Support NeoGAF

[Swamped]

VOTE: Cabot

Two reasons:

1. He somehow invaded my head and stole my idea for my next D1 gambit. I was going to post solely in rhyming couplets D1.

2. He's not doing an RNG vote because Splinter says so. Why, you scared of him or something?

 

[cabot]

No, I'm still angry at him for the end of MGS and ONUW 8.

 

[Swamped]

We win when all threats are eliminated. There is definitely some evil neutral shenanigans going on, possibly SK (serial killer)

 

[ultron87]

Hi, I'm a random town sleepwalker. I visit someone at random each night but it doesn't do anything and I don't even get to know who I visited. So it just throws off investigative roles. I'm sorry.

 

[cabot]

I'm supposed to listen to Sheriff Bigby?

 

[CornBurrito]

holy shit did I somehow possess you to type that?

That's such a me response.


So, we can assume there's at least 5 mafia right?

We had four and that was with 22 players.

Is six an option? So much scum.

This game has like 29 players? I think for certain there's probably 5-6 scum.

 

[cabot]

Hi, I'm a random town sleepwalker. I visit someone at random each night but it doesn't do anything and I don't even get to know who I visited. So it just throws off investigative roles. I'm sorry.

well that's a downgrade and a half. Was it necessary to insta-claim?

 

[Darryl]

We win when all threats are eliminated. There is definitely some evil neutral shenanigans going on, possibly SK (serial killer)

Yea to speed up the game, no doubt

 

[CzarTim]

pls rng vote me

 

[*Splinter]

hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha

I'M HILARIOUS.

VOTE: *Splinter

This is not random. This is because I hate you.

Unless you can tell me what the second haiku is from in my first post, then I'll consider loving you.

Reasonable, but predictable enough that I can't glean much from it, unfortunately

 

[Swamped]

No, I'm still angry at him for the end of MGS and ONUW 8.

Fair enough lol. But point 1 still stands.

 

[Xamtheking]

well that's a downgrade and a half. Was it necessary to insta-claim?

It could seem mighty suspicious if you went to someone's house, and that someone was also visited by a killing role the same night, and that someone died.
Additionally, I also am a Sleepwalker. Somnambulism FTW

 

[CornBurrito]

Yea to speed up the game, no doubt

Darryl had a dog avatar when he was town last game.

Now he has a cat avatar. Cats are the opposite of dogs. Therefore his alignment is the opposite of last game.

 

[ultron87]

well that's a downgrade and a half. Was it necessary to insta-claim?

Yeah, same principle as being a Miller.

 

[cabot]

two sleepwalkers?

oh god its ONUW all over again, please no.

 

[Darryl]

Do we think a game as large as this would have a town cop or mafia cop? What do you think bats?

My gut reaction is that Ultron is lying

 

[Septimus Prime]

Hi, I'm a random town sleepwalker. I visit someone at random each night but it doesn't do anything and I don't even get to know who I visited. So it just throws off investigative roles. I'm sorry.

That sounds like a pretty shitty power.

well that's a downgrade and a half. Was it necessary to insta-claim?

It makes sense to do it if what he says is true. That way, if he turns up on a tracker's results, we won't mistakenly think he's some power role.

On the other hand, if he is a power role and lied about his role claim, then that gives him impunity to target whomever he wants.

 

[Xamtheking]

Do we think a game as large as this would have a town cop or mafia cop? What do you think bats?

My gut reaction is that Ultron is lying

That sounds like a pretty shitty power.


It makes sense to do it if what he says is true. That way, if he turns up on a tracker's results, we won't mistakenly think he's some power role.

On the other hand, if he is a power role and lied about his role claim, then that gives him impunity to target whomever he wants.

As a Sleepwalker, he said the exact same thing my role PM said.
Either Palmer literally sent Ultron the role list, or Ultron is a Sleepwalker

 

[Swamped]

So we can start this game a little differently than usual.

Does anyone have a burning desire to be deputized?

Also two sleepwalkers, lol. Guess I'll take that at face value for now.

 

[cabot]

Do we think a game as large as this would have a town cop or mafia cop? What do you think bats?

My gut reaction is that Ultron is lying

Remember there was no cop in the reveal list before, Palmer might just like no cops.

There were trackers.

 

[Deleted member 231381]

Dogs, you say?

I'm out.

 

[Style]

Yea we survived night repeat start.
I look forward to playing with all of you.

I hope we are still secretly best buds. :>

 

[cabot]

So we can start this game a little differently than usual.

Does anyone have a burning desire to be deputized?

Also two sleepwalkers, lol. Guess I'll take that at face value for now.

Is this a not-alliance alliance thing?

swamped...swamped please.

 

[Rats Off To Ya]

Interesting. Two sleepwalker claims right off the bat.

I get why you guys claimed, but if you're telling the truth, you've now narrowed down the wolves' selection of juicy targets. Eh.

 

[cabot]

Interesting. Two sleepwalker claims right off the bat.

I get why you guys claimed, but if you're telling the truth, you've now narrowed down the wolves' selection of juicy targets. Eh.

This is the side I was coming from.

Sure sleepwalkers are a pain for investigations but is it worth narrowing down the list for scum this early?

 

[Drop]

Yea to speed up the game, no doubt

I agree, considering the size of the game that's likely.

Also, like others have mentioned there are probably 5 or 6 wolves.

 

[Rats Off To Ya]

Also, with sleepwalker roles, it's not unlikely that scum has a motion detector. And now you guys have wasted your role's utility. Great job.

 

[CrimsonFist]

Since we've got more players, I'd assume that there's more roles in play too, since it was a hurried start, might make sense if there's more duplicates too, so I guess there's no reason to doubt the sleepwalker claims for now.

 

[ultron87]

Or did I?

*wavey hands*

 

[Xamtheking]

Also, with sleepwalker roles, it's not unlikely that scum has a motion detector. And now you guys have wasted your role's utility. Great job.

I'd rather die by the hands of scum than by a town lynch

 

[cabot]

Or did I?

*wavey hands*

Well, you've certainly linked you and Xam together currently, like linked sausages.

Or the human centipede.

.....Or the WOLFIE CENTIPEDE

 

[Rats Off To Ya]

Or did I?

*wavey hands*

Well, I considered this, but didn't want to say it. But now you've said it, so I don't know what to think. I find both of you suspect right off the bat.

 

[CzarTim]

Both times we've had sleepwalkers, it's been to confuse scum not town.

 

[cabot]

I'd rather die by the hands of scum than by a town lynch

funny you didn't seem to have much of a problem with the opposite before.

Well at least it's not going to be a boring day.

 

[Rats Off To Ya]

I'd rather die by the hands of scum than by a town lynch

Then you should have said nothing and let them think you have a power.

 

[Lollipop Dave]

My name is Dave and I'm a friendly Baker.

As Highland Sheep War veteran, I was relocated here 5 years ago, I live by the windfall up on the hill. During the weekends I enjoy long strolls in the park, a good game of table tennis and catching up on the Eastenders omnibus.

Likes:
Milkman
Taxidermy
Custard

Dislikes:
Heartbeat
Porridge
Boys in my yard

 

[Drop]

Interesting. Two sleepwalker claims right off the bat.

I get why you guys claimed, but if you're telling the truth, you've now narrowed down the wolves' selection of juicy targets. Eh.

And that's also what I was thinking, I'm not sure it was a good idea, but what's done is done.

Also, I have no intention of deputizing anyone this early, but I think no one had a doubt about that.

 

[CornBurrito]

Lets say we believe there are two sleep walkers.

My guess is:

1. Both are town aligned, and this is to make investigatory roles weaker. Except that downside is easy to work around. Unless the investigator somehow can only see 1 person max, with priority given to the sleepwalker.


2. Opposite alignments. One is town, the other mafia. Not sure why mafia would be given a sleepwalker role though.

3. One or both are lying. If town, I see no reason for them to both lie. If mafia... that's just an absurd gambit. Unless one is town and one is mafia. In which case Ultron is town and Xamtheking is mafia, because Xam is backing up Ultron's claim which a townie wouldn't do.

 

[Fireblend]

So there's 29 of us, probably 5 or more of which are mafia, and 2 duplicate role claims so far?

Oh boy.

 

[cabot]

My name is Dave and I'm a friendly Baker.

As Highland Sheep War veteran, I was relocated here 5 years ago, I live by the windfall up on the hill. During the weekends I enjoy long strolls in the park, a good game of table tennis and catching up on the Eastenders omnibus.

Likes:
Milkman
Taxidermy
Custard

Dislikes:
Heartbeat
Porridge
Boys in my yard

Milkman as in the job title or the Aphex Twin song?

I would like some milk from the Milkman's wife's tits.

 

[CornBurrito]

I'd rather die by the hands of scum than by a town lynch

Literally nobody was voting for Ultron yet.

 

[cabot]

So there's 29 of us, probably 5 or more of which are mafia, and 2 duplicate role claims so far?

Oh boy.

I actually think the most mind shattering event we've had so far is a Septimus Prime post that actually makes some logical sense.

But I digress. Happy Thanksgiving, Septimus!

 

[ultron87]

Well, you've certainly linked you and Xam together currently, like linked sausages.

Or the human centipede.

.....Or the WOLFIE CENTIPEDE

Hey, I did it first. Xam just jumped on my coattails. Not my problem.

 

[Rats Off To Ya]

My gut tells me, unless another target presents itself, that I'd be okay with testing one of our claimed sleepwalkers today.

 

[Drop]

My gut tells me, unless another target presents itself, that I'd be okay with testing one of our claimed sleepwalkers today.

And how would you go about doing that?

 

[Xamtheking]

Literally nobody was voting for Ultron yet.

How did I imply anything of that sort
If there happened to be a case of mistaken identity and a murder, I don't think people would believe my role claim then.

 

[Lollipop Dave]

Milkman as in the job title or the Aphex Twin song?

I would like some milk from the Milkman's wife's tits.

Both. Sorta, Aphex Twin is thr milkman, it's the towns best kept secret.

 

[*Splinter]

I'll trust the sleepwalkers. Xam mentioning role text specifically makes me think it's either true or a planned gambit, and it would be really weird for them to risk 2 scum together right off the bat.

Speaking of day 1 gambits...

...nah nevermind, not just yet



CzarTim

Your thoughts on the sleepwalker claims? True or false? Good or bad play?

 

[Septimus Prime]

I actually think the most mind shattering event we've had so far is a Septimus Prime post that actually makes some logical sense.

But I digress. Happy Thanksgiving, Septimus!

Awww, yeah!

Happy Thanksgiving!

 

[Rats Off To Ya]

And how would you go about doing that?

A noose would be involved.