-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Star Wars Mafia |OT| A Wretched Hive of Scum and Villainy
- Thread starter MattyG
- Start date
but no doctor.
Matt Attack
Member
I'm really sorry about this but even after going over most of the thread again, I just don't have enough information to make a conclusive vote. All I really got out of it is that I think I trust eJawa and AB a bit more than I did before. I know that I don't want to vote for CzarTim or raindoc because they feel more rebel to me than not. Palmer is still probably neutral to me. That doesn't leave me with very many options for my vote though, so I'll go with the one who I'm more suspicious of:
VOTE: YesNOnoNOYes
Should we be pushing for the identity of Palmer's target at this point? I'm not sure it's a great idea but frankly I'm starved for new information.
VOTE: YesNOnoNOYes
Should we be pushing for the identity of Palmer's target at this point? I'm not sure it's a great idea but frankly I'm starved for new information.
ATM I don't think we've much to gain from that, but the Hutts could score a double "kill".
If he is telling the truth.
Oh man.
AbsolutBro
Member
wat
Which btw is why you should always lynch day 1, increases the chances of being right while removing potential candidates.
Only 5 hours left guys.
Vote count:
YesNOnoNOYes (0)
Palmer_v1
redhood56 (0)
Palmer_v1
CzarTim (2)
raindoc
Palmer_v1
Why the hell are people waiting so long to vote? This is terrible.
Wait a second mister - you said yourself that revealing your target would result in a double kill.
I might have said it COULD result in a double kill. I can protect either myself or my target each night. At the time, I couldn't know for sure if they had a role blocker, strongman, or double kill to get around it. My safest defense was obfuscation at that point. At this point, I'm fairly certain it's just a thief and UI, and I'll obviously choose to protect my target each night as the games comes to an end.
It's been a daily struggle.
YesNOnoNOYes
Member
You forgot MattAttack's vote against me, raindoc.
Even though he kept ignoring my question with regards to his supposed to be 'pro-town' profile :<
I mean... he even voted for Zipped even when Makai was on the chopping block... I guess at least he was on board OceanicAir's lynching, though XD
As for my vote, I guess I better make true to my promise of not voting against the flow this time. So:
vote: CzarTim
More like:
You're Darth Vader right?
and how have we not had an actual Jedi or Sith get revealed?
AbsolutBro
Member
Sorry guys, in-game day is ending weirdly in the middle of the workday for me and things are insane at work since our network has been down for two days.
Onward:
I have deleted and retyped this post about six or seven times now trying to decide on my vote. It's hard. If we're wrong today, we could lose tonight. I've had my suspicions for most of you, some more than others. But still...
Vote: CzarTim
Little things adding up man. And while I can defend some things, other things that at first seem pro-Rebel start coming out anti-Rebel with hindsight.
Calling out non-voters seemed Pro-Rebel at the time, but now knowing definitively that at least 3 of those people are Rebels it just comes across and blackballing.
Advocating the shielded out them self. It made sense to confirm Quantum, but at the same time it was abused either way. If a hutt got the shield, they just lie and we go for QuantumBro. If a Rebel got the shield, the Hutts have a target to steal from. All after Quantum told us he had no more protection.
This exchange
you had with OA
about Shields / QB
... it feels like you both knew the shield went to a Hutt, but wanted to put on a show.
I'm still super suspicious about Redhood, but as I reread this stupidly long and convoluted thread I have to watch for what jumps out, and those are the things that did.
Sorry man. Unless you flip hutt and then HA!
Onward:
I have deleted and retyped this post about six or seven times now trying to decide on my vote. It's hard. If we're wrong today, we could lose tonight. I've had my suspicions for most of you, some more than others. But still...
Vote: CzarTim
Little things adding up man. And while I can defend some things, other things that at first seem pro-Rebel start coming out anti-Rebel with hindsight.
Calling out non-voters seemed Pro-Rebel at the time, but now knowing definitively that at least 3 of those people are Rebels it just comes across and blackballing.
Advocating the shielded out them self. It made sense to confirm Quantum, but at the same time it was abused either way. If a hutt got the shield, they just lie and we go for QuantumBro. If a Rebel got the shield, the Hutts have a target to steal from. All after Quantum told us he had no more protection.
This exchange
you had with OA
about Shields / QB
... it feels like you both knew the shield went to a Hutt, but wanted to put on a show.
I'm still super suspicious about Redhood, but as I reread this stupidly long and convoluted thread I have to watch for what jumps out, and those are the things that did.
Sorry man. Unless you flip hutt and then HA!
AbsolutBro
Member
Well this is after A New Hope, so the only Jedi left is Yoda. We did have a Force Sensitive Rebel get himself killed though.
AbsolutBro
Member
And now I'm in bizarro world because I find myself agreeing with Redhood.
This
Fuckin
Game
lol
AbsolutBro
Member
I feel like I'm missing something here...
Forgot to add Matt's vote:
Vote count:
YesNOnoNOYes (1)
Palmer_v1
MattAttack
redhood56 (0)
Palmer_v1
CzarTim (4)
raindoc
Palmer_v1
YesNo
AbsolutBro
Updated above^
AbsolutBro
Member
This, this I can get behind. eJawa has the least chance of being a hutt, in that he can't be the Thief. Sure, he could be the UI, but so could any of you.
vote: redhood
Gah, why is today's vote so hard?
AbsolutBro
Member
Dumb question. I already said why.
AbsolutBro
Member
Why though? Why suicide it?
We basically can't trust him after he went all-in on Zipped and was proven wrong. He basically lost his value to town once that happened.
Do you really think we should go after Redhood today? I might switch my vote if you really think that's a better choice.
AbsolutBro
Member
I honestly don't know. I flip flopped on Redhood and Czar when writing up my original vote post. You and Czar have a good point about Czar being a distraction and losing the trust of some people, myself obviously included. :-\ I still feel like he's a Rebel, more than I feel that way about Redhood at least. But Czar's being such a driving force for the game sort of highlights my suspicions of him a bit more; the contrast is more stark than for redhood, of whom I've basically had a simmering suspicion for a few days now. It hasn't gone up, hasn't gone down, so it's still just "there" without a whole lot of substance (as my other post shows).
I honestly don't know. I can see what Czar is trying to do. Bite the bullet so the rest of us have the thoughts of a confirmed Rebel for what could be our last vote. The problem is if he flips Rebel, we could lose tonight and that sacrifice would be for nothing.
AbsolutBro
Member
I have to run to the store on my lunch hour. Probably won't be back by the time voting ends, but I'll try to follow along on my cell phone while I'm at the store.
AbsolutBro
Member
Definitely true. But in context, you're trying to sacrifice yourself; he's not.
I mean, if there are 3 total hutts and we detain a rebel, our only hope is that they kill the UI tonight.
I really can't see there being 3 hutts. 2 would be working together and know I'm not a main hutt so either they both had already voted for me when i was sitting at 4 votes, or they're playing super conservatively and decided not to hammer me just in case they hit the IA tonight. Like I literally asked people to vote for me so they had an out.
I considered that argument but the UI throws things off. If there were 2 Hutts and a UI, they cannot be sure about anything. They might be hammering the UI on accident, or the UI might not catch on to the plan.
I still think it's extremely unlikely we have 3 at this point, but it's technically possible.