I think I can still find a way to support Tom Holland through this. For starters, he is NOT a policy maker, so his opinion on this has no real direct effect. Secondly, I think he is pretty clear this is a bad outcome, but his "noble origin" comment is about how you -could- say this is a "barbaric act" but that kinda paints the entire culture with a negative brush, something he as an academic and a historian is wary of doing. Something that I, of course, have little to no concerns about doing as virtually all of my adult life has revolved around 'managing' US relations with islamic extremists in some form or fashion.
But Tom has teenaged daughters, IIRC, and I'm sure he keeps them far from these people and suffers the same "white guilt" about it that lots of liberals do.
I'm still confused as to how this stuff occurs. Are these thugs straight up snatching girls off the street or are they just the "party house" in a poor block with lots of unattended kids coming from broken homes where there are no fathers, or they are in prison, etc. to deal with this stuff. Surely there are enough ex-mil folks sitting around that would conduct some nocturnal "behavior correction" if the society itself was at least somewhat functional.