With a few more episodes of everything under my belt this is how I see the season so far:
Best
My Hero Academia S2 - Ton of fun so far, I can see why people feel the manga hit its stride at this point (Sports festival was the only arc I hadn't read/seen at this point.)
Attack on Titan S2 - So glad to finally experience these parts with actually enjoyable visuals <-- shots at manga art. Now the good story can be good visually too.
KADO - Methodical, gripping, I'm still hooked to see how it'll play out.
Tsukigakirei - My wife and I seem so at odds on this one. I surprisingly love it, while she's much more mediocre on it.
Good
Atom: The Beginning - Not feeling the problems are quite as big as others make them out to be. So far seems to capture the same tone as what I've enjoyed of Astro Boy (The 2003 version to be specific, since there's like, 4 iterations counting the CGI movie.
Re:Creators - I'm so at odds with Gaf on this. Episode 2 was a bit weak, but Episode 3 was really interesting as they tried to explore the internal mechanics of creators and creations. I mean, it's not a mind-blowing show, but it's a fun idea.
Eromanga-Sensei - If they can keep the sis/bro stuff to a minimum
then I feel like it's still a solid comedy.
Grimoire of Zero - Still having a lot of fun with this one.
The Royal Tutor - Pretty funny and seems to get more enjoyable every episode.
Girl Beats Boys - Still funny and insane
WorldEnd - It's enjoyable, though I'm still not crazy about it like others, I think that's because I still feel like I don't really know most of the girls besides that they're cute and shouldn't have to die.
Sakura Quest: Haven't seen the latest episode but I still feel it's a fun comedy. Not sure what all the trouble is about.
Sword Oratoria - Generally pretty fun, though the grouping joke is already dangerously old.
Seven Mortal Sins - If you like ecchi that pushes boundaries to the max, this is inappropriately fun.
Decent
Alice & Zouroku - I liked this show a lot more when we were focused on the slice of life stuff and the latest developments honestly kinda feel like stuff that should've happened much later in the story after we'd really built up a relationship between Zouroku and Sana. I don't hate the thriller/supernatural stuff, but I feel like the show does better when that stuff isn't squarely in the foreground.
Love Tyrant - Gradually becoming more miss than hit for me and I feel like some of the humor is way to random i.e. Rape Penguin.
Bad
Akashic Records: It speeds through anything that might've given a sense of character interaction and relationships in order to hit the big dramatic events of episode 3. So then episode 4 feels really unearned as we've never really seen Glenn get to know the whole class outside of montages and being told he did.
Awful
I already dropped everything I felt was actually awful.
