So I decided to buy Web Of Shadows as well because I know I'm going to have full on Spidey-fever after the movie tomorrow, and sometimes comics aint enough.
It's actually kinda fun to compare these two games (WoS was the last open world game, right? Or was Spider-Man 3 after?), despite any superficial similarities they couldn't be more different and have flaws unique to each other.
I don't know if I can say this right, but yeah Amazing Spider-Man's web swinging is "easy mode" but it just clicks and is fun as hell. I spent hours just straight up swinging through the city and I never got bored. Whoever came up with web rush deserves a gold star, and WoS feels lesser without it.
That being said, WoS has great web swinging in it's own right, mostly because it takes a bit to get down but once you "master" it, it's a blast but not in the same way AMZSM is. Does that makes sense? I need sleep.
Combat in both games is great, but once again WoS has that depth thing going for it.
One thing Amazing has going for it, and it's the thing putting it over the top for me over WoS (for now), is that it absolutely NAILS being Spider-Man. I think it's the quips. Amazing has a great lead voice actor, and he's always talking shit. Giant robot? Busting it's chops. Monster? Makes fun of it. 2-bit thug? Let's em know who's boss. That's how I like my spider-man. I never even got tired of his screams of joy during an awesome swing.
On the other hand WoS's Spider-man is annoying, and worst of all he is dead silent during the game. No trash talking during battles, no incidental banter, just a few jokes during mission set ups. It takes away from the game just enough to not put it over Amazing Spider-Man.