-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
The Price Is Right MAFIA edition |OT| Come on down!!!
- Thread starter Sophia
- Start date
"I won't flip town but I totally want you to win anyway"
Huh? We have another day right?
Vote tally:
wherearemahdragonz (2)
*splinter 565
kalor 744
el topo (1)
melonrabbit 573
melonrabbitt (0)
wherearemahdragonz 597 (720)
nin1000 (0)
kalor 628 (744)
dusk soldier (6)
starsketch 664
karkador 678
kyanrute 700
stanleypalmtree 739
ynnek7 740
christina mackenzie 741
magnumboy20xx (2)
dusk soldier 685 (710)
el topo 716
wherearemahdragonz 720
*splinter (1)
cornburrito 695
stanleypalmtree (1)
dusk soldier 728
Majority is 10
Day 2 ends in
wherearemahdragonz (2)
*splinter 565
kalor 744
el topo (1)
melonrabbit 573
melonrabbitt (0)
nin1000 (0)
dusk soldier (6)
starsketch 664
karkador 678
kyanrute 700
stanleypalmtree 739
ynnek7 740
christina mackenzie 741
magnumboy20xx (2)
el topo 716
wherearemahdragonz 720
*splinter (1)
cornburrito 695
stanleypalmtree (1)
dusk soldier 728
Majority is 10
Day 2 ends in
MagnumBoy20xx
Neo Member
I know I voted for dusk last day phase, but I am not really feeling his Lynch today. I would rather vote for someone felt more scummy to me.
Vote:wherearemahdragonz
Voting for a neutral Lynch at this time seems too much like a move that scum would make, mainly because it's a "safe" move. While I do have my suspicions on el topo, WAMD is the one who has more of a scum leaning right now.
Vote:wherearemahdragonz
Voting for a neutral Lynch at this time seems too much like a move that scum would make, mainly because it's a "safe" move. While I do have my suspicions on el topo, WAMD is the one who has more of a scum leaning right now.
StarSketch
Banned
Kark Is this what you wanted
I'd rather lynch WAMD today, have Magnum steal the Xbox, then lynch Dusk. Otherwise we probably have to lynch Magnum after all.
See post 752
Lone_Prodigy
Member
Interesting how Dusk has so many votes. Scum are pushing it along, sure, but he has given out a lot of information but no one has vouched for him. At all. Up to 8 unique bidders and two item holders yet Dusk is the only one telling us stuff.
With 18 left in the game, 8 bidders doesn't strongly suggest mafia is participating in the vote.
That's not a role claim
That's not Day 1
I might have missed them if you had some questions about my arguments.
Unless you're talking about the whole 'staying quiet keeps you safe' thing. If that was it then it's my turn to say I was being a bit facetious.
It is, everyone knows the best game is Infamous 2.
My response to Kawl was a joke.
99% of the time everything I say to Kawl is a joke unless I call him garbage, then I'm being 100% serious.
spoilers: it's all a joke
As for Dragonz all I can really say is I didn't know how to respond to her comment. It was a deflect and a hand-wavey joking response that just abruptly brought an end to that conversation.
Now it's my turn, Melon. I've noticed that you are starting to ignore most questions being thrown directly at you and are just moving on instead. Whether that is intentional or not doesn't matter but it does leave me feeling scum vibes about you.
StarSketch
Banned
No, but "even if I lose I want you guys to" sounds like a soft claim. After all, if he's town, he'd still win wven if he dies, no?
StarSketch
Banned
*"even if I lose I want you guys to win"
*sounds like a soft neutral claim
*even if he dies
Man I hate the no editing rule.
*sounds like a soft neutral claim
*even if he dies
Man I hate the no editing rule.
Dusk Soldier
Member
-Stanley Palmtree
has mainly avoided commenting on this game except for the occasional post here or there to give his opinions on the major events. Made a point to say that we shouldn't just target active players, and that we should focus more on some of the less actives. However contrarily, he hasn't actually offered up any suggestions for scum, and only places votes on high activity players.
-nin1000
has tried to discourage what he feels are bad lynches. Not much activity other than that.
-Sawneeks
probably the widest range of scum accusations. She has changed stances on several players, showing she is open to hearing other perspectives of issues.
-OceanicAir
Shown most suspicion towards players guilty of tunnelling or drive-by voting. He did advocate for policy lynching Blarg early, but later decided that it would be a waste of a vote.
-Kyanrute
opened with a soft town claim. Fairly active D1, but mostly silent since. A few activity prods, and a few summary posts. Not many scum accusations, and has already admitted than none of his votes so far were placed on players he thinks are scummy.
-Kalor
has been very analytical, and tried to avoid jumping on bandwagons. Kalor has several times offered up the hidden motives behind other players posts.
-Starsketch
has mainly stuck to voting for bandwagons. Cautioned us not to target melon. Gave circular reasoning when questioned on it.
-melonrabbit
probably one of our most active posters so far. Has garnered minor heat, I don't know that any of the votes against her were more than gut reads though.
---
It's still D2 so there is not much to work with.
Stanley, Kyanrute, and Nin are the scummiest from this lot.
Something is off about Starsketch too.
has mainly avoided commenting on this game except for the occasional post here or there to give his opinions on the major events. Made a point to say that we shouldn't just target active players, and that we should focus more on some of the less actives. However contrarily, he hasn't actually offered up any suggestions for scum, and only places votes on high activity players.
-nin1000
has tried to discourage what he feels are bad lynches. Not much activity other than that.
-Sawneeks
probably the widest range of scum accusations. She has changed stances on several players, showing she is open to hearing other perspectives of issues.
-OceanicAir
Shown most suspicion towards players guilty of tunnelling or drive-by voting. He did advocate for policy lynching Blarg early, but later decided that it would be a waste of a vote.
-Kyanrute
opened with a soft town claim. Fairly active D1, but mostly silent since. A few activity prods, and a few summary posts. Not many scum accusations, and has already admitted than none of his votes so far were placed on players he thinks are scummy.
-Kalor
has been very analytical, and tried to avoid jumping on bandwagons. Kalor has several times offered up the hidden motives behind other players posts.
-Starsketch
has mainly stuck to voting for bandwagons. Cautioned us not to target melon. Gave circular reasoning when questioned on it.
-melonrabbit
probably one of our most active posters so far. Has garnered minor heat, I don't know that any of the votes against her were more than gut reads though.
---
It's still D2 so there is not much to work with.
Stanley, Kyanrute, and Nin are the scummiest from this lot.
Something is off about Starsketch too.
It's still a stretch to call that a roleclaim compared to what he said this day. I forgot why we're even arguing this.
The important bit is that letting a neutral live is trouble. At worst, it's mafia claiming neutral. A little less worse, it's a neutral who WILL work against Town in unpredictable ways. Players sticking up for other players like this is really troubling.
Are you being purposely obtuse?
Do you have problems reading timers?
StarSketch
Banned
Splinter, question. Why are you defending the neutral? I know theoretically we can leave him alone, but Dusk is currently the one with most votes.
Dusk Soldier
Member
vote: Wherearemahdragonz
WAMD vs *Splinter has turned into a huge distraction, and I think it's allowing players to contribute w/o worrying about saying anything too controversial.
I've said this before but I think *Splinter's initial reaction to her flub was a huge stretch. Especially seeing as he made the exact same mistake a page or so later. However her attempts to try to explain away her mistake have actually made her look more scummy, not less.
If this isn't resolved today it's going to turn into a huge talking point again tomorrow. As scum isn't stupid enough to off one of these two in the middle of the night.
WAMD vs *Splinter has turned into a huge distraction, and I think it's allowing players to contribute w/o worrying about saying anything too controversial.
I've said this before but I think *Splinter's initial reaction to her flub was a huge stretch. Especially seeing as he made the exact same mistake a page or so later. However her attempts to try to explain away her mistake have actually made her look more scummy, not less.
If this isn't resolved today it's going to turn into a huge talking point again tomorrow. As scum isn't stupid enough to off one of these two in the middle of the night.
'I don't want to vote Magnum because it can be perceived as safe'
'I don't want to vote dusk because it would be a bandwagon now and I already bandwagoned Blarg on Day 1'
buuut I could be wrong.
But this makes me feel even worse about a Dragonz lynch despite my scum read on her.
hm.
I still don't trust Melon either but I feel like I need to go back and reevaluate my stance on her. It's just a gut feeling but I'm not trusting my own read on her and I would rather reread than place my vote there just yet.
melonrabbit
Member
I do love Infamous 2. But Delsin is superior to Cole so yeah.
I have responded to you, Dragonz, and El Topo throughout the day. If there are questions I've missed I will be glad to answer them.
Because I think it's in our best interest not to waste a lynch on him. As I said before, I'm not doing this to help Magnum, I couldn't care less if he wins or loses.
We're here to find scum, neutrals are a distraction
CornBurrito
Member
Looks like it's either WAMD or Dusk. I believe Dusk is the better option.
Vote: Dusk Soldier
Vote: Dusk Soldier
And then votes on Magnum instead.
Yeeaaahhh I'll go with my gut on this one
Vote: WhereAreMahDragonz
OceanicAir
Member
Dusk, you realize that you're ahead on votes by a good margin right? Are you hoping for a last minute surge or what? What do you think about the people that are voting for you? Anything else you want to say about the Xbox?
No lies detected. Cole is a cardboard box with electric powers.
Also there are a couple, not just ones from me:
It was for you and Kyan.
You never responded so I brought it up again but you never responded there either:
And then some from our argument towards the start of this Day phase you never replied to.
Might have missed some but I believe those were it.
melonrabbit
Member
I explained why I voted Splinter D1. I wanted to see reactions including his. I pegged him to be town because on his reaction and the back and forth felt genuine. At present, I am still leaning for him to be town although I disagree with him on a few points. Specifically, this plan to aid Mags.
Star hasn't posted too much but what she has has been consistent with her usual self. I can only based this off on playing with her in DP where she garnered a lot of heat for her more passive play style. That's why, so far, I'm inclined to believe she is mostly likely town.
melonrabbit
Member
As for the Blarg vote,
Other than yourself and Dusk no one else had struck me as scummy. I will need review Kalor as right now I'm null there. In general, though I don't think that scum would all jump into the same vote. I think they likely spread themselves more evenly hoping to blend in. In the case of El Topo I'd say the opposite of that happened.
Other than yourself and Dusk no one else had struck me as scummy. I will need review Kalor as right now I'm null there. In general, though I don't think that scum would all jump into the same vote. I think they likely spread themselves more evenly hoping to blend in. In the case of El Topo I'd say the opposite of that happened.
Oh, that reminds me. The start of the next Day Phase is when classes start for me so, if I'm still in the game, I'm not going to be around a whole lot. Monday, Tuesday, and Wednesday are crazy for me but I'll squeeze in time where and when I can. Just expect a significant drop in activity from me. :c
Thank you.
I'm still going to go over everything from this Day and Day 1 but my gut keeps saying you're Town even though my thoughts say otherwise. We'll see where it goes. :x
Thank you.
I'm still going to go over everything from this Day and Day 1 but my gut keeps saying you're Town even though my thoughts say otherwise. We'll see where it goes. :x
Dusk Soldier
Member
I don't think a last minute surge is coming.
OceanicAir
Member
So that's it then, no other info to help town?
My vote on Dusk is less that I think he's scum, but more that I want to see if he truly has the x-box.
He made no mention of bidding on Day 1 that I can recall, and then at the start of Day 2 decided that it was a good time to claim.
I do think that he may be talking with someone through the xbox, but I'm thinking it's more likely that he was the target of its power.
He made no mention of bidding on Day 1 that I can recall, and then at the start of Day 2 decided that it was a good time to claim.
I do think that he may be talking with someone through the xbox, but I'm thinking it's more likely that he was the target of its power.
It was the same yesterday.
Dusk Soldier
Member
I bread crumbed my targets
Lone_Prodigy
Member
Made it in time. Was distracted by a lure.
Dusk is a good vote for scum, but is also useful for town. He's been in the conversation pretty much all day since he claimed to win the Xbox, so there's lot of information there.
Magnum needs to be voted out eventually.
WAMD, well I still think her death and flip would only resolve the Splinter situation, and even then it's dicey. When you go at someone all game, one flip won't tell you much.
Dusk is a good vote for scum, but is also useful for town. He's been in the conversation pretty much all day since he claimed to win the Xbox, so there's lot of information there.
Magnum needs to be voted out eventually.
WAMD, well I still think her death and flip would only resolve the Splinter situation, and even then it's dicey. When you go at someone all game, one flip won't tell you much.
The contestants looked around at Dusk at his outrageous claim. He had given his Xbox away to someone?! Or part of it anyhow. Why would anyone do that? To avoid paying taxes on it? But it wasn't a car after all!
Just like before, as everyone had reached a census, Cabot had jumped up in his seat, springing for security!
Just like before, the security came down in a pack.
"Hmm... this one now? Are you sure...?" spoke the male guard, as the majority of hands in the room went pointing at Dusk Soldier.
"They're wrong.... but whatever, I accept my fate." replied back from Dusk, as he was slowly and calmly escorted out of the building by two of the three security guards.
The remaining guard looked back at Cabot and, with a glare, said to him "Alcohol isn't allowed on the building, son. You're going to have to come with me."
"Eh? It's just water ma-" but before Cabot could finish the security had grabbed him by arms and was now dragging the man out of the building.
"THIS IS A MISTAAAAAKE I TELL YOU!" could be heard as the muscular man dragged the drunkard kicking and screaming out the door.
And with that... another contestant had been removed.
...
.....
Suddenly, out of nowhere, Lone Prodigy returned from the bathroom.
"Oh hey guys, what did I miss?"
Several dirty looks were given back at him...
Dusk Soldier, the Town Mason starter, has been removed from the building.
Dusk Soldier had the following items in his possession.
Up on stage, the contestant lost his pricing game, and slowly returned to the seat.
Drew Carey looked back up at the cameras, now unfazed at the nonsense that was going on below him.
"George, can we get another prize, please?"
From above, George Grey responded with his cheerful demanor.
"You betcha, Drew!
Here we have an outdoor patio set with a grill perfect for barbecue!
Enjoy a summer afternoon out with this four piece outdoor patio set from Outsunny! Featuring a double seated sofa, two single seats, and an outdoor coffee table!
And as afternoon turns to evening, grill you and your family dinner on this two-burner gas grill by Char-Broil!"
Night 2 will end in:
Just like before, as everyone had reached a census, Cabot had jumped up in his seat, springing for security!
Just like before, the security came down in a pack.
"Hmm... this one now? Are you sure...?" spoke the male guard, as the majority of hands in the room went pointing at Dusk Soldier.
"They're wrong.... but whatever, I accept my fate." replied back from Dusk, as he was slowly and calmly escorted out of the building by two of the three security guards.
The remaining guard looked back at Cabot and, with a glare, said to him "Alcohol isn't allowed on the building, son. You're going to have to come with me."
"Eh? It's just water ma-" but before Cabot could finish the security had grabbed him by arms and was now dragging the man out of the building.
"THIS IS A MISTAAAAAKE I TELL YOU!" could be heard as the muscular man dragged the drunkard kicking and screaming out the door.
And with that... another contestant had been removed.
...
.....
Suddenly, out of nowhere, Lone Prodigy returned from the bathroom.
"Oh hey guys, what did I miss?"
Several dirty looks were given back at him...
Dusk Soldier, the Town Mason starter, has been removed from the building.
Dusk Soldier had the following items in his possession.
Up on stage, the contestant lost his pricing game, and slowly returned to the seat.
Drew Carey looked back up at the cameras, now unfazed at the nonsense that was going on below him.
"George, can we get another prize, please?"
From above, George Grey responded with his cheerful demanor.
"You betcha, Drew!
Here we have an outdoor patio set with a grill perfect for barbecue!
Enjoy a summer afternoon out with this four piece outdoor patio set from Outsunny! Featuring a double seated sofa, two single seats, and an outdoor coffee table!
And as afternoon turns to evening, grill you and your family dinner on this two-burner gas grill by Char-Broil!"
Night 2 will end in:
Final vote count for Day 2
wherearemahdragonz (5)
*splinter 565
kalor 744
magnumboy20xx 759
dusk soldier 772
sawneeks 777
el topo (1)
melonrabbit 573
melonrabbitt (0)
wherearemahdragonz 597 (720)
nin1000 (0)
kalor 628 (744)
dusk soldier (7)
starsketch 664
karkador 678
kyanrute 700
stanleypalmtree 739
ynnek7 740
christina mackenzie 741
cornburrito 776
magnumboy20xx (2)
dusk soldier 685 (710)
el topo 716
wherearemahdragonz 720
*splinter (0)
cornburrito 695 (776)
stanleypalmtree (0)
dusk soldier 728 (772)
wherearemahdragonz (5)
*splinter 565
kalor 744
magnumboy20xx 759
dusk soldier 772
sawneeks 777
el topo (1)
melonrabbit 573
melonrabbitt (0)
nin1000 (0)
dusk soldier (7)
starsketch 664
karkador 678
kyanrute 700
stanleypalmtree 739
ynnek7 740
christina mackenzie 741
cornburrito 776
magnumboy20xx (2)
el topo 716
wherearemahdragonz 720
*splinter (0)
stanleypalmtree (0)
Hyperactivity
Banned
Oh dear, that's 4 players now
Luckily mini has been going pretty slow, so it's not that unmanageable, and 1 day phases is making the game go quickly in that regard
Hyperactivity
Banned
MODKILL: Sophia