Support NeoGAF

[Boss Doggie]

Not into the Ponies but it sure is funny seeing the haters froth at the mouth so much, god damn. Who gives a shit what other people watch, especially if it's actual quality work.

What's hilarious is that they're pretty much doing the same fallacy when it comes to "their" nostalgic show (e.g. Transformers).

 

[Devolution]

My beef with the Bronies is that they feel the need to insert their cutesy animated gifs into every goddamn thread. Keep it to your own thread! Stop shitting up other threads with your animated gifs.

Flat out telling them it gets you heated will probably net you more gifs you know lol.

What's hilarious is that they're pretty much doing the same fallacy when it comes to "their" nostalgic show (e.g. Transformers).

I've said it before if the show has quality writing, stuff that goes above kid's heads and good animation, and the only thing people are hung up on are it's for girls. Get the fuck over it. I grew up watching non-stop shit that was "for little boys."

 

[Neki]

My beef with the Bronies is that they feel the need to insert their cutesy animated gifs into every goddamn thread. Keep it to your own thread! Stop shitting up other threads with your animated gifs.

are Simpsons gifs or other random t.v show gifs somehow more appropriate then pony gifs? you should just hate on people posting gifs.

 

[Htown]

This is how most people do it. Most people don't care, some people even laugh at the occasional .gif or picture. Most the threads that ended up derailed were because of the people who just went all nerd-rage on the whole thing.

That's what it looks like from the outside of this whole "controversy", yeah.

 

[Deleted member 74300]

The same could be said for all animated gifs.

 

[Conceited]

are Simpsons gifs or other random t.v show gifs somehow more appropriate then pony gifs?

Yes, because those other GIFs are actually good.

 

[notworksafe]

The same could be said for all animated gifs.

just keep all gifs out of normal GAF and we'd be happy, amirite?

Hm. Seems overly defensive but whatever.

Sorry you need to get so uptight. I just don't care for your cartoon.

 

[Negator]

My beef with the Bronies is that they feel the need to insert their cutesy animated gifs into every goddamn thread. Keep it to your own thread! Stop shitting up other threads with your animated gifs.

It has been mentioned before, but people who usually post the gifs are trolling. I have also yet to see any pony gifs in any other threads besides the PonyGAF OT, and well, this thread.

Hm. Seems overly defensive but whatever.

Sorry you need to get so uptight. I just don't care for your cartoon.

I ain't even mad

 

[Boss Doggie]

I think Captain Falcon is a derogatory character who spews out annoying catchphrases while offending Kamen Rider fans. Should I make a lobby?

 

[Discotheque]

are Simpsons gifs....

YES THEY ARE. You comparing a GOAT to a sheep.

 

[Boss Doggie]

YES THEY ARE. You comparing a GOAT to a sheep.

But goats are more awesome than sheep.

 

[2th]

Yes, because those other GIFs are actually good.

 

[Discotheque]

But goats are more awesome than sheep.

Simpson's the GOAT

 

[Regulus Tera]

All of PonyGAF has let me down today.

Except Fish and DrForester.

 

[notworksafe]

I ain't even mad

If you say so.

Pony people should take the Korean singer-GAF approach as an example. That stuff rarely leaves their OT and almost never has an unneeded meme tacked on.

But it's not against the rules so whatever.

 

[Boss Doggie]

Simpson's the GOAT

That's not how analogy works! It should correlate to their positions!

 

[Uchip]

I think Captain Falcon is a derogatory character who spews out annoying catchphrases while offending Kamen Rider fans. Should I make a lobby?

fighting for justice is derogatory?

 

[Neki]

If you say so.

Pony people should take the Korean singer-GAF approach as an example. That stuff rarely leaves their OT and almost never has an unneeded meme tacked on.

But it's not against the rules so whatever.

or people could be more tolerant.

who knows.

Yes, because those other GIFs are actually good.

so how do we judge on good GIFs are based on? how relevant they are? how cool they look?

 

[survivor]

or people could be more tolerant.

who knows.

People should just nerd rage less often. It will solve all the problems.

 

[Narag]

or people could be more tolerant.

who knows.

Ideally it'd be see .gif, move on, rather than making a production out of it on either side.

 

[notworksafe]

or people could be more tolerant.

who knows.

Yep. Saying I don't care for it is intolerant.

 

[Deleted member 74300]

I think Captain Falcon is a derogatory character who spews out annoying catchphrases while offending Kamen Rider fans. Should I make a lobby?

Of course not.

Spoiler

FALCON KICK!

 

[Negator]

If you say so.

Pony people should take the Korean singer-GAF approach as an example. That stuff rarely leaves their OT and almost never has an unneeded meme tacked on.

But it's not against the rules so whatever.

I see way more SNSD gifs than pony gifs outside of their respective threads.

Side note: I have not actually seen anyone get banned for posting a pony gif.

 

[Puddles]

Same with Firefly.

Probably same fans, too.

At least Firefly fans want to fuck human characters.

 

[Pandaman]

If you say so.

Pony people should take the Korean singer-GAF approach as an example. That stuff rarely leaves their OT and almost never has an unneeded meme tacked on.

But it's not against the rules so whatever.

can you find an example of a pony gif posted outside of a pony thread [or starcraft thread] in the last month?

I'm genuinely curious because i don't see them.
admitedly i dont often go into gaming though.

 

[DrForester]

Poor Applejack.

 

[Boss Doggie]

Spoiler

FALCON KICK!

I like it better when it was called Rider Kick and when it can actually hit people.

 

[notworksafe]

can you find an example of a pony gif posted outside of a pony thread [or starcraft thread] in the last month?

I'm genuinely curious because i don't see them.
admitedly i dont often go into gaming though.

Odd that you specify starcraft thread as well. Is that not outside of a pony thread?

 

[DrForester]

What's hilarious is that they're pretty much doing the same fallacy when it comes to "their" nostalgic show (e.g. Transformers).

At least Firefly fans want to fuck human characters.

It is possible to enjoy movies, TV, games, etc. without wanting to have sex with what you see on screen.

Shocking, but true.

 

[Narag]

can you find an example of a pony gif posted outside of a pony thread [or starcraft thread] in the last month?

I'm genuinely curious because i don't see them.
admitedly i dont often go into gaming though.

http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?t=442635 It happens but it is rare.

 

[Neki]

Odd that you specify starcraft thread as well. Is that not outside of a pony thread?

a lot of pony gaffers exist in the starcraft thread. or more correctly, a lot of starcraft gaf don't hate MLP.

 

[Flying_Phoenix]

My beef with the Bronies is that they feel the need to insert their cutesy animated gifs into every goddamn thread. Keep it to your own thread! Stop shitting up other threads with your animated gifs.

Yes because every other fan group on GAF limits the gifs to their OT.

You NEVER see Lost, Lil' B, *insert anime*, gifs and memes etc.

 

[Pandaman]

Odd that you specify starcraft thread as well. Is that not outside of a pony thread?

well, there's a lot of crossover between the communities and we used to 'charge' players for training lessons by having them watch episodes of the show. >_>

 

[DrForester]

a lot of pony gaffers exist in the starcraft thread. or more correctly, a lot of starcraft gaf don't hate MLP.

Most gaffers don't hate MLP, most just don't care. The people who rage are a small amount of people, but they're loud about it.

 

[thetrin]

My roommate is a brony. I make fun of him about it when he brings it up, but it's all in good fun. Whatever. I like lucky star. It's not that different.

 

[2th]

can you find an example of a pony gif posted outside of a pony thread [or starcraft thread] in the last month?

I'm genuinely curious because i don't see them.
admitedly i dont often go into gaming though.

http://sweet2th.imgur.com/reaction_images

 

[Deleted member 74300]

I like it better when it was called Rider Kick and when it can actually hit people.

Like they actually made physical contact in those cheesy shows.

Spoiler

Come on man don't make me hate on Kamen Rider.

 

[notworksafe]

well, there's a lot of crossover between the communities and we used to 'charge' players for training lessons by having them watch episodes of the show. >_>

Ahh okay. Also thanks for answering in a non-jerk fashion.

Hm. Didn't take long for someone to find an errant pony gif. I see them more in Gaming than in OT, but the amount has slowed down lately. It is the off season though.

 

[Neki]

Yes because every other fan group on GAF limits the gifs to their OT.

You NEVER see Lost, Lil' B, *insert anime*, gifs and memes etc.

but those gifs are somehow better on an unspecified merit that we have not even discussed yet!

 

[Puddles]

Yes because every other fan group on GAF limits the gifs to their OT.

You NEVER see Lost, Lil' B, *insert anime*, gifs and memes etc.

Those other fan groups aren't goddamn furries.

 

[Big One]

It is possible to enjoy movies, TV, games, etc. without wanting to have sex with what you see on screen.

Shocking, but true.

How could you possibly not with Firefly?

As for MLP I hope no one here has honestly thought any of these ponies are sexy.

 

[Orayn]

Those other fan groups aren't goddamn furries.

Bronies aren't all furries dude.

 

[Pandaman]

http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?t=442635 It happens but it is rare.

I see. it probably has a little to do with me not keeping up with new stuff, which is where you'll find all the omg/yes/megaton stuff.

 

[Regulus Tera]

My roommate is a brony. I make fun of him about it when he brings it up, but it's all in good fun. Whatever. I like lucky star. It's not that different.

It could be worse. You could like K-ON!.

 

[DrForester]

can you find an example of a pony gif posted outside of a pony thread [or starcraft thread] in the last month?

I'm genuinely curious because i don't see them.
admitedly i dont often go into gaming though.

not a .gif but I dropped a reaction pic in the Daily Show thread after Colbert gave a shout out to bronies

http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?p=29779858#post29779858

And look! no rage!

 

[Negator]

Those other fan groups aren't goddamn furries.

If PonyGAF are all furries, AnimeGAF are all pedophiles and ALL of GAF are manchildren.

 

[Puddles]

If PonyGAF are all furries, AnimeGAF are all pedophiles and ALL of GAF are manchildren.

I see nothing to disagree with in this post.

 

[2th]

Those other fan groups aren't goddamn furries.

and you are implying PonyGAF is a bunch of furries? to that i say

Spoiler

posting pony gifs is highly amusing if only to see the reactions

 

[notworksafe]

As for MLP I hope no one here has honestly thought any of these ponies are sexy.

There was some odd comic produced by gaffer that was a bit in that direction lol.

 

[DrForester]

Those other fan groups aren't goddamn furries.

So by your logic, everyone who enjoyed The Lion King (And no, despite my enjoyment of MLP, I am not suggesting that it's anywhere as good as The Lion King) is a Furry, and by extension anyone who enjoys something with talking animals?