• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

: *:* The British detective drama appreciation thread *:*:

Status
Not open for further replies.

pashmilla

Banned
Takin a break from politics threads for a while. Let's talk about something fun! These kinds of shows are my main weakness, after pretty girls and soft cats. Of course shows like Sherlock and Broadchurch are known all over the world (Broadchurch has an American remake, I think?) but I'm not talking about those kinds of detective dramas (high budget, high-brow, you get me). I'm talking the shows that are almost always an ITV production. You know, those. Procedural dramas, often involving a subplot thread about the personal lives of the main characters, and sometimes cheesy as shit, and other times so, so good. A basic rundown for the uninitiated:

Midsomer Murders. Not the oldest, but still the granddaddy of them all, somehow.

midsomer-murders-set-1.jpg


Look at those haircuts. LOOK AT THEM. Midsomer Murders is a very apt title. The show is set in the English county of Midsomer which, despite what even some British people think, is not actually a real place. Midsomer is filled with little old ladies who are also ruthless serial killers. Midsomer has a murder rate of 32 per million people. That's a higher murder rate than Syria. SYRIA! The Queen of England herself once asked the producers why anyone would move to Midsomer, since they're only going to get murdered. My favourite part of the show is the first-person cold opening following a pair of Black-Gloved Hands of Death™ as they go to enact their nefarious deeds, usually driven by such compelling motives as joining the village social club, winning the local regatta, and, occasionally, incest. It's that kind of show. 11/10, everyone should watch this. Your life will be enriched for it, I promise you.

Inspector Morse

83546839f5e2dc86fb3876fac21e8081.jpg


I'll be honest, I haven't watched this show. I've tried so many times to get into it, but I just can't. I find old!Morse an unlikable old coot. However, the success and popularity of this show gave rise to not one, but TWO spinoffs, both of which I love, so I can't hate it too much.

Spinoff 1: Lewis (known as Inspector Lewis in the US)

01-127327.jpg


Set some twenty years after the end of Inspector Morse, Lewis follows the adventures of Morse's former sergeant, Robbie Lewis, now a tired and world-weary detective inspector. Lewis is a straightforward simple dude, but his own sergeant, James Hathaway, is a former priest-in-training who is intellectual and sarcastic and vulnerable, and their differing personalities lead to all sorts of wonderful drama, but THEY LOVE EACH OTHER SO MUCH OK. Their banter and father-son relationship gives me life. I cry every time. 10/10, would recommend.

Spinoff 2: Endeavour

MV5BMTczNDQ1NDUwOF5BMl5BanBnXkFtZTgwNzg1MTUzMjE@._V1._CR221,3,1055,1494_UY268_CR3,0,182,268_AL_.jpg


Endeavour is a prequel to Inspector Morse, following a young, fresh-faced Morse in his early days as a copper under the tutelage of gruff-but-fair Fred Thursday (played by the spectacular Roger Allam). Lots of delicious drama and angst and some intriguing mysteries, and it's set in the swinging 60s to boot. 10/10, would recommend.

And if you like stuff set in the 60s, check out...

Inspector George Gently

41Onp9qoRaL._SY445_.jpg


This show is set in the 60s, but in the grim grey hellscape that was County Durham in the 60s as opposed to genteel Oxford. Compared to Endeavour's more idealised depction of the 60s, Inspector George Gently does not shy away from portraying the bigotry of the time, and addressing it in a critical light. The show has tackled homophobia, racism, Islamophobia, sexism, all in a very effective manner. It's often dark and bleak as hell, but man it is SO. GOOD. 11/10, everyone needs to watch this.

Inspector Lynley Mysteries

518PYV4S0QL._AC_UL320_SR224,320_.jpg


The tale of a posh, upper-class detective inspector and his working-class, loud-mouthed sergeant, and the oodles of sexual tension between them. Just KISS ALREADY. 10/10, would recommend.

And finally, but far from least, my own personal fave:

2870-Landform-Surveys-News-Images-Vera.png


Vera follows Detective Inspector Vera Stanhope, a jaded old woman with a whole host of issues, and her young sergeant Joe Ashford, who slowly draws her out of her shell. This is the mother-son relationship we need but don't deserve. It's so beautiful okay. SO. BEAUTIFUL. THE CHARACTER DEVELOPMENT. i can't handle this. fuck. 112456787654567876/10. Everybody watch this show. fuck im cryin again
 
Do any of these compare well to Law & Order (mothership, og), NYPD Blue or Homicide? We tried to watch the UK version of Law & Order and it kind of sucked.
 

pashmilla

Banned
Do any of these compare well to Law & Order (mothership, og), NYPD Blue or Homicide? We tried to watch the UK version of Law & Order and it kind of sucked.

They're not really anything like Law & Order, etc. Very much their own thing. If you're leery, I'd recommend Vera, Lewis or Inspector George Gently to dip your toes in. Midsomer Murders is great fun but it's not the best first impression :p
 

Chuckie

Member
Oh my God......I know all of these...and I have seen at least a couple of episodes of every one of them.

I love George Gently. Great show and probably my fave.

Midsomer Murders is my guilty pleasure. Used to watch that with me mom every Wednesday. I simple love the setting of those small English villages.
 
They're not really anything like Law & Order, etc. Very much their own thing. If you're leery, I'd recommend Vera, Lewis or Inspector George Gently to dip your toes in. Midsomer Murders is great fun but it's not the best first impression :p

Procedural cop dramas are pretty much my wife and I's favorite form of TV so I'll definitely check them out.
 

BigDes

Member
Do any of these compare well to Law & Order (mothership, og), NYPD Blue or Homicide? We tried to watch the UK version of Law & Order and it kind of sucked.

Not really, they come from a different place.

Most of the shows that are highlighted here share the same Agatha Christie DNA.

EDIT: Also no Touch of Frost?

Come on, Frost is awesome.
 
there's the GOAT, Jim Bergerac from the BBC's 'Bergerac'
Detective on Jersey in the Channel Islands for a (fictional?) department set up to investigate crimes involving strangers (but really any crime that has ties top either Jim's ex father-in-law Charlie, or his daughter, or his ex-wife, or restaurant owner Diamante Lil.

First couple of years were so good, then it ran for too long and just got silly.

Theme tune is one also one of the greats
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xQ369paM8_Y
 

KAOz

Short bus special
Does Wallender fall into this group?

That should technically fall under Swedish Police Dramas though since that seems to be the only thing we fucking produce here. Only. Thing. Police dramas everywhere in Sweden.

But yeah, UK-version of Wallander should probably fall in here.
 
Not a detective drama, but does Jonathan Creek count? One of my favourite TV programmes of all time and it's about a man who designs tricks for a magician and works with a novelist to investigate unsolved or unusual crimes - because of his job he has a knack for putting pieces together and working out strange situations.
 

jorma

is now taking requests
British crime dramas are the best. Lewis was my favourite for a long time. I don't see how broadchurch doesn't apply to to the genre though?

Also missing DCI Banks, Waking the dead, Silent witness, Wire in the blood (so so awesome), Scott and Bailey, Whitechapel, and Cracker. Man Cracker was good shit. I really liked Wallander as well, despite me being Swedish :)
 

Chuckie

Member
That should technically fall under Swedish Police Dramas though since that seems to be the only thing we fucking produce here. Only. Thing. Police dramas everywhere in Sweden.

But yeah, UK-version of Wallander should probably fall in here.

Don't forget the awesome Äkta människor!
 
I'm generally ambivalent to these shows but I was really surprised by how much I enjoyed the latest season of Endeavour, it has a quality to it I wasn't expecting.

Also Broadchurch and Happy Valley are excellent as well.
 
Morse is the best ever. THE FUCKING BEST. It's no low brow bullshit either. John Thaw is amazing (RIP)

I like Lewis as well (They filmed a scene round the corner from me - whoop!) but it's not a patch on the original.
 

Blue Lou

Member
I've just caught up on Line of Duty in anticipation of series 4. It was excellent, no wonder it was BBC2's highest rated show. Deservedly on BBC One.
 
I'll always love the ITV Poirot adaptations. David Suchet honed that role to perfection over twenty years and he's not going to be beaten whenever they inevitably remake them.

I've just caught up on Line of Duty in anticipation of series 4. It was excellent, no wonder it was BBC2's highest rated show. Deservedly on BBC One.
Line of Duty is indeed amazing.
 

Google

Member
Mates....Midsommer Murders is the fucking boss.

Watching a lot of it these days. It makes me miss the late 90's/early 00's of my teenage years but it's also full of sex, murder and old people banging each other.

I love it.
 

Fat4all

Banned
does Poirot count?

I've seen every single episode of Poirot

I've read all the books as well

I really like Poirot
 

Seiryoden

Member
Where's Prime Suspect? Or is helen mirren too awesome for this thread

The lack of Prime Suspect and Cracker in this OP vexes me. Never watched Inspector Morse? Fuck's sake you should've just titled your thread Middlebrow ITV Cop Shows Popular With Daily Mail Readers instead of baiting me into this spiral of mediocrity.

No Cracker, no Prime Suspect, didn't watch Morse, smfh

I mean you haven't even listed Foyle's War ffs.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom