Negotiator101
Member
Both reviewed well, so which one?
-
Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!
Two remakes but which one?
- Thread starter Negotiator101
- Start date
Josemayuste
Member
In my restless dreams I see that town.
CrimsonTide
Banned
Both are done "the right way" imo
So kinda comes down to which game you liked more to start with
So kinda comes down to which game you liked more to start with
LectureMaster
Or is it just one of Adam's balls in my throat?
Snake eaters I say.
RedC
Member
CrimsonTide
Banned
I'll have to give that a watch after work. 40 mins
adamsapple
Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
That's a tough one.
If you've never played it before, MGS3.
If you've played them both before, SH2.
If you've never played it before, MGS3.
If you've played them both before, SH2.
Poppinfresh
Member
Both
Lokaum D+
Member
Metal Gear Solid: Zero ASSaultSnake eaters I say.
Negotiator101
Member
It's so close in the poll I just might
Gamer_By_Proxy
About to beat off
I thought Delta got a bad reception at first. Am I misremembering?
CrimsonTide
Banned
Did it? Seems good to me. Played 4 hours or so thus far.
CrimsonTide
Banned
What's the time frame on SH2?
Icymanipulator
Member
Snake Eater because Metal Gear is a better franchise than Silent Hill.
AmuroChan
Member
12-15 hours.
adamsapple
Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
CrimsonTide
Banned
Yeah that's a good point lolNot if you're watching all the cut-scenes and listening to the codec calls
Kojima gonna make sure it's a 30 hour sink
AmuroChan
Member
SH2 was free on PS+ back in October. So that one lol.
Arsic
Loves his juicy stink trail scent
SH2 on PC is great but it's not good on console. It's a bad reflection and aliasing experience for performance and the 30fps mode is not the smooth kind.
MGS3 at launch when I played was just great on pro with only real issues being at the end with the shagohod.
The better game IMO is silent hill 2 if you've never experienced like I had. MGS3 a sliver less but a better game you can play over and over again.
TLDR both,
MGS3 at launch when I played was just great on pro with only real issues being at the end with the shagohod.
The better game IMO is silent hill 2 if you've never experienced like I had. MGS3 a sliver less but a better game you can play over and over again.
TLDR both,
Hawk The Slayer
Member
Don't like either but MGS3 Remake is better.
Now Silent Hill 1 and 3 Remakes would be a different story as those two were the best Silent Hill games.
Now Silent Hill 1 and 3 Remakes would be a different story as those two were the best Silent Hill games.
I would say Snake Eater but I don't believe that is a remake as much as sh2 is
in my opinion it's not a remake it's a spruce remastered what Dead Rising should have been
kpopSuperstar
Member
What are they trying to do with their hands?Snake eaters I say.
EverydayBeast
ChatShitGPT Alpha 0.001
Silent hill vs mgs2, mgs2 is a historic game, silent hill honors the horror genre.
mgs2??????????????????????????????
adamsapple
Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
Chat GPT glitch.
semiconscious
Member
in my restless dreams i see that ocelot spinning revolver sequence...
adamsapple
Or is it just one of Phil's balls in my throat?
In my restless dreams, I kept you waiting, huh?
AI has trouble reading text. I think it didn't recognise the symbol Delta and took it for a two. He's talking about everydaybeast, it's an inside joke about the user being AI.are you talking about me orEverydayBeast
saintjules
Gold Member
What do you want to get out of this thread is the real question here. Otherwise it's gonna go into a dead end.
Rocinante618
Member
If you prioritize gameplay = SH2 Remake
If you like a whack, "Kojima" ah meta story = MGS Delta
Personally I recommend both, especially SH2 Remake as it's 50% right now. MGS Delta is seriously a breath of fresh air in the current slop era, the story, characters, plot and the whole silliness, the bait, the memes are so good, truly art. Gameplay is quite limited and sometimes tiresome, it's a "once done and uninstall" type game (obvious: twists and surprises work once.)
SH2R shines in gameplay and length, you can replay the game multiple times, it's probably the best survival horror after the post 2017-RE games. RE4R still king, always will be the king.
If you like a whack, "Kojima" ah meta story = MGS Delta
Personally I recommend both, especially SH2 Remake as it's 50% right now. MGS Delta is seriously a breath of fresh air in the current slop era, the story, characters, plot and the whole silliness, the bait, the memes are so good, truly art. Gameplay is quite limited and sometimes tiresome, it's a "once done and uninstall" type game (obvious: twists and surprises work once.)
SH2R shines in gameplay and length, you can replay the game multiple times, it's probably the best survival horror after the post 2017-RE games. RE4R still king, always will be the king.
Last edited:
NeverYouMind
Member
Embrace Oblivion (unless you play on console in which case go sight seeing in the reimagined ghost town).
Negotiator101
Member
I got Silent Hill in the end, seems like the general consensus is it's the better game.
Witchilich
Member
Silent Hill 2 Remake was not good. I don't know what people here are smoking.
Breakfast at Noon
Member
Neither, Konami will never get a penny from me again.
Paasei
Member
No they're not, they are great remakes!
GymWolf
Member
Both good but i enjoyed sh2 remake much more, the improved voice acting and digital acting help selling the story much more, mgs3 original graphic and voice acting already sell the silliness/epicness pretty well.
Sh2 also improved the gameplay and level design a bit, mgs3 improved something but it still feel like and old game with old ass level design and just a coat of paint for the most part.
Sh2 also improved the gameplay and level design a bit, mgs3 improved something but it still feel like and old game with old ass level design and just a coat of paint for the most part.
Similar threads
- Poll
- Poll