Just finished watching the DS9 series on Netflix, took me about 2-3 months.
I probably watched about 60-75% of the episodes when I was a kid/teen, but this was the first time watching every ep of the series and as an adult. A lot of the political themes went over my head as a kid, back then I just loved the on-going battle between the Dominion and Alpha Quadrant.
Anyway, overall I think the series still holds up pretty strong. The character development and story-arc are excellent, and it touches on themes where other Treks were afraid to boldly go. Most of DS9s short-comings were basically the same as all the other Trek series. Rough first season, holodeck episodes, random non-sensical time travel, and re-hashed episodes. Basically the filler episodes.
But since DS9 had an on-going story-arc, the filler episodes were clearly identifiable. Also in the latter seasons, DS9 had 6 & 8 part episodes which were completely devoid of filler.
I just really enjoyed the continuity of the show. Situations that happened in seasons 1-3, actually would be relevant to some eps in seasons 4 - 6. For example, early on in the series Dr. Bashir finds the cure for the "Blight". Then several seasons later he goes to a conference to speak about the Blight. Also the characters in general will reference things that happened to them in early seasons. It makes the characters feel more alive since they actually remember what you saw them experience. You don't get this with episodic resets.
That said, there were a few things that still annoyed me with the series:
- It seemed like it took about a season and a half for the actors to really settle in their roles in DS9.
- Too many alternate universe eps. The first one has fine. Maybe another would have been okay, but it felt like there was at least 5-6 alt eps. I think they finally stopped because they killed off too many cast members in the alt universe.
- They should have designed/constructed better gun props which didn't look like fisher price plastic toys.
- The revelation about Dr Bashir's past in the latter seasons, basically turned him into Dr. Data. Aside from he eps where he was helping the institutionalized, it didn't really add much to his character or the storyline. It just became annoying character detail O'Brian would have to bring up almost every ep.
- Ezrie Dax should have just been a 2-3 episode character and then gone back to Trill. The writers/producers knew it was the last season of DS9, not sure why they threw a brand new character with the main cast, which all had been fully developed for 7 seasons.
- Was it just me or did Kieko and O'Brian in the latter seasons seem to be a broken replicator away from a divorce? I was almost certain that either O'Brian would run away with Bashir or Keiko would leave him for a plant.
- Jake Sisqo's receding hairline
I'm already starting to have Star Trek withdrawals. But I don't know if I want to watch Voyager again, I couldn't stand it when I was younger. Also Enterprise always gets mediocre to terribad reviews.... but I guess I should watch it since it's the only Star Trek TV series I haven't seen.