Horseticuffs said:
Anyone tried the "Heroica" games under the LEGO label? I just saw a commercial for them, and they seem great for kids having only a play time of 10-20 minutes. I imagine that set up would be much longer than that, though I guess that's sort of the point with a LEGO product.
Here's a link to the main set's BGG page:
http://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/94731/heroica-fortaan
Seems sort of neat how you can combine all of the sets. Why, I bet even your local big box store would carry this since it's LEGO. I read a review on the BGG forums saying that the rules are dead simple and it's easy to make your own, so that's certainly something to think about, too.
The rules are very simplistic and rely far too much on random rolls of the dice (LEGO's game philosophy is that randomness evens the playing field, so kids don't get frustrated or angry). Truth be told, it is a mildly enjoyable game. We play with my kids (aged 3 and 6) and they enjoy it quite a bit. There's a lot of complicated things happening, with multiple goals, rules, and things to keep track of, but they've all been simplified down to the point that a 6 year old can play without help.
So, as a parent, I think the rules are good for kids. It warms my heart to see my daughters traveling through caves and killing orcs rather than arguing over which My Little Pony was cuter. With all four sets put together, it create a much more interesting experience that requires a bit more planning and cooperation. Each set has unique items and rules, but not enough to be overwhelming for kids.
I don't think I would recommend it to an adult that didn't love LEGOs and that wasn't willing to create their own rules. The rules, as is, aren't deep or strategic enough to keep adults interested. You really need to customize the rules (there's a thread over on Eurobricks for Heroica house rules, but I haven't seen any full conversions made available)
Frankly, with just a couple changes and all the sets put together, the game can be pretty fun with kids. I hope they release more Heroica sets in 2012, with Advanced Heroica rules, because there is a lot of potential. If nothing else, the building blocks are literally there to make whatever dungeon crawl experience you want.
For the record, my house rules:
- Fully cooperative game. Usually, the one who defeats the boss wins. But we play together to defeat all the enemies on the board together. There's no winner, and there's no real way to lose, but the kids still enjoy it.
- In the caves, there are blocks you can't get past unless you roll a specific thing on the dice. After all four of us getting stuck for about ten turns, we decided to treat the boulders as enemies that didn't fight back that you kill and remove from the board.
- There's not enough gold on the board, so there is very little buying of weapons (the weapons aren't that awesome, but the kids like to collect them in their backpack). So we said you can sell the enemies you defeat for 1 gold each. Also, you can typically only buy weapons, but we also allowed the kids to buy potions - but can only have a max of one each in their pack.
EDIT: The
LEGO Heroica website has rules you can download.