• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt |OT3| Metz Some Ploughing Good Ladies In the Forest

D

Deleted member 17706

Unconfirmed Member
Finally came back to the game to dig into the Hearts of Stone expansion. Some really good stuff in here so far. Really makes me wonder how CDProjekt manages to pump out such high quality content in seemingly such a short time.

90+ hours played now with no real end in sight, especially once the next expansion comes out. Pretty sure this might edge out Bloodborne for my game of the year.
 
so just disable the question marks and nothing else?

Yeah that's fine. Also, make sure to loot alcohol so you can meditate.

Finally came back to the game to dig into the Hearts of Stone expansion. Some really good stuff in here so far. Really makes me wonder how CDProjekt manages to pump out such high quality content in seemingly such a short time.

90+ hours played now with no real end in sight, especially once the next expansion comes out. Pretty sure this might edge out Bloodborne for my game of the year.

They really are efficient. I can't wait for Blood & Wine. Hearts of Stone has my favorite quests in the game.
 

Karl Hawk

Banned
speaking of hearts of stone, is it recommended I play that before or after finishing the main quest?

Since the expansion is unrelated to the main plot, you can play it during the main questline or after as long you got to the recommended level (30 for NG/60 for NG+).

Though I recommend playing the expansion after the main quest.
 

Clopezi

Member
Hi,

Is going CD Projekt to relase more real world Gwent cards? I have the two decks from HoS expansion and i want more...

Thanks!
 

LogicStep

Member
I'm lvl 27 and currently on Final Preparations. Should I finish the main story or do whatever else I can? My side quests are grey except for one and the expansion says I should do it at 30 making me want to do whatever side stuff I can and do that at 30. Not sure what the best way to do it would be. If I do a lot of side stuff now I doubt I'll play the whole thing in NG+.
 
Are you able to play after the main quest tho? Is hearts of stone selectable from the main menu or does it show up ingame?

You can still continue playing the game after the main quest ends. Hearts of Stone shows up in game, but it is also selectable from the menu if you want to create an autoleveled Geralt for it. (Level 32)

Hi,

Is going CD Projekt to relase more real world Gwent cards? I have the two decks from HoS expansion and i want more...

Thanks!

I don't believe they've said anything officially about that yet, but I imagine Blood & Wine will probably get the same treatment.
 

Lender

Member
I have a question concerning the start of the mission where you enter the Isle of
mists. It says in advance that certain side quests will fail if you venture beyond this point, so I ventured on, saw which side quests failed and reloaded the game to do those. One of those was A Deadly Plot. I've done it, and it's also marked in the completed section of the quests menu, but I just ventured beyond the point of no return, and it says again that A Deadly Plot has failed. I then look in the quest section, and now it's been put in the failed section. Did I miss something? Must I do anything further after I've escorted Thaler to his wagon? I had a feeling the mission wasn't over yet, but since it was marked as completed I had no further objectives for that mission.
 

Karl Hawk

Banned
Hi,

Is going CD Projekt to relase more real world Gwent cards? I have the two decks from HoS expansion and i want more...

Thanks!

Not known yet, though I wouldn't doubt that CDPR will release a physical version of Blood and Wine with two Gwent Decks (Northern Kingdoms and Nilfgaard)

edit: beaten.
 

Lender

Member
I have a question concerning the start of the mission where you enter the Isle of
mists. It says in advance that certain side quests will fail if you venture beyond this point, so I ventured on, saw which side quests failed and reloaded the game to do those. One of those was A Deadly Plot. I've done it, and it's also marked in the completed section of the quests menu, but I just ventured beyond the point of no return, and it says again that A Deadly Plot has failed. I then look in the quest section, and now it's been put in the failed section. Did I miss something? Must I do anything further after I've escorted Thaler to his wagon? I had a feeling the mission wasn't over yet, but since it was marked as completed I had no further objectives for that mission.

Ok, this is weird. I just read the mission description in the failed quests menu, and the two totally contradict.

I
saved thaler in the game,
, but in the description it literally says this:

http://i.imgur.com/8K3Z1ul.jpg

"
he thus abandoned the task, and roche and dijkstra never mentioned the unfortunate matter again

Wtf, that's completely the opposite of what I did? And I feel like I'm missing out on a hugely important (side) quest now? What should I do now?
 

The God

Member
Don't rely on quen, learn the movesets of enemies. Don't use lock on. Dodging is usually better than rolling in most circumstances. Read the bestiary and learn enemy weaknesses.

Potions and bombs are essential. Buy diagrams for them. Oils aren't necessary, but they do make a difference. This isn't a game that you can just burn through. Take your time.

Mix in sidequests(sidequests are amazing in this game) with the main quests so that you're not overleveled for them later. Gwent is really fun and even if you don't get it initially, it's worth sticking with because it has great payoff later.

I also don't recommend trying to beeline from POI to POI at all. Some say the game is better with the hud and minimap turned off.

Also, turn on alternate movement controls.

Leave the question marks enabled for White Orchard and visit them all, then disable them when you are about to leave. Exploration will be more enjoyable that way.
Thanks guys.
 
I've played for an hour and I'm already in love with this game, but I've already spent way too much money this past week on games and other things so I'm thinking of only buying the $10 dlc but how much content does it add?
 

Matush

Member
After a long time I finally strarted the game, any tips for Death March difficulty? Any abuse/cheap tricks? I like challenge and want to play on highest one as possible.
 

The God

Member
After a long time I finally strarted the game, any tips for Death March difficulty? Any abuse/cheap tricks? I like challenge and want to play on highest one as possible.

I'm only about 10 hours in, but like RespectThySole said, learn enemy patterns and weaknesses (oils, signs, etc), and dodge/roll.
 
seemingly completed the quest blood gold in velen, looted the treasure chest and the blood trail doesn't go any further, but the quest refuses to complete for me :/

is this a common bug?


i reloaded and it fixed itself, all good
 

Coreda

Member
Got the game for Christmas and have been in love with it! Question, though. I heard people online say you could give honeycombs to the herbalist in White Orchard for 18 crowns but it's only saying 7 crowns for me. Am I doing something wrong or did they change the value of honeycombs with a patch?

Could have been a patch, not sure why they'd change it. From a quick search looks like someone else experienced the same thing.

Not a huge deal though. Picking up all the loot you find and selling it to merchants, blacksmiths and such becomes the better way of fattening Geralt's coin sack :)
 

ViciousDS

Banned
I kept them for my next playthrough on NG+.

so few questions on that



What exactly carries over on NG+

What level is Hearts of Stone at and when do you unlock the ability to play it. I'm about to start over here completely no NG+ on another platform.....going to fix my ending that I jacked on the first go around lol.


also does NG+ work with the DLC and scale correctly.
 

X-Frame

Member
So oils and potions and stuff can always be refilled for free when I meditate? I'm on the 2nd of the 4 difficulties right now.

This means in each fight I can use all the bombs, potions and oils I have and then meditate afterwards to immediately get it all back? It says it uses Alcohol, but where is it taking that from? Thanks!
 

Karl Hawk

Banned
so few questions on that



What exactly carries over on NG+

What level is Hearts of Stone at and when do you unlock the ability to play it. I'm about to start over here completely no NG+ on another platform.....going to fix my ending that I jacked on the first go around lol.

What carries over in NG+:
Player level (If you're not level 30 or above, your character will be bumped up to 30 on NG+)
Your gear on the inventory (Including the ones on the stash).
Crafting/Alchemy ingredients
Alchemy recipes (Potions, oils, bombs)
Money
Food and drink

What doesn't carry over:
Quest items
Crafting schematics
Gwent cards
Monster trophies
Books and letters
Difficulty level (You'll be able to re-select your difficulty level on NG+)
Points of Interest, Signposts, etc...


Anyways, for Hearts of Stone:

You need to be at level 30+ to play the expansion on non-NG+ playthrough. And yes, the expansion also scales up to NG+, therefore you need to be at level 60+ to play Hearts of Stone on NG+

So oils and potions and stuff can always be refilled for free when I meditate? I'm on the 2nd of the 4 difficulties right now.

This means in each fight I can use all the bombs, potions and oils I have and then meditate afterwards to immediately get it all back? It says it uses Alcohol, but where is it taking that from? Thanks!

As long you have any alcohol in your inventory (Dwarven Spirit, Alcohest, or White Gull), your potions and bombs will be automatically refilled after meditation.

And oils don't count since they have certain amount of charges depending on their quality (20 for standard, 40 for enhanced, 60 for superior). You can refill the oils on your sword anytime you want.
 

ViciousDS

Banned
What carries over in NG+:
Player level (If you're not level 30 or above, your character will be bumped up to 30 on NG+)
Your gear on the inventory (Including the ones on the stash).
Crafting/Alchemy ingredients
Alchemy recipes (Potions, oils, bombs)
Money
Food and drink

What doesn't carry over:
Quest items
Crafting schematics
Gwent cards
Monster trophies
Books and letters
Difficulty level (You'll be able to re-select your difficulty level on NG+)
Points of Interest, Signposts, etc...


Anyways, for Hearts of Stone:

You need to be at level 30+ to play the expansion on non-NG+ playthrough. And yes, the expansion also scales up to NG+, therefore you need to be at level 60+ to play Hearts of Stone on NG+


Excellent


not looking forward to going after all the POI's again.......gggrrrrr. Skellige as much as I love the music, atmosphere and scenery is a dread grabbing all the interest points.


There a guide online that tells me which POI's i can just skip due to them being just loot caches and not containing key items or witcher gear?
 

X-Frame

Member
As long you have any alcohol in your inventory (Dwarven Spirit, Alcohest, or White Gull), your potions and bombs will be automatically refilled after meditation.

And oils don't count since they have certain amount of charges depending on their quality (20 for standard, 40 for enhanced, 60 for superior). You can refill the oils on your sword anytime you want.

Thank you! And just to confirm re: the alcohol on my inventory, it doesn't actually remove 1 of them each time they're refilled via meditation does it? So as long as I have 1 in my inventory I can infinitely refill them each meditation? Why does that seem too good to be true to me? Haha.
 

Karl Hawk

Banned
Thank you! And just to confirm re: the alcohol on my inventory, it doesn't actually remove 1 of them each time they're refilled via meditation does it? So as long as I have 1 in my inventory I can infinitely refill them each meditation? Why does that seem too good to be true to me? Haha.

When you refill your potions/bombs after meditation, it takes 1 alcohol from your inventory.

But since there are plenty of places where you can hoard tons of alcohol (Like Dwarven Spirit for instance), you don't need to worry about whether you should re-fill your potions/bombs

@ViciousDS: I would turn off the Points of interests and not bother exploring them if I were you.
 

Sai

Member
Ok, this is weird. I just read the mission description in the failed quests menu, and the two totally contradict.

I
saved thaler in the game,
, but in the description it literally says this:

http://i.imgur.com/8K3Z1ul.jpg

"
he thus abandoned the task, and roche and dijkstra never mentioned the unfortunate matter again

Wtf, that's completely the opposite of what I did? And I feel like I'm missing out on a hugely important (side) quest now? What should I do now?
It's a glitch, that I thought was fixed in the last big patch. :/
 

The God

Member
So I think I've completed everything in White Orchard (game is crack), but I keep seeing letters posted on the board. They don't turn into quests when I take them so are they just for detail?
 

Nordicus

Member
So I think I've completed everything in White Orchard (game is crack), but I keep seeing letters posted on the board. They don't turn into quests when I take them so are they just for detail?
The smaller sized notes on the board are just world-building.
 

ViciousDS

Banned
When you refill your potions/bombs after meditation, it takes 1 alcohol from your inventory.

But since there are plenty of places where you can hoard tons of alcohol (Like Dwarven Spirit for instance), you don't need to worry about whether you should re-fill your potions/bombs

@ViciousDS: I would turn off the Points of interests and not bother exploring them if I were you.

don't you get really good gearsets from the POI's though? I would feel as though I'm missing out.
 
I was messing around a bit with the Debug Console; for whatever reason, I can't change the appearance of Ciri, either if I'm playing as her or if I spawn her around. I tried spawning Triss and the command does work for her. Am I missing something? D:
 

Karl Hawk

Banned
don't you get really good gearsets from the POI's though? I would feel as though I'm missing out.

Witcher sets are by far more superior than any gear you get in the game. You can find them through treasure hunt quests (Which can be initialized by buying the maps from certain blacksmiths/armorers)

POI's on the other hand varies. They could be hidden treasures, an abandoned settlement, monster nests, or god forbid smuggler caches like in Skellige *shudders*
 
I'm still not sure whether I should turn off undiscovered locations on the map or not. Hmm.


Anyway is there any reason to use the alternate Igni other than it looking cool? It seems like it covers a smaller area and it's obviously slower to cast. Does it do much more damage or something or what
 

Spy

Member
This question is coming from someone who doesn't know much about The Witcher 3. I have a younger brother who is into games like Skyrim, Fallout, etc. though from what I can tell they aren't has "hardcore" as The Witcher.

I've asked him if he wants this game since it's on sale but he said no, it doesn't look that great to him. He's said this same thing about plenty of games that he ended up loving. So the question is, should I gamble and buy it for him while it's on sale hoping he'll like it because he likes Skyrim and Fallout or are they nothing alike?
 
This question is coming from someone who doesn't know much about The Witcher 3. I have a younger brother who is into games like Skyrim, Fallout, etc. though from what I can tell they aren't has "hardcore" as The Witcher.

I've asked him if he wants this game since it's on sale but he said no, it doesn't look that great to him. He's said this same thing about plenty of games that he ended up loving. So the question is, should I gamble and buy it for him while it's on sale hoping he'll like it because he likes Skyrim and Fallout or are they nothing alike?
I don't really know what you mean by hardcore, Skyrim and Fallout definitely have more interactivity with the world and less overall guidance than Witcher 3. They're just different games really, Witcher 3 still has action combat, it's not like you're throwing him in to Baldur's Gate.

If he liked open world games like RDR or maybe more dialog driven rpgs then I'd say definitely gamble on it though.
 
Anyway is there any reason to use the alternate Igni other than it looking cool? It seems like it covers a smaller area and it's obviously slower to cast. Does it do much more damage or something or what

Both are good. In general, the normal igni is useful if you want to cast a sign and then remain mobile to follow up with sword attacks on enemies that didn't get set on fire, while firestream is great to lockdown enemies, or to bait enemies to approach you, walking into the stream and setting them on fire. Stamina cost and use also plays a role. Normal igni will drain your stamina, while you control how long you use the stream.

Couple little tips if somebody doesn't know is to learn to love the tawny owl potion, and if something is burning, let it burn. Hitting them with another spell or attack will remove the burn effect, and prevent the fire damage ticks from continuing.
 

iNvid02

Member
This question is coming from someone who doesn't know much about The Witcher 3. I have a younger brother who is into games like Skyrim, Fallout, etc. though from what I can tell they aren't has "hardcore" as The Witcher.

I've asked him if he wants this game since it's on sale but he said no, it doesn't look that great to him. He's said this same thing about plenty of games that he ended up loving. So the question is, should I gamble and buy it for him while it's on sale hoping he'll like it because he likes Skyrim and Fallout or are they nothing alike?

fwiw i have a brother who enjoyed skyrim and loved the witcher 3 as well, they're not that different really.

He's said this same thing about plenty of games that he ended up loving.

haha yes this sounds familiar
 
I'm still not sure whether I should turn off undiscovered locations on the map or not. Hmm.


Anyway is there any reason to use the alternate Igni other than it looking cool? It seems like it covers a smaller area and it's obviously slower to cast. Does it do much more damage or something or what

I prefer Alt Igni myself and originally it was superior, but it did receive a nerf a couple patches ago so they're basically on equal footing now. It just depends on your playstyle, RandomSeed covered that pretty well.

This question is coming from someone who doesn't know much about The Witcher 3. I have a younger brother who is into games like Skyrim, Fallout, etc. though from what I can tell they aren't has "hardcore" as The Witcher.

I've asked him if he wants this game since it's on sale but he said no, it doesn't look that great to him. He's said this same thing about plenty of games that he ended up loving. So the question is, should I gamble and buy it for him while it's on sale hoping he'll like it because he likes Skyrim and Fallout or are they nothing alike?

They're definitely not the same, but he'll probably like it.
 
This question is coming from someone who doesn't know much about The Witcher 3. I have a younger brother who is into games like Skyrim, Fallout, etc. though from what I can tell they aren't has "hardcore" as The Witcher.

I've asked him if he wants this game since it's on sale but he said no, it doesn't look that great to him. He's said this same thing about plenty of games that he ended up loving. So the question is, should I gamble and buy it for him while it's on sale hoping he'll like it because he likes Skyrim and Fallout or are they nothing alike?

The Witcher 3 isn't really hardcore in its mechanics. Contrary to Skyrim for example it does require attention in regards to dialogue and plot developments. If he's into that, go ahead and buy it for them. Skyrim and The Witcher 3 are both RPG's but are completely different games at the core.
 

X-Frame

Member
I have a question about quests so far. I'm only about 6 hours in I guess? I just arrived in
Velen
, and so far it seems way bigger than the first area.

Anyway, the way I usually like to play RPG's when I get to a new area is try and explore the land as much as I can and do as many side quests as I can before continuing with the main story, so that I don't miss anything if quests or places become unavailable in the future. (This is why I was stuck in the damn Hinterlands forever in DA:I)

Now, I am noticing that I'm out leveled almost everywhere. I'm only level 5 and seeing 10-13 enemies a lot, and getting crushed.

Basically, in this game should I be progressing with the main story first until it's about time to go to the next area, then at that point try and do all the side quests? Or vice versa? Or a mix of the two ideally?
 

EatChildren

Currently polling second in Australia's federal election (first in the Gold Coast), this feral may one day be your Bogan King.
I have a question about quests so far. I'm only about 6 hours in I guess? I just arrived in
Velen
, and so far it seems way bigger than the first area.

Anyway, the way I usually like to play RPG's when I get to a new area is try and explore the land as much as I can and do as many side quests as I can before continuing with the main story, so that I don't miss anything if quests or places become unavailable in the future. (This is why I was stuck in the damn Hinterlands forever in DA:I)

Now, I am noticing that I'm out leveled almost everywhere. I'm only level 5 and seeing 10-13 enemies a lot, and getting crushed.

Basically, in this game should I be progressing with the main story first until it's about time to go to the next area, then at that point try and do all the side quests? Or vice versa? Or a mix of the two ideally?

Velen is technically the main map of the game. White Orchard, where you started, is the "small" prologue area. So yeah, Velen is fucking gigantic.

But what you're describing is accurate, yes; if you're finding side quests (or quests in general) too high level, too difficult, then progressing the main quest will help bring you up to speed. Remember that quests are marked with a recommended level too, giving you an idea of what is/isn't doable at your skill level (it isn't always accurate, but it's a decent guide).

Wild Hunt is indeed structured in a way that deters "clearing out" areas. Reason being that it's more true open world than something like Inquisition. I too fell into the early pitfalls of clearing out the Hinterlands before moving on, because I didn't want to miss anything (I did ween myself off this though). Wild Hunt is instead a whole bunch of quests and stuff scattered across the map, with no uniformity on difficulty and challenge. So it's not like the bottom half of Velen is easy, and the top half is hard. You'll find easy stuff all over the map, and hard stuff right where you started.

Due to the nature of design it's pretty much inevitable that you will miss something, come back later and find it only to realise you're significantly over levelled and it's a breeze. But in the grand scheme of things there's not a whole lot that gets entirely cut off. A handful of quests become inaccessible after a certain point in the story, but if you just arrived in Velen you're a long way from that.

AFAIK arriving in Velen you basically have three leads to try and locate Ciri. These are your three main objectives, and each will lead you all across the map, and can be completed in any order.
 

Lender

Member
I'm 82 hours in, and just about to
search for the sunstone

I really have the feeling that the game is nearing the end, and I don't want it to stop. :(
 

Repo Man

Member
Gah! Just finished the main story finally and got the "bad ending" which soured my experience slightly seeing I'm usually all for the suprhappyunicornsandbunnies-endings. Tried to revert to an earlier save too to see if some of my choices changed things but it seems the ending had been decided by my decisions much earlier on. Cool design though and this is definately my GOTY regardless and I look forward to starting the expansion and maybe finish off exploring and completing some of the remaining Contracts.

To all you people who got the game for christmas, enjoy and stick with it. This is one game everyone should experience.
 

Auctopus

Member
I just started this the other night. Any general tips - what to put points in early, etc?

Not to tell you how to play but complete the "Looking For Ciri..." quest line in both Velen and Novigrad before leaving for Skellige. The change in environment will be incredible.
 
Top Bottom