To be fair, I think that could be said about half the people in the discussion right now.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Werewolf! |OT| Making Animal Friends Is Awesome?
- Thread starter Palmer_v1
- Start date
To be fair, I think that could be said about half the people in the discussion right now.
I'm noticing a pattern after doing some filtering:
First pattern is the "if you notice me than you must be mafia" pattern. Sometimes this is called OMGUS defence:
Again, Styles responds to being called out by concluding that people who call him out can only be feisty scums.
-
Second pattern is the "I'm new, please don't notice that I'm not contributing" pattern:
-
Also Styles knows that Darryl was not targeted by wolves last night, he says so here:
Also Styles does not want to commit to voting until the last second, presumably so he can't be held accountable for his vote:
First pattern is the "if you notice me than you must be mafia" pattern. Sometimes this is called OMGUS defence:
Flux notices Styles. Styles says flux is too aggressive and could be in cahoots with wolves.
cabot notices Styles. Styles concludes cabot and flux must be mafia together, because they are bringing attention to him.
Again, Styles responds to being called out by concluding that people who call him out can only be feisty scums.
-
Second pattern is the "I'm new, please don't notice that I'm not contributing" pattern:
Some newcomers "might just be too shy to contribute." The top two posting-est players this game are both new.
Styles again asks not to be noticed because he is new.
-
Also Styles knows that Darryl was not targeted by wolves last night, he says so here:
Styles should not have this information if he is a villager.
Also Styles does not want to commit to voting until the last second, presumably so he can't be held accountable for his vote:
As for my own voting, I'll probably wait for the last moment or go no lynch on this day. I'm keeping an eye on you scums though. ( ≖_≖
Andodalf
Banned
Haha, Abdodlaf! that's pretty funny. Ill openly admit, I do argue in weird ways, I've openly admited that and discussed it earlier, I'll assert that it's just the way argue.
And yeah, Hearing some of the arguments against me, I've gotta say that my aligning myself with Darryl is probably not the best thing for town after all. I'm just gunna say that I'm new as my only defense for that. I feel like I've put to much stock into Darryl, and now that more people are posting my opinion of the game, and the town, as a whole is changing. Sorry :I
I don't think that's what they're saying, or it would be a giant red flag. I think Style is saying that Darryl is infamous and, because of his perception that people wanted to take Darryl out because of this combined with the assumption that they're town, it would be weird that the werewolves didn't target Darryl on N0.
But sure, the pattern for the rest is what I had pointed out and what continues to not seem right, combined with contradicting himself in order to try to implicate me as a werewolf.
VOTE: Style
Yeah, that Style does paint him pretty suspiciously. Constant reminder that the other guys are the scum and he's new. Aka please don't look at me!
I will say that these kind of observations are generally pretty loose. Sure, it is possible he is hiding while formulating a defense with his Wolf co-conspirators, but it is also possible he just had a Sunday lunch to get to, or is running some errands or any of the thousands of other ways real life can make checking the Mafia thread not the highest priority. An hour's absence shouldn't ever be taken as evidence for anything.
I will say that these kind of observations are generally pretty loose. Sure, it is possible he is hiding while formulating a defense with his Wolf co-conspirators, but it is also possible he just had a Sunday lunch to get to, or is running some errands or any of the thousands of other ways real life can make checking the Mafia thread not the highest priority. An hour's absence shouldn't ever be taken as evidence for anything.
Why did you think that things were such a slam dunk for who to lynch next based on how Flux flipped?
It is a pretty loose observation, I admit.
I actually want to hear Style's opinion on Flux's original question. It doesn't sit right with me that he deflected it so harshly, especially because it's not much more harsh than what Flux asked me earlier.
Andodalf
Banned
Because I saw Darryl as a the de facto leader of the town if right, and a de facto enemy of the state if wrong. I was probably a little hasty.
That response was so weak, the poor chap got banned.
Neither of those outcomes were dead certain based on Flux's flip, because life isn't a Star Wars movie, it's not clear cut.
Darryl would have probably a little heat on him the following day if he was wrong about Flux, but it would be foolish to assume he's a scum of the earth dancer of Scum Club just because he stuck his neck out and tried to get a reaction out of someone. That's a town move, scum will rarely do that, even more unlikely to do it on D1.
GreatLord Tiger
Member
Why would you pick now to get banned.
CornBurrito
Member
Pro tip: just don't post anywhere else on the site while playing mafia.
Terrabyte20xx
Junior Wrestlemania XXX Champion
Actually this made think...
Why did everyone dogpiled styles when andodalf was easily just as suspicious?
They both are, which is why they're currently both being targeted.
Terrabyte20xx
Junior Wrestlemania XXX Champion
Wait, just double checked the vote tally, and has more than styles...
Why did it feel like the opposite?
Why did it feel like the opposite?
CornBurrito
Member
Who just eats spinach leaves and hot sauce.
CornBurrito
Member
My guess would be perma or a long time. Bish gave him "1 hour" to post a source that a Black Student Union refused to accept Whites.
well this can only end well.
Well. You have enough to decide if you want to lynch him or not regardless of his sudden ban. I'll replace him if he survives the day, but not before then. Same for Rolanderson.
A possible explanation is that Style is a wolf and despite the stronger evidence/pressure against him, his wolf buddies would rather lynch Ando who is a villager.
"wolf buddies"
I have no friends. *forever alone*
Also, a real bummer Ando got banned, going to mess the game up. :/
... I'm lost now. Are you trying to get lynched?
Nah, I lost my cool. It's pretty agitating to get a lot of votes when you aren't a scum. >:T
What do you think of Andodalf?
Terrabyte20xx
Junior Wrestlemania XXX Champion
So... Do we want to Lynch ando, or wait for replacement?
If we decide to wait, who do we Lynch?
I ask this as he was the front runner in terms of votes.
GreatLord Tiger
Member
So Darrly, you gonna remain voting on flux?
Well, if he was a werewolf, he'll still be replaced by a werewolf.
Modkill: Andodalf
He's ordinary villager. It's simply not fair to the game in general if he gets a bye at the last minute due to this ban. It's also a Bish ban, so I doubt it's shorter than a week.
Don't take this to mean that Rolanderson is anything special, and thus protected from my whims. He technically met his posting requirement and may yet show up. Possible issue vs a definite issue.
Majority is now 11.
Don't start none, won't be none.
He's ordinary villager. It's simply not fair to the game in general if he gets a bye at the last minute due to this ban. It's also a Bish ban, so I doubt it's shorter than a week.
Don't take this to mean that Rolanderson is anything special, and thus protected from my whims. He technically met his posting requirement and may yet show up. Possible issue vs a definite issue.
Majority is now 11.
Don't start none, won't be none.
I honestly thought you were in cahoots since he was following your lead from the get go. But I don't know, he seems to just be a confused newcomer like me now. He threw his votes on whoever was infamous.
Oh snap.
But, huh? I suppose there's an additional 24 hours missing here, or I'm misreading it.
But, huh? I suppose there's an additional 24 hours missing here, or I'm misreading it.
Oh wait, the deadline for Rolanderson to post. I see.
Convenient that you posted this right after the modkill, but alright.
Convenient that you posted this right after the modkill, but alright.
Yes. Flux is absolutely scum. It's almost hilarious to watch him dance.
I've lightened up on RNH.
Leaning town:
Timeaisis
Batsnacks
CB
Aldo
Leaning neutral:
RNH
QB
Leaning scum:
Cabot
Xam
Scum:
Ultron
Flux
What do you think of Style?
Sorry, I am bad at math and telling time apparently.
Well, at least you didn't almost ended the day at the wrong time because you can't tell the time like our moderator!
You and a few others apparently want him evicted for idiotic reasons, just like Aldo.
But see, whatever time the mods end the day IS the right time, cause fuck you guys, I'm the captain now.
Why do people always forget me. o|-<