• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

The Xbox that never was: Our first detailed look at the 'Keystone' cloud streaming console design

Topher

Identifies as young
Ever wondered what Xbox Keystone was going to look like? A new patent gives us an idea!


Xbox Keystone patent

The front of Xbox Keystone. (Image credit: ppubs.uspto.gov)

What you need to know​

  • A newly discovered Microsoft patent has given us a closer look at the canceled Xbox Keystone streaming console.
  • The device was designed to sit under a TV and stream games via Xbox Game Pass.
  • Keystone was canceled after Microsoft was unable to price it reasonably.

Back in 2021, Microsoft announced that it was working on a dedicated streaming device for Xbox Game Pass. That device was later revealed to be codenamed Keystone, which took the form of a streaming box that would sit under your TV, cost a fraction of the price of a normal Xbox, and enable the ability to play Xbox games via the cloud.
Unfortunately, it appears Microsoft has since scrapped plans to ship Xbox Keystone due to an inability to bring the price down to a level where it made sense for customers. Xbox CEO Phil Spencer is on record saying the device should have costed around $99 or $129, but the company was unable to achieve this.
This means we never really got a chance to see what Xbox Keystone looked like. The closest we ever got was in a photo posted by Phil Spencer, which just so happened to include a front-on view of the Xbox Keystone device on a shelf. That’s as much as we’ve ever seen of the console, that is until now.

Xbox Keystone patent


Thanks to a patent discovered by Windows Central, we can finally take a closer look at the box Microsoft had conjured up internally. First up, the patent reveals that the console took the form of an even square with a circle shape on top, similar to the black circular vent on an Xbox Series S. The front of the box had the Xbox power button, and a USB-A port.
Around the back, there were three additional ports; HDMI, ethernet, and power. On the right side of the console there was appears to be an Xbox controller pairing button, and the underside featured a circular “Hello from Seattle” plate that the console sat on, similar to the Xbox Series X.

Xbox Keystone patent



This patent was filed in June 2022, which was around the time when the first details of Xbox Keystone were being revealed. Sadly, Xbox Keystone in this specific form is unlikely to ever to see the light of day, but at least we now know what it would have looked like.

We still don’t know much about what powered things under the hood, including what kind of OS or firmware it ran. Was it a fully fledged Xbox OS with local game support stripped out? Or was it running something lighter with an Xbox Game Pass app on top? We don’t currently know, and likely never will.

Keystone is gone, but Microsoft isn't backing down from cloud​


Microsoft has given up on its Xbox keystone console, at least for now, but that doesn't mean they've given up on cloud.
The biggest barriers to cloud right now revolve around the business model. Running cloud gaming servers 24/7 is incredibly expensive, and Xbox Game Pass Ultimate at $15 per month doesn't cover the costs by itself. At least in theory, in-game purchases and outright game purchases would help improve the business model to some degree, but gatekeeper companies like Apple and Google work hard to prevent that business model from evolving. Microsoft is known to be working on a mobile gaming store for Android and iOS of its own, but I have absolutely no idea how they're going to get people to download it. It won't appear on Android and iOS by default, much like cloud gaming doesn't, and the audiences across mobile expect ease of access as their north star.
A console like Keystone would help cut through this, but like my colleague Zac Bowden noted above, Microsoft was unable to get the price down. People would expect a device that can only play streaming games to cost around $99, and that was the target for Keystone, but the demand for components (boosted by the AI gold rush) has kept prices of computing components irregularly high.

In lieu of a dedicated device, Microsoft told me in LA for the Xbox Games Showcase 2024 that they're seeing huge growth with TV apps, such as those included by default on the Samsung TV Gaming Hub. I've heard Microsoft has been experimenting with delivering PC cloud games too via Xbox Cloud Gaming, which would boost the catalog. Microsoft is also known to be working on allowing players to bring their existing game libraries into cloud and buy cloud games to own, pending discussions with third-party publishers and license holders.
Cloud might be additive today, but it's important that Microsoft keeps a foot in the door in this space. One day, cloud gaming could be indistinguishable from local playback, and platforms like NVIDIA GeForce Now is proving that the technology is completely and utterly viable. Xbox Cloud Gaming has some catching up to do on the tech side, but there's no reason to think they won't be able to in the future.



I'd imagine there will be some variation of that in the future. When is Xbox Cloud Gaming going to come out of "beta"?
 

analog_future

Resident Crybaby
It's crazy how poorly xCloud performs and looks after all these years. Microsoft was the first big purveyor of this tech and they've completely fumbled it.


GeForce Now is literally a generation ahead of it and feels near-native comparatively.
 

clarky

Gold Member
It's crazy how poorly xCloud performs and looks after all these years. Microsoft was the first big purveyor of this tech and they've completely fumbled it.


GeForce Now is literally a generation ahead of it and feels near-native comparatively.

Yeah Nvidias solution is actually decent. They need to get into bed with them if they wanna make it work.
 

deriks

4-Time GIF/Meme God
Uh... Smart TVs have app stores and they can run GamePass on it

Can't see a good reason to have a hardware exclusive to a cloud service
 

Punished Miku

Human Rights Subscription Service
What I want to do is go to my brother's house, get on my phone on the Xbox app and just connect that to the TV. Then his TV loads up the app and I have my whole library and GP portable. Wouldn't be something I use a lot, but that would be pretty dang convenient. I was playing Persona 3 on cloud a few days ago and could barely tell any difference. Not something I'd want to use as my primary means of gaming, but it is a great additional benefit (especially if it doesn't really cost anything extra).
 
I played a decent amount of Xbox cloud streaming cause I didn't wanna install windows on my Steam Deck, the issue is that their service just isn't very good.
It's still beta. I get random disconnects/crashes. When the screen gets pixelated and you pause for a few seconds for the screen to clear up, it about never actually recovers.
I had to close the game and open it again to get a clear image again.
 

analog_future

Resident Crybaby
Yeah Nvidias solution is actually decent. They need to get into bed with them if they wanna make it work.

MS has too much money tied up into Azure to do this.

Azure's not even the bottleneck anyway. Nvidia has the leg-up because they've built their hardware from the ground-up to be impossibly low-latency, to the extent that several Geforce NOW experiences have actually been measured to have lower input lag than Xbox Series X|S native experiences.


At this point it seems that it's Microsoft's console hardware/software/rendering pipeline that's really holding them back rather than their infrastructure.
 
Last edited:

Fess

Member
Looks like a Dreamcast 👍

Didn’t know it was scrapped. But few want this, Xbox Cloud has always been terrible compared to other cloud services, at least at my location.

Stadia was the best overall service for me, no jank and a good UI and low latency. The hardware was too weak though, I jumped out when The Crew 2 was 30fps when you could run it at 60fps on Geforce Now. Geforce Now is amazing technically but there is way too much jank with 2fa login crap and queues,
 

Dr. Wilkinson

Gold Member
They were smart to shelve this. It would not have done well. And would need to have been heavily discounted to sell through.
 

RagnarokIV

Battlebus imprisoning me \m/ >.< \m/
That would have been amazing 😍, so small. I would of copped loads out of my own money then plant them at friends and familys homes without them knowing, just so I could know when I go to sleep at night I have done my part to get the Xbox brand in more homes 💪💪💪.
Alright mate, loving the new photo. Looks like a proper Xbox estate. We catch any of those PlayStation poofs walking around there we’ll fucken fill them in, dull twats lol. We're like the Essex Boys, but we're Series S|X Boys. We drive round in the range rover vogue and fuck up them mouthy cunts.
 
Last edited:

hououinkyouma00

Gold Member
I know it depends on location but XCloud has been by far the worst performing streaming option for me. GeForce Now has been great, and PlayStation streaming is also pretty good. Not quite up to GFN levels but definitely playable overall.

I just don't see how this would have been a good deal even at $99.
 

DAHGAMING

Member
Alright mate, loving the new photo. Looks like a proper Xbox estate. We catch any of those PlayStation poofs walking around there we’ll fucken fill them in, dull twats lol. We're like the Essex Boys, but we're Series S|X Boys. We drive round in the range rover vogue and fuck up them mouthy cunts.

Yea mate proper naughty round here, Im up in Glasgow now as upset to many down there. Nice you know of them Essex boys, Pat Tate, Tony Tucker and Craig Rolfe, realy sad wjat happened to them especialy as they was a credit to society, they would of been Xbox if they hadnt got killed. 30 yrs next December, think il pop down to Rettondon and lay some flowers.
Thanks mate, yea I like that pic of the lads and 1 of the bullies from the estate, hes name is Big Phil 💪💪💪.
 

RagnarokIV

Battlebus imprisoning me \m/ >.< \m/
Yea mate proper naughty round here, Im up in Glasgow now as upset to many down there. Nice you know of them Essex boys, Pat Tate, Tony Tucker and Craig Rolfe, realy sad wjat happened to them especialy as they was a credit to society, they would of been Xbox if they hadnt got killed. 30 yrs next December, think il pop down to Rettondon and lay some flowers.
Thanks mate, yea I like that pic of the lads and 1 of the bullies from the estate, hes name is Big Phil 💪💪💪.
Three young lads taken too soon, heartbreaking mate. They deffo be Xbox boys, I can imagine Pat in a MW2 lobby on the Xbox 360... Someone say they shagged his mum, he'd be at their door with a hammer to teach them some manners. Proper respectful lads, these modern gamers now got no manners.

Aye my mate wanted a bully so we went up to some dodgy place in Bradford to pick one up for cheap, think he's retarded though. Vet said his chromosomes are fucked up or some shit, must be inbred so we named him Jimmy Ryan
 

Drew1440

Member
Not a fan of cloud streaming, but if this box was capable of streaming from a local Series console on the same network, this could have been very interesting. Like the Steam Link or Sony's remote play.
 

Shut0wen

Banned
Uh... Smart TVs have app stores and they can run GamePass on it

Can't see a good reason to have a hardware exclusive to a cloud service
Yeah i was thinking this to, unless there was something in it which eliminated input lag then sure if not fuck it cancel it
 
Top Bottom