• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Spring Anime 2013 |OT -7| My Giant CG Pony Can't Possibly Read This Much Baudelaire

Status
Not open for further replies.

Jex

Member
No, I understand what you're saying. My problem is the "parents who have no bearing on the plot." Everyone who's been a kid, which I have to assume is everyone here, knows parents have a huge effect on the "plot" of your life, LOL. It's a problem of believability in writing, not production priorities.

Gundam was my mother, war was my father.
 

Seraphis Cain

bad gameplay lol
K-On is not a show about the plot of anyone's life. It's about cute girls doing cute things. That usually doesn't involve parents... at all.

I'd agree with this if there weren't so many scenes of Yui's home life. It just kills the believability a bit (fuck you Chrome it's a word) when Ui is doing all of the parenting in the household, just because some dude with a dakimakura doesn't want to imagine having to seek the approval of his waifu's parents.

...that was an uncharacteristically bitter response, coming from me...eek...
 

duckroll

Member
I'd agree with this if there weren't so many scenes of Yui's home life. It just kills the believability a bit (fuck you Chrome it's a word) when Ui is doing all of the parenting in the household, just because some dude with a dakimakura doesn't want to imagine having to seek the approval of his waifu's parents.

...that was an uncharacteristically bitter response, coming from me...eek...

Haha. I agree! But I also don't watch K-On for a bunch of reasons, that included! :p
 

BGBW

Maturity, bitches.
Funnily enough Yui's parents have been designed. Did you lot not watch the K-On movie?

If I grew up in Anime Japan I'd be buggered. I'd be eating ready made meals everyday because I was a bad cook in my younger days. Can't live without mama's good ol' home cookin'.

Girls Bravo doesn't even bother with an explanation. It was something like "oh yeah, my parents left so I live on my own". Like what? Dial Child Line you fool, that's like abandonment.
 

jgminto

Member
Guys I think I had the greatest idea ever. A wall scroll with attachable/detachable clothing! You'd have mangnets/velcro on the base wall scroll with the character in their underwear. It'd have attachable clothing sets, that can be easily interchanged. Then you could release extra clothing sets. Holiday-themed, cross promotion from other shows, etc. Otakus would gobble that shit up!

Fuck, I should patent that shit!
 

Articalys

Member
Ahahahahahaha
DLyxFq0.jpg
So this is the reason why the voice for Grace the squirrel was ???'d out in the credits for the first two episodes of Gargantia... if I'm reading this correctly, they're having a contest where you can try to guess which member of the cast is doubling as the noisemaker for the animal, and they'll pick three entrants who guess correctly by the time the third episode airs (when they'll reveal it) to win signed copies of the first episode script.

One commenter joked "if it's Sugita I'll buy a dozen copies of the first BD box."
 

Branduil

Member
Funnily enough Yui's parents have been designed. Did you lot not watch the K-On movie?

If I grew up in Anime Japan I'd be buggered. I'd be eating ready made meals everyday because I was a bad cook in my younger days. Can't live without mama's good ol' home cookin'.

Girls Bravo doesn't even bother with an explanation. It was something like "oh yeah, my parents left so I live on my own". Like what? Dial Child Line you fool, that's like abandonment.

Apparently in Japan there are like no laws about parental abandonment. Both parents can just "work overseas" and send money to their homesitting schoolchildren, and everything's cool. Also, if your parents die you don't need new guardians, just go it alone, it's no problem at all for children to manage an adult's responsibilities after their parents just tragically died.
 
What shows this season even have parents in them? Arata Kangatari. They're in like one scene of OreImo 2. There's Space Bros. Am I missing something else?
 

Jex

Member
Guys I think I had the greatest idea ever. A wall scroll with attachable/detachable clothing! You'd have mangnets/velcro on the base wall scroll with the character in their underwear. It'd have attachable clothing sets, that can be easily interchanged. Then you could release extra clothing sets. Holiday-themed, cross promotion from other shows, etc. Otakus would gobble that shit up!

Fuck, I should patent that shit!
I find it hard to believe that that doesn't exist.
 

duckroll

Member
Apparently in Japan there are like no laws about parental abandonment. Both parents can just "work overseas" and send money to their homesitting schoolchildren, and everything's cool. Also, if your parents die you don't need new guardians, just go it alone, it's no problem at all for children to manage an adult's responsibilities after their parents just tragically died.

I think what usually happens after a tragic death is that the children get legally adopted by an aunt or uncle, who happens to also be working overseas. Yeah that's it!
 

duckroll

Member
What shows this season even have parents in them? Arata Kangatari. They're in like one scene of OreImo 2. There's Space Bros. Am I missing something else?

Existence of parents are confirmed in Aku no Hana, Attack on Titan, Devil Survivor 2, and Yuyushiki. Those are the ones I'm watching anyway.
 

Branduil

Member
I think what usually happens after a tragic death is that the children get legally adopted by an aunt or uncle, who happens to also be working overseas. Yeah that's it!

I bet all of these "working overseas" parents are actually in jail for selling crack. I know that's what I'd tell people in that circumstance.
 

BGBW

Maturity, bitches.
Guys I think I had the greatest idea ever. A wall scroll with attachable/detachable clothing! You'd have mangnets/velcro on the base wall scroll with the character in their underwear. It'd have attachable clothing sets, that can be easily interchanged. Then you could release extra clothing sets. Holiday-themed, cross promotion from other shows, etc. Otakus would gobble that shit up!

Fuck, I should patent that shit!
So just a paper doll that you can't hold?
Anime related!! (NSFW??)

Apparently in Japan there are like no laws about parental abandonment. Both parents can just "work overseas" and send money to their homesitting schoolchildren, and everything's cool. Also, if your parents die you don't need new guardians, just go it alone, it's no problem at all for children to manage an adult's responsibilities after their parents just tragically died.
I had no idea what my goal in life was. Now I know. To set up Child Line in Japan. Parents of Japan, you better watch out!
 

Branduil

Member
Then again, with Ano Hana and Black Rock Shooter, Okada showed that sometimes having offscreen parents is better than the alternative, LOL.
 

duckroll

Member
Where were there parents in Devil Survivor?

They're mentioned specifically to be in the country, and they could be contacted on the phone. That means they exist and have not abandoned their children and/or died tragically (yet). The fact that the characters are worried about them also indicates that they have a normal relationship with them!
 
They're mentioned specifically to be in the country, and they could be contacted on the phone. That means they exist and have not abandoned their children and/or died tragically (yet). The fact that the characters are worried about them also indicates that they have a normal relationship with them!

Off-screen and inaccessible, that sounds like every other anime parent. They might as well be overseas.
 

BGBW

Maturity, bitches.
Well luckily for the kids of Anime Japan the world economy is still in the gutter so there are no jobs overseas.
 

Articalys

Member
So if I don't give a damn about anime trying to maintain the illusion of normal family structure or responsibilities or whatever and am willing to accept whatever hand-wavy explanation it gives for parents or grandparents or whoever not being involved characters or even existing, does that make me a bad person or something?

As long as the plot doesn't use it as active elements of the ongoing story, and it remains part of the vague setup scenario, what do I care?
 

duckroll

Member
Off-screen and inaccessible, that sounds like every other anime parent. They might as well be overseas.

Not really. The original point was about believability (which IS a word, Google spellcheck is wrong!), and parents being separated from their children during a national disaster is believable.
 
Not really. The original point was about believability (which IS a word, Google spellcheck is wrong!), and parents being separated from their children during a national disaster is believable.

It makes sense for Devil Survivor. I just think it's just more of a convenience of the setting than a difference in writing or approach.

So if I don't give a damn about anime trying to maintain the illusion of normal family structure or responsibilities or whatever and am willing to accept whatever hand-wavy explanation it gives for parents or grandparents or whoever not being involved characters or even existing, does that make me a bad person or something?

As long as the plot doesn't use it as active elements of the ongoing story, and it remains part of the vague setup scenario, what do I care?

Where are you even getting this from? No one criticized anime viewers like that in this discussion.
 
My neighbours the Yamadas

Yeah this is a real Ghibli movie. Its a family story without any real plot, divided in multiple chapters/skits. Its unique in that it is presented in a comic strip style. The stories are about every day situations of a normal household, presented in a humorous way. Yamadas is refreshing and never boring, actually it has lots of life lessons. Highly recommended. Score 6 or 7/10

 

BGBW

Maturity, bitches.
So if I don't give a damn about anime trying to maintain the illusion of normal family structure or responsibilities or whatever and am willing to accept whatever hand-wavy explanation it gives for parents or grandparents or whoever not being involved characters or even existing, does that make me a bad person or something?
Yes. But you could have simplified all that with "So if I [...] give a damn about anime [...] does that make me a bad person [...]?
 

Branduil

Member
So if I don't give a damn about anime trying to maintain the illusion of normal family structure or responsibilities or whatever and am willing to accept whatever hand-wavy explanation it gives for parents or grandparents or whoever not being involved characters or even existing, does that make me a bad person or something?

It makes you worse than Hitler, obviously.
 

Theonik

Member
Guys I think I had the greatest idea ever. A wall scroll with attachable/detachable clothing! You'd have mangnets/velcro on the base wall scroll with the character in their underwear. It'd have attachable clothing sets, that can be easily interchanged. Then you could release extra clothing sets. Holiday-themed, cross promotion from other shows, etc. Otakus would gobble that shit up!

Fuck, I should patent that shit!
That reminds me of that Yukari fan made dakimakura
Did you quote the wrong post? Lol
Whoops. This is what I wanted to quote. Stupid multi-quote.
Hypothesis: Diebuster should be watched with Utena goggles, not with Gunbuster goggles.
 

Seraphis Cain

bad gameplay lol
Where are you even getting this from? No one criticized anime viewers like that in this discussion.

I, uh...*cough*...I might have...(or at least, it may have been interpreted that way...though I certainly hope not)

Of course, I didn't mean it as "anyone who is okay with the lack of parents in SOL shows must be a dakimakura-hugging hikki". But you'd have a hard time convincing me that the reasoning for the lack of parents in these shows doesn't have at least something to do with said audience.
 

Kurita

Member
My neighbours the Yamadas

Yeah this is a real Ghibli movie. Its a family story without any real plot, divided in multiple chapters/skits. Its unique in that it is presented in a comic strip style. The stories are about every day situations of a normal household, presented in a humorous way. Yamadas is refreshing and never boring, actually it has lots of life lessons. Highly recommended. Score 6 or 7/10

I was thinking about watching it since I loooove the manga. It looks good, will give it a shot.
 

Jintor

Member
I, uh...*cough*...I might have...(or at least, it may have been interpreted that way...though I certainly hope not)

Of course, I didn't mean it as "anyone who is okay with the lack of parents in SOL shows must be a dakimakura-hugging hikki". But you'd have a hard time convincing me that the reasoning for the lack of parents in these shows doesn't have at least something to do with said audience.

I dunno man, it's also an effective way to keep your story contained without having to keep dragging in more and more characters. That said, I find the SOL shows that just incorporate the parents into the lols much more entertaining. (Yandere Kanojo, for instance)
 

Jex

Member
Oh yeah, none of you sons of guns ever answered my question about Nadja earlier - does it get kind of creepy, as in, inappropriate? Because it looks like it really could go down that route and I just want to be warned.
 
I, uh...*cough*...I might have...(or at least, it may have been interpreted that way...though I certainly hope not)

Of course, I didn't mean it as "anyone who is okay with the lack of parents in SOL shows must be a dakimakura-hugging hikki". But you'd have a hard time convincing me that the reasoning for the lack of parents in these shows doesn't have at least something to do with said audience.

Your comments were general and unspecific enough that no one here should have been offended. Well, unless there are people self identifying with "some dude with a dakimakura doesn't want to imagine having to seek the approval of his waifu's parents."
 

jgminto

Member
So just a paper doll that you can't hold?
Anime related!! (NSFW??)
I'd say it's more a poster you can dress up.
That reminds me of that Yukari fan made dakimakura

I guess you could call that an inspiration.


But seriously, why do wall scrolls have to suck so much? I'd rather have them over posters but there are just no appealing designs. I'd do anything for some sweet Jojo wall scrolls, all colourful and vibrant, they'd look great.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom