only because they are local. Not much of a fan.

Soccer - MLS? Or are there other stuff? Favourite teams?

Mostly just high school stuff.
 

SDCowboy

Member
Football- Dallas Cowboys (I just watch NCAA casually)

Baseball- No favorite team, and I don't watch it past the college game (Little League World series FTW)

Basketball- No favorite team, I just watch it casually

Hockey- I don't even ever see it on TV, so I don't watch it. I'm not sure I've sat down and watched an NHL game since the 90's.

Soccer- lol...
 
Top Bottom