• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Spring Anime 2013 |OT -7| My Giant CG Pony Can't Possibly Read This Much Baudelaire

Status
Not open for further replies.

Jex

Member
[Trust & Betrayal] - 1

I have decided that it was a grave error to even consider discussing this seminal work without showing you all the strikingly beautiful artistry that exists within it. Dresden already touched on the light and the dark contrast, as well as the importance of shadows and they key role they play in the visual language of the piece. However, it's not just the lighting that demands your attention. It's the composition, the framing, the contrast, the detail, the colour work - pretty much everything that you could think of. There's plenty of wallpaper material, in other words:





There are still a few little touches I'd like to comment on regarding shadows. Firstly, at the beginning of this episode:


This is just classic visual storytelling. We don't need to see anything else to realise that these group of people have been enslaved and, in fact, it's not explicitly mentioned in the dialogue for quite some time. What I really respect here is how restrained the actual framing is - they don't focus entirely on the chains in a manner which would be the equivalent of beating the audience over the head with the point.


This master and student are clearly worlds apart, as demonstrated by the immense barrier between them.

Two areas in which I find this work particularly visually arresting, at least in comparison to other good looking anime, is the hair and the blood. The hair looks amazingly dark and detailed but it still managed to actually move in a convincing manner, something which must have been a bit challenging:


Meanwhile the blood is extremely thick and striking and the manner in which it dries makes it resemble paint. A very interesting, and powerful choice:

 

Narag

Member
One of the touches I appreciate about that Kenshin OVA is how grounded it is. Main characters are mostly depowered down to something much more normal and consequently they came across as far more believable.

I guess the exception there is Hiko's introduction where he cuts that guy multiple times in an instant. but he's supposed to be on an entirely higher level than anyone else. I can't remember if it was in this or the TV series where he says
that he's not allowed to take sides in the revolution and must remain neutral as the Hiten Mitsurugi Ryu was so strong, whichever side he took would be the victor.
What a boss.

Shame about the terrible later OVAs that abandons this.
 

Dresden

Member
[Trust & Betrayal] - 1

This is just classic visual storytelling. We don't need to see anything else to realise that these group of people have been enslaved and, in fact, it's not explicitly mentioned in the dialogue for quite some time. What I really respect here is how restrained the actual framing is - they don't focus entirely on the chains in a manner which would be the equivalent of beating the audience over the head with the point.

I loved how that leads in later on into the most accomplished piece of cinematography in the episode:

4YZogZ2.jpg
vSTmHXE.jpg

It's just a really nice confluence of writing, animation, framing, you name it. Just from that brief cut, there's a deliberate call-back to the beginning of the episode, but repurposed this time to shed light on Katsura's motives and how he feels about them. It's a mission that has committed him to servitude in almost the same way that a young Kenshin was sold into bondage; it binds him, in the shadow of his master, the circumstances of his death forcing him onto this road.

It's so damn good.
 

Theonik

Member
so, uhh, can anyone explain the freakout over "otaku tropes" in the Bravely Default thread? Is everyone just threatened because there are flat-chested characters?
Flat characters are children and so if you aren't disgusted playing games with them on you must be a paedophile. :GAF
 

/XX/

Member
I may not remember much of the Reminiscence OVAs, all but a vague idea left since the last time I saw them but one thing I never forgot, and the first thing that came to mind seeing images of it you guys posted, is this:

るろうに剣心追憶編OST 「In Memories "KO・TO・WA・RI"」 - YouTube
http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=nmz9oo-V3GY#t=225s

And this is precisely all I need to remind me how much I liked it!
 
That k-on poster in the movie thread brought uo something I have noticed in some of these anime were the girls are trying to be portrayed cute. Why are there knees bent like that and point inward (maybe just kyoani thing). Wish I could find a gif for it.
It's called pigeon toed.
2NDSGQt.jpg

so, uhh, can anyone explain the freakout over "otaku tropes" in the Bravely Default thread? Is everyone just threatened because there are flat-chested characters?

The same people that find this completely inoffensive cover creepy:
When people complain about something like that, it usually boils down with how the face look, rather than the chest size.
 

Mr.Jeff

Member
This one: http://neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?t=541530

Perhaps everyone's all mature and stuff now.

The topic title is too inoffensive and focused on the wrong thing. If it had been something along the lines of "The K-On has the most believable female characters and waifus ever. FACT", OT would probably have gone up in flames. Talking about animation though? Not in the same league.


While the subject of Kick-Heart is floating around, I did find it amusing that they sent backers out a "sample" of the soundtrack which is around 3 mins 30 long so nearly a third of the soundtrack has essentially been revealed.
 
CCS is the best mahou shoujo show (sorry Hito).

This is 100% true.

It's the Sakuga among other things.
Also CLAMP people are best people.

Oh god. It's been so long that I've forgotten just how great the show could look. I really need to do a rewatch sometime soon.

Oh, okay, I feel silly for not realising that Cardcaptor Sakura was directed by Morio Asaka that directed: Gunslinger Girls, Nana and Chihayafuru among many other titles. Madhouse are lucky they've still got talent like him under their roof.

I haven't really seen enough of his works to pick up on any obvious directorial quirks. He's not quite as easy to spot as a Dezaki, an Ikuhara or a Hosoda. Perhaps if I consume more titles from his catalogue it'll become clearer. One that that's immediately clear is that he's a very tasteful director, I can't really recall any pandering or fanservice in works that he's put out but as there's so much I haven't seen it could well exist.

With Asaka, you can always count on something extremely well done. I don't know if he has any real obvious trademarks (but I also watched most of his stuff years apart), but he does handle everything tastefully and treats the characters with respect. I've never been disappointed when watching one of his shows.

All I know about Cardcaptor Sakura is that little girls date their adult teachers.

Hey, there's only one who does that!
 

BGBW

Maturity, bitches.
Attack on Titanic 2

Poor titans. Not only will they die from food poisoning and dye poisoning they're going to freeze to death. Get them some clothes pronto.
 

Kazzy

Member
best k-on girls are the random ones in class with no lines or any mention, yet for some reason fans know their names and shit.

It's probably because they are background characters that remain static, are recurring, and have a clear visual identity. Also, KyoAni gave out the class profiles with the BD volumes.
 

Nafe

Member
Heartcatch PreCure!


Episode 18

Mentioning before about the side characters like classmates showing up again, I'm not sure if Ban-kun was there before. You could pretty much tell the direction the episode would be going in but it's just entertaining to see how they get there. This episode was pretty entertaining too! All the different reactions and antics. Kumojacky walking past the camera at the library and then again later followed by the pretty amusing fight. Ban-kun is a pretty cool guy and I think this might have been one of my favorite episodes.

---

Episode 19

I don't mind tomatoes and have them on sandwiches or hamburgers and such but I've never liked them enough to east them like an apple like that.

Regarding the battle this episode...
it would be interesting to maybe see the girls use the heart seeds more and get different powers from time to time just to change up the battle like this episode. This is the second, maybe third, time they've used the speed boost. Actually I think Tsubomi used it three and Erika only twice because Tsubomi was trying to rescue Erika from the water monster during the camping trip with the couple.

I could see the problem introduced this episode but the resolution felt a bit thin again. I guess it is ultimately just a kids show and they've only got about twenty minutes to work with. It was entertaining in the end with the different antics and reactions though again.

This show seems to have that weird thing with keeping the PreCure a secret at times and not really caring at others though. For the person that becomes a monster I could see them carrying on with telling them it was just a dream but what about the others? They often don't react with "What's going on?" There's also that not seeming to recognize the girls even though they aren't in disguise either,haha.

---

Episode 20

Looks like things are starting to pick up now. You have
not only the introduction of the third fairy but the seemingly true leader of the baddies, Dune, makes a brief appearance. He's voiced by Hikaru Midorikawa who does the voice of Koga in Saint Seiya Omega, along with others, but I was kind of almost thinking it was Koga talking there just with having watched SSO for so long now. Even the baddies teamed up in the fight for the first time.

It was also nice to get an episode focused partially on Momoka again. I remember now seeing that gif of Momoka pushing down on Erika's head here in the thread.

I also think it's kind of funny how they've kept the little running gag of someone encountering Sasorina and exclaiming "Henna hito!" to which she gets upset and replies "Shitsurei ne!".

---

Episode 21

Mentioning before about Ban-kun, I didn't see him in the classroom group shots but you can see him as the student on the left with his back turned in the one shot that the teacher is going to look into the hallway.

This episodes fight was alright but the reasoning behind it felt a little silly. It was like they needed something and that was the best they could come up with. Also,
trying to catch a trespasser with a small butterfly net, haha. Cobraja's entrance there was pretty good though.

Regarding the theme of this episode...
Ban-kun as a PreCure would have been pretty funny, haha. Unless it's someone not introduced yet, I think the best guess would be the student council president girl who's name I forget right now. It kind of told you without telling you. It focused on the camera girl and soccer girl and had an amusing diversion with Ban-kun. While she quickly appears, I guess to maybe try and trick you, Potpurri doesn't get a chance to talk to her. While I didn't think it would happen anyway, the show even rules out Yuri getting a new heart seed. There was still the actress Azusa and the Mother's Day girl Nanami but the student council girl has had two whole episodes devoted to her, not just one and she's had a few small cameo appearances as well. It seems like it's been dropping hints such as the show having you think she could have been a boy but she's actually a girl. Despite her somewhat maybe male upbringing she still likes cute things and has a liking to the colour yellow as show by her making a dress. Potpurri is also yellow and there's the whole colour coding thing which the show mostly seems to follow. Barring a newly introduced character or some crazy big twist like Sasorina really being a PreCure or something, I'm going with the student council president girl.

I guess that comment about PreCure playing soccer was also a reference to one of the other girls but I haven't seen any earlier series aside from about half or so of the first Pretty Cure.

It was also kind of interesting how they changed the stock footage of putting a heart seed away from Tsubomi's hands to one of the mascots because the girls were busy when it happened.
 

cajunator

Banned
I've read and watched it, and prefer the anime. Those translation notes are pretty classic though!

Cute is cute. However, anime containing more Cute per second is cuter than manga which only has cute. Its science.

Pretty interesting MAKING OF for Little Witch Academia:

http://www3.nhk.or.jp/nhkworld/english/tv/imagine/arch.html

It's in English, so watch it. It's supposed to be for Anime Mirai as a whole, but they focused on LWA for obvious reasons.

thanks for this. Will watch later.

OMG that narrator voice haha.
Some interesting stuff. Dat Yoshinari slap.

Edit:

School Days 03
Sekai > Kotonoha. Also more Makoto being an idiot. A shame for all other awesome Makotos in anime.
Also we get more hints of what seems to be the formation of a harem of sorts.

Makoto is always a total idiot but this trainwreck hasn't quite begun.

That's specifically a reason why it's different to the manga, but not necessarily a reason why it's worse, though. Although history often suggests otherwise, differing from a manga doesn't necessarily make something bad - infact, there's a number of clear examples purely restricted to CLAMP works (mostly thinking of Angelic Layer here) where the anime is both wildly different and most certainly superior.

Angelic Layer is fantastic and a good example of why anime is better than manga. This stuff needs to move. It needs to come alive. It needs memorable music and voices.

What would the argument for Cutey Honey to not be a magical girl show be? If we go by "source of the powers of the heroine", Cutey Honey isn't any different from Corrector Yui or Nanoha. If we go by "the way in which the heroine fights", Honey is fairly similar to Precure and Nanoha (again). If we go by target audience, Honey fits right in with Uta Kata and Nanoha (I'm abusing this example). Hell, you can even compare it to shows like Minky Momo and Akko-chan due to Honey using her powers to change shape and take different "jobs".

Uhh...Cutey honey is totally a magical girl show. She is literally a girl who is magic. What else could it be?

Gargantia has blushing shoulders because that's what Hanaharu Naruko draws them like.

That's a part of it yes. And I was talking about the whole episode as a whole, not just what he was talking about.

Blushing shoulders are best shoulders. The guy is a hentai artist. what did people expect?

Yes!!



Much knows what's up.



Awwww yeah!



Yeah no doubt Mitsu is my #1 OTP.



So cute.



She has made a strong case!

Mitsu is indeed the best and the rest aren't close.

All I know about Cardcaptor Sakura is that little girls date their adult teachers.

Then you need to know more about CCS!

only ichigo I know are the dude in Bleach and the ones on the panties of ichigo 100%

Theres another Ichigo..

Sort of sucks. Usually it takes us roughly 1 month to get through each AnimeGAF OT. I wonder if we'll even make it to OT4. *sigh*

We still could. Have faith, little mascot-kun!

Mio>>>Ritsu>>>>>>>>>>Sawako>>>>Azusa>>>>Jun>>Yui=Ui>Bushy brows

Ritsu > Mio >Sawako >>>Ui > Jun >>Yui >> Mugi >>>>>>>>>Azusa

That k-on poster in the movie thread brought uo something I have noticed in some of these anime were the girls are trying to be portrayed cute. Why are there knees bent like that and point inward (maybe just kyoani thing). Wish I could find a gif for it.

That is a common "cute" pose in many mediums. It works so damned well too!
 

cajunator

Banned
The same people that find this completely inoffensive cover creepy:

I cant help but think actual girls with flat chest would get offended with how up in arms GAF gets about characters with no boobs. Not all girls have boobs. But I'm not sure if many Gaffers have actually seen a girl so I don't blame them for not knowing.

Noses are overrated. All mine does is make it harder to breathe during allergy season. :/

Oh god you aint kiddin >_

yay miku! \^.^/



After the shit that happened this week, I'm pretty sure everyone that isn't a NRA member is on that list.

Im an NRA member and an Otaku. the govt is totally confused by my actions.
 
Darker than Black: Gaiden 2


I should have mentioned this with the prior episode, but I have no clue how Hei and Yin got into the situation they're in now. A proper prologue would have been nice. I at least hope these last two episodes will somehow tie in to the beginning of S2.
 

Dresden

Member
Darker than Black: Gaiden 2



I should have mentioned this with the prior episode, but I have no clue how Hei and Yin got into the situation they're in now. A proper prologue would have been nice. I at least hope these last two episodes will somehow tie in to the beginning of S2.

They do, which makes them really nonsensical. :(
 

Articalys

Member
The newest Sword Art Online light novel volume (12) moved 187,409 copies in its first week on sale.

Just thought you might want to know.

In perhaps more pleasant news to the lot of you, the first LN volume of Hataraku Maou-sama saw a decent sales bump from the anime starting to air.
 
Guess Im bringing up the rear.

The newest Sword Art Online light novel volume (12) moved 187,409 copies in its first week on sale.

Just thought you might want to know.

In perhaps more pleasant news to the lot of you, the first LN volume of Hataraku Maou-sama saw a decent sales bump from the anime starting to air.

I hope they actually are pursuing trying to get SAO to release here in english by some book publishers.

I wouldnt mind having more in general, then I could go back into reading more than one/two novels a year.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom