Andodalf
Banned
I agree. You being town means Darryl needs to go. and probably me too. even if we aren't mafia we're shit town. But the same can be said for you and cabot if I turn up town.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Werewolf! |OT| Making Animal Friends Is Awesome?
- Thread starter Palmer_v1
- Start date
I agree. You being town means Darryl needs to go. and probably me too. even if we aren't mafia we're shit town. But the same can be said for you and cabot if I turn up town.
Andodalf
Banned
I want this high on a page. Not every page, but it was a little low last one.
Day 1 votes
septimus prime (0)
cabot 96 (158)
darryl (0)
robotninjahornets 99 (247)
quantumbro 153 (230)
fluxwavez 197 (365)
xamtheking 268 (289)
cabot (0)
terrabyte20xx 123 (260)
cornburrito (3)
makai 129
lollipop dave 175
andodalf 360
rolanderson (1)
quantumbro 150 (153)
greatlord tiger 325
batsnacks (2)
cabot 158 (204)
quantumbro 230 (249)
el topo 257
quantumbro 427
fluxwavez (1)
darryl 162
robotninjahornets (0)
cabot 204 (331)
quantumbro (0)
robotninjahornets 247 (330)
andodalf (2)
quantumbro 249 (427)
fluxwavez 365
septimus prime 429
darrly (0)
andodalf 259 (318)
timeaisis (2)
terrabyte20xx 260
cabot 331
septimus prime (0)
darryl (0)
cabot (0)
cornburrito (3)
makai 129
lollipop dave 175
andodalf 360
rolanderson (1)
greatlord tiger 325
batsnacks (2)
el topo 257
quantumbro 427
fluxwavez (1)
darryl 162
robotninjahornets (0)
quantumbro (0)
andodalf (2)
fluxwavez 365
septimus prime 429
darrly (0)
timeaisis (2)
terrabyte20xx 260
cabot 331
Yeah, I'd definitely kill a veteran and probably one who has succeeded at deception. Maybe El Topo or NinjaHornets.
Andodalf
Banned
Xamtheking
Member
It's just an instinct, I could be wrong about Ultron (and you)
Additionally, just because I like someone doesn't mean I am not suspicious of them
This early in the game, the only people I trust are the ones 6 feet under
Terrabyte20xx
Junior Wrestlemania XXX Champion
I need everyone's reads on me, Timeaisis, and Ultron87 right now.
Just so we're clear, I'm not saying it for your benefit. I'm just saying it as a possibility.
It's there now.
sec, I'll see if I can figure out that out. Does anyone see it differently on that site?
Edit: Weird. It's only updating through post 429 for me. Browser is caching the wrong page.
I disagree with a lot of what you're saying except for the fact that when I'm eliminated, Darryl must absolutely be eliminated immediately.
Andodalf voted for me, too:
It's because of Darryl. I don't know how it happened but, from the very start, they have had some kind of weird influence with those in this game who are familiar with them + Andodolf. The only people questioning him are those who haven't played with them before.
My survival doesn't matter anymore; but I think they have to go. Once I die, it won't matter if they turn out to be Town or a Werewolf. People need to realize they're an enemy, and they will hinder us whatever they are.
No, I'm simply acknowledging that you responded and posted the list.
Xamtheking
Member
I don't know about you
Time seems ok, but I'm not sure
I still think ultron is cool
Oh, I see. Fair enough.
It does hold true for flux. I haven't had anything bad to say about ando or flux and something unexpected would have to happen to make me vote either of them.
That said I also support Darryl and I think he should continue to follow his dreams. I also want to say that if Darryl is wrong about flux, that doesn't mean he's a wolf. Villagers are wrong more often than not. If flux is town, I think people sheeping Darryl are more frequently wolves than Darryl is.
As a villager the best thing you can do is find someone you think is a wolf and convince other villagers that you are right. I think that's what Darryl appears to be doing.
We're not setting up a chain vote just so you get revenge. It doesn't help us if you focus on one person because of a petty grudge.
Obviously, we'll lynch him if you flip Cop or something.
No, no, no... it doesn't matter. The one leading the pack is the destructive influence, and will continue to destroy after the initial target is gone. This is what I'm saying: DO NOT question whether Darryl is a werewolf or not once I'm gone. What they are doesn't matter: eliminate them all the same. I guarantee it.
Heh...
Anyways, it's part grudge, but it's also because of their influence. You at least have to acknowledge that, based on the amount of evidence of it in this thread. And because of the fact that I know their "almighty reasoning and deductive prowess" can be absolutely wrong, they're not beneficial to town.
Andodalf
Banned
you happening to want a townie gone, just because he wants you gone seems decidedly scummy.
"anybody who is against me is clearly anti town!"
that said, I agree that if he's wrong, Darryl needs to go. Because I agree with you on so much :/
Don't resign yourself to defeat so easily. You have my support you're obviously doing some things right. If there are problems with Darryl they need to be addressed NOW and not after you flip. Your flip has very little to do with Darryl's alignment imo.
Xamtheking
Member
Tonight is going to be interesting
You're contradicting yourself, because the latter statement is what I'm saying, which would also mean you believe in the first.
I don't care that it's a townie who is targeting me. I'm aware that happens in this game. But it's because of their influencethe power that entailsand because they can be so adamant while being so utterly wrong. This isn't something that helps town, and it's not something that will. In fact, it's already hindering us.
Andodalf
Banned
How? I'd love if Darryl could be understood prior to a flux flip, but how?
You're stating the obvious. If I turn out to be a werewolf once lynched then, yes, Darryl is indeed the leader of the town who should have his word be law just as it has been up until this point.
He's obnoxious, but I think batsnacks is right in that he's being a fairly good townie.
If you don't understand Darryl's reasons for voting flux then don't sheep him and flux won't get lynched. Flux only gets lynched if Darryl is compelling enough to convince at least some villagers that he's right.
-I don't agree with Darryl that flux is a werewolf so I am not sheeping Darryl-
See it's easy!
Because I know they target people haphazardly. They're close-minded and have their own agenda when it comes to literally every statement in this thread, with their decision made about every single thing right when the game started with no room for deviation or changing one's mind.
I'm not saying to lynch Darryl. I'm saying to lynch Darryl after I'm lynched.
Andodalf
Banned
yep, so we have to put him to the test, and the only way I see to do this is lynching you.
Also Darryl, where are you?
Andodalf
Banned
Then who do we lynch?
CornBurrito
Member
Those other 2 aren't even on my radar tbh. I don't recgonize Timeaisis. Nor Ultron. I'm going to have to read.
As for you, you seem townie to me. Just based on my previous experience with you.
Terrabyte20xx
Junior Wrestlemania XXX Champion
No one is taking his word as law.
In fact, I doubt many people are even putting much stock into him thinking you're a wolf.
I suggest that you stop defending yourself against his claims for a brief moment and use that effort instead to find others who COULD be scum. Otherwise we could be wasting this entire day.
Fine, I'll let this pass for now, but Day 1 has been the "FluxWaveZ vs. Darryl" show even when neither of us have been commenting about it so it's difficult to not respond to it.
Let me get this straight. You want to lynch one of two most active posters in this thread on day one? With no information other than the back and fourth conversation? On the basis of testing Darryl?
That doesn't make any sense for the town....
I don't know yet, which is bad on my part but I'm apprehensive to commit after last game when all my scum reads were power roles and I got lynched d1. Failing the N0 kill was probably demoralizing for the wolves so I'm looking in the non-posting-est people.
We lynch people because we think they're Werewolves, not because they were wrong about you. We agree Darryl is mean and we'll be happy to lynch him if you convince us he is a Werewolf. Drop your revenge plea or I'm voting for you.
Terrabyte20xx
Junior Wrestlemania XXX Champion
Annodof, lollipop Dave, why do you still have your votes on Corn?
This will be my final reply on the matter for the moment because Terrabyte20xx; we're losing time on this when we could be focusing on other things.
But I will say this: vote for me all you want. Our aim is to vote for werewolves, but what happens when we vote against townies? What happens when we lynch our own power roles? We're put at a disadvantage. Those with sway and those who lead us to lynch those people under the guise that they know what they're doing with full confidence... do you really think that is a boon for the town?
Terrabyte20xx
Junior Wrestlemania XXX Champion
Glad I wasn't the only one...
It's showing andodalf's vote on Flux for me, with Corn crossed out.
Andodalf
Banned
Ugh, that's my greatest fear. so many are quiet that we might all just be town arguing against town.
also I moved my vote
CornBurrito
Member
In some ways, yes it is. Let us assume Darryl is town. For better or worse, Darryl has put focus on someone and forced them to defend themselves. If he is wrong, then he struck wrong. The good thing though is that in either case he gets people talking, puts people on the defensive, and isn't afraid to call out anyone. That is a boon to town. And quite frankly, none of us are omniscient. We're all going to falsely accuse someone at some point, if we make accusations. Darryl is acting confident, but he's playing as blind as the rest of us. Acting confident is just a playstyle.
CornBurrito
Member
Terrabyte20xx
Junior Wrestlemania XXX Champion
CornBurrito
Member
I generally work under the assumption that at least one member of the mafia team will attempt to be active, and one of the more active posters. Both GAF mafia games I played had mafia members as some of the highest post count posters. Influencing the town discussion is the best way for mafia to win the game after all.
It might even be a safe bet to look at the top 5 or so posters thus far. I'd put money on one of them being mafia.
But yeah, it could be town arguing with town. Which is why going after the least contributing posters is a good early game strategy for Town. Mafia will likely be targeting suspected PR, and/or high post count Town posters who contribute helpfully to the discussion. High post count posters who prove immune to the mafia's attempt to control the flow of discussion are most at risk I feel.
CornBurrito
Member
Ok so batsnacks is at 29, but I made my arbitrary cutoff at 30.
Andodalf : 61
FluxWaveZ: 59
cabot: 55
CornBurrito: 48
Darryl: 34
As I said, I'd bet money that a mafia member exists among this group. I'm confident I'm innocent,, and I suspect Darryl is town. So my top suspects would happen to be cabot, Flux, Andodolf.
Andodalf : 61
FluxWaveZ: 59
cabot: 55
CornBurrito: 48
Darryl: 34
As I said, I'd bet money that a mafia member exists among this group. I'm confident I'm innocent,, and I suspect Darryl is town. So my top suspects would happen to be cabot, Flux, Andodolf.
That's an odd way to say your town.